Chapter X · The general theory of the logarithmic, exponential and circular functions
The power series for exp z
The series 1 + z + z²/2! + … converges to exp z for every complex z; two proofs, one of which needs nothing about the series for sine and cosine.
Why this matters
We now have two candidates for “ to the power ” when is complex. One is , obtained by inverting the logarithm. The other is the sum of the series , which converges for every complex (§198) and equals when is real (§219). §242 proves they are the same function. Many modern books start from the series; Hardy’s order shows that the series is a theorem about a function already known.
The idea
Draw the partial sums in the Argand diagram. Each new term is a step from to : its direction turns by from one step to the next (multiplying by turns by ), and its length is multiplied by , which eventually becomes small. So the partial sums form a polygonal spiral whose sides first grow, as long as , then shrink rapidly, and the spiral closes in on a point. The theorem says that point is .
Try this. Drag to (on the imaginary axis, at height about ) and increase the number of terms from to . Then drag further out, to modulus about , and see how many terms are needed. Try a negative real as well.
- z (drag it)
- partial sums sₖ, one side per term
- the sum
What to notice
At the polygon turns a right angle at every vertex and spirals in to : Euler's . The sides grow while and shrink after that; once is a few times the partial sums are indistinguishable from the sum. For negative real the polygon zigzags along the real axis, overshooting in both directions, because the terms alternate in sign.
Precise statements
For every complex ,
the series being absolutely convergent.
Write for the sum of the series. The proof rests on one property of that comes straight from the series.
For all complex , : .
Proofs
Multiply the two absolutely convergent series term by term (§202), collect the terms of total degree , and recognise the binomial expansion of .
Absolute convergence
converges for every (ratio test: ), so both series are absolutely convergent and their product may be formed as a Cauchy product.
Collect terms of degree
The terms of degree in are .
Add up
So .
Split and use the functional equation: . The real factor is by Chapter IX. For the imaginary factor, separate the series into real and imaginary parts and recognise the series for and .
Split
By the lemma, .
The real factor
For real , (§219).
The imaginary factor
The powers of cycle through . Grouping the real and imaginary terms (allowed, since the series converges absolutely), , by the power series for the real cosine and sine (§152).
Conclude
by §233.
Hardy adds a second proof that avoids the sine and cosine series and uses only differentiation. It is worth knowing because the same pattern (show a quotient has zero derivative) recurs everywhere.
Put for real . The functional equation shows , the differential equation satisfied by . Then show that has derivative zero, so it is constant, equal to its value at .
A difference quotient
For real , , and .
The error term is small
for , so as . Hence is differentiable and .
A quotient with zero derivative
Let . By the product rule, .
Conclude
The real and imaginary parts of have zero derivative, so they are constant (mean value theorem). Since , , and . As before, .
Worked examples and exercises
Use the series to show that and , and estimate how many terms of the series give to within .
Hint
Solution
By the theorem, and . For the tail: if , then each term after is at most half the previous one in modulus, so the error after the term in is at most . With : gives ; gives . So the terms up to (thirteen terms) suffice; the explorer shows the polygon is indistinguishable from by then.
Show that .
Hint
Solution
By the theorem with in place of , . Now , so by the addition theorem. Taking real parts for real gives .
Show that and for every complex .
Hint
Solution
. Similarly . Finally . (The first inequality is also clear from .)
Let and be complex and real. Show that .
Hint
Solution
, and , which tends to as because the bracket differs from by at most (previous exercise). This is the rule used in §246.
Check yourself
The series converges for every complex , and its sum is never .
True. It converges absolutely everywhere (ratio ), and by the theorem its sum is , whose modulus is positive. (From the series alone: .)
In the polygon of partial sums for , the side added at step is . When do the sides start to get shorter?
. While this ratio exceeds and the sides grow; afterwards they shrink faster and faster. The series converges for every ; large only delays the shrinking. The amplitude controls the turning of the sides, not their length.
In the first proof, what is the functional equation used for?
Convergence comes from the ratio test. The functional equation splits the problem into two known cases: (Chapter IX) and (the real series for sine and cosine).
Hardy’s language
Summary
- for every complex ; the series converges absolutely.
- The key step is , from multiplying series and the binomial theorem.
- First proof: . Second proof: , and is constant.
- The partial sums form a spiralling polygon; its sides grow until and then shrink factorially.