Chapter X · The general theory of the logarithmic, exponential and circular functions
Problems: Miscellaneous Examples on Chapter X
Ten of Hardy's Miscellaneous Examples on complex logarithms, exponentials and circular functions, with graded hints and full solutions.
These problems are chosen for variety: computing many-valued expressions, solving transcendental equations in the complex plane, limits, mappings, level curves, trigonometric series and an integral. Hardy’s statements are restated compactly; the numbering is his. In every problem, say whether each logarithm or power is a principal value or the general value. Try each one before opening the hints, and open the hints one at a time.
Computing with many values
Show that the real parts of the values of are , any integer. (Here is the principal value and the power is the general value.)
Hint
Hint
Solution
. The real part is and the imaginary part . So the values are , and their real parts are as stated. The principal value () has real part (a numerical check of the principal value gives ).
Let be real and non-zero. How does behave as approaches along the positive real axis? Along the negative real axis? (Principal values, then general values.)
Hint
Hint
Solution
For : , a point of the unit circle. As , , so goes round and round the unit circle infinitely often; its real and imaginary parts oscillate finitely between and , and tends to no limit.
For : , so : the same behaviour on the circle of radius .
General values: (or ), so the other values move round circles of radius (or ) in the same way.
Equations in the complex plane
Let , , be real with . Show that the solutions of are
where is any odd integer if and any even integer if , and , .
Hint
Hint
Solution
The addition formula holds for complex , so , and the equation is , with because .
By Examples XCVI, 8: if (that is, ), ; if (), . In both cases . So with even when and odd when . There are no real solutions, as expected, since for real .
Let be real. Determine the number and approximate positions of the roots of .
Hint
Hint
Hint
Solution
With (positive except at the poles of on the real axis), the equation splits into and .
No roots off the axes. If , and , dividing gives . But for real , while for real (compare the power series term by term). Contradiction. (If the equation is , whose roots are real.) So or .
Real roots (): . is always a root. The line meets every branch of for large , so there are infinitely many real roots; for large there is one near , just before or after it according to the sign of (Examples XVII, 4).
Imaginary roots (): , so the equation is . The function is even, equals at , and decreases to as (its values lie in ). So there is a pair of non-zero roots exactly when , and none when or .
Conclusion: infinitely many real roots always; in addition two purely imaginary roots when ; no other complex roots.
Limits and mappings
Show that if as , then .
Hint
Hint
Let with . Show that (i) the principal value maps the whole -plane (without ) onto the strip ; (ii) a straight line in the -plane corresponds to an equiangular spiral in the -plane (or, in degenerate cases, a circle or a ray).
Hint
Hint
Solution
(i) . The principal logarithm has imaginary part in , so has , and each corresponds to exactly one such . Other values of give the other strips .
(ii) On the line, and , where is a continuously varying amplitude. If , eliminating gives , i.e. : an equiangular spiral, cutting each radius at the constant angle (since ). If (horizontal line), is constant: a ray. If (vertical line), is constant: a circle, covered infinitely often. This is the same picture as the values of , which lie on the image of a line under .
Level curves
Sketch the level curves for . Then check your sketch with the figure below.
Hint
Hint
Solution
On the real axis, increases from to on , and on rises from (at ) to (at ) and falls back to (at ).
- : the level set meets the real axis in three points: one in , one in , one in . The first two lie on a small closed oval round the zero (close to the circle when is small). The third lies on an open curve to the left of , symmetric in the real axis, whose two branches go off to infinity with as .
- : the oval and the open curve meet at , a double point where .
- : a single curve crossing the real axis once, at a positive , and opening out to the left.
As increases the curves move to the right on the right side, since grows rapidly with .
Try this. Select and move the level through . Then look at , and (Hardy's Figs. 56–59).
- Hardy’s levels k = 0.1, 0.2, 0.37, 0.6, 1, 2, 4
- your level k
- zeros (|f| = 0)
- a point z (drag it)
What to notice
For the oval round and the open curve on the left join at when . In each family the shape changes exactly at levels through a point where the derivative vanishes.
Series and integrals
Prove that, for ,
and find the sums for all other for which the series converge.
Hint
Hint
Solution
Adding the series for and and halving gives , valid on except at .
With , : with and amplitude ; and with and amplitude . Both amplitudes are principal, so
Equating real and imaginary parts gives both formulae.
Other : replacing by changes to , and the series has only odd powers, so both sums change sign. Since , the first formula holds for every that is not a multiple of (where and the cosine series diverges). The sine series is for , for , and at multiples of , where every term vanishes: a square wave.
Let and be real. Show that , and deduce the values of and .
Hint
Hint
Solution
By the derivative rule, (integrate real and imaginary parts). Since , the integral converges to .
Now . Equating real and imaginary parts: and , the results of Examples LXXXVIII, 6 obtained in one stroke.
Let , and suppose neither nor is real. Prove that
each logarithm having its principal value. Verify the result when , , .
Hint
Hint
Hint
Solution
Antiderivative. For real , has constant non-zero imaginary part , so it stays in the open upper or lower half-plane, where the principal amplitude is a continuous, differentiable function. As in §231, . Similarly for . Hence, by partial fractions,
Limit at infinity. As , , and both principal amplitudes tend to (a point with fixed imaginary part and real part has amplitude ). So .
Result. The integral is .
Check. , : the integrand is , with integral . The formula gives , , so . ✓
(If or is real and negative, stays on the positive real axis and the formula still holds; if one is real and positive or zero, the integrand has a pole on the path (or at its end-point ) and the integral does not exist as it stands. This is the “discuss” part of Hardy’s problem.)