a^ζ = exp(ζ Log a) for any complex a ≠ 0 and ζ; its values lie on an equiangular spiral, there are infinitely many unless ζ is real and rational, and i^i is a sequence of real numbers.
What could 2i, (1+i)2 or ii possibly mean? Elementary algebra defines aζ for rational ζ as roots of powers, and Chapter IX extended this to real ζ and positive a by aζ=eζloga. §235 gives one definition covering every non-zero a and every complex ζ, checks that it agrees with all the old ones, and finds the price: the power is in general infinitely many-valued, because the logarithm in its definition is.
The idea
Copy the real formula aζ=eζloga, but with the general logarithm: aζ=exp(ζLoga). Because Loga has the values logσ+i(ψ+2mπ), one for each integer m, the numbers ζLoga are
ζlogσ+iζψ+2mπiζ,m=0,±1,±2,…,
equally spaced points on a straight line, a step 2πiζ apart. Each of them gives a value of aζ when we apply exp. Two of them give the same value only if they differ by a multiple of 2πi, and that is rare. So we expect infinitely many values, lying on the image under exp of a straight line. That image is an equiangular spiral.
ExploreAll the values of a^ζ
Try this.Start with 20.3+0.1i. On the left are the numbers ζLoga for m=−M,…,M; on the right their exponentials, the values of aζ. Change Imζ to 0, then try Reζ=0. Finally pick the examples ii, (−1)1/3, 22 and (1+i)1+i from the menu (for the last, consecutive moduli differ by a factor e2π≈535, so use the zoom).
aζ=exp(ζLoga),Loga=logσ+i(ψ+2mπ)
the numbers ζ Log a (one for each m)
ReIm
their exponentials: the values of a^ζ
ReIm
principal value (m = 0)
other values, m = −M … M
the line and its image under exp
a=2,ζ=0.3+0.1i. Principal value 1.228+0.08527i; m = 1 gives −0.2457+0.6091i, m = −1 gives −0.5594−2.239i. 5 of the 7 values shown fit in the window. The moduli form a geometric progression and the amplitudes an arithmetic one: an equiangular spiral.
What to notice
The left-hand points are always equally spaced on a line, and the right-hand points on its image: an equiangular spiral, with the moduli in geometric progression. When ζ is real the line is vertical and the spiral becomes a circle; for (−1)1/3 the points on the circle repeat after three steps (the three cube roots), for 22 they never repeat. When ζ is purely imaginary the spiral becomes a ray: every value of ii is a positive real number.
Precise statements
Throughout, a=σ(cosψ+isinψ) with σ=∣a∣>0 and −π<ψ≤π, and ζ=ξ+iη.
DefinitionThe general powerHardy: §235
For a=0 and any complex ζ,
aζ=exp(ζLoga),
where Loga is any value of the logarithm of a. Each value of Loga gives a value of aζ. The principal value of aζ is exp(ζloga), given by the principal logarithm.
TheoremConsistency with the earlier definitionsHardy: §235
(1) If a>0 and ζ is real, the principal value of aζ is the real power eζloga of Chapter IX. (2) If ζ=p/q is rational, the values of aζ are exactly the q values of ap/q found in §48.
m any integer; the principal value is the case m=0.
TheoremHow many values?Hardy: §236
aζ has infinitely many distinct values unless ζ is real and rational. If ζ=p/q in lowest terms (q>0), it has exactly q values.
CorollaryDe Moivre generalisedHardy: §236
If ζ is real and −π<ψ≤π, the principal value of (cosψ+isinψ)ζ is cosζψ+isinζψ.
The corollary needs the restriction on ψ: for ψ=3π/2 (not principal), (cosψ+isinψ)1/2 has principal value (−i)1/2=cos41π−isin41π, not cos43π+isin43π.
Proofs
ProofThe general value of a^ζ
Strategy
Multiply out ζLoga into real and imaginary parts, then apply the formula exp(L+iM)=eL(cosM+isinM) of §233.
(ξ+iη){logσ+i(ψ+2mπ)}=L+iM with L=ξlogσ−η(ψ+2mπ) and M=ηlogσ+ξ(ψ+2mπ).
Exponentiate
aζ=exp(L+iM)=eL(cosM+isinM), which is the formula. Putting m=0 uses the principal logarithm.
∎
ProofHow many values?
Strategy
Compare two values, with integers m=n. If η=0 their moduli differ. If η=0 the moduli agree, and the values coincide exactly when the amplitudes differ by a multiple of 2π, which is a question about whether ξ is rational.
The case η=0
The modulus eξlogσ−η(ψ+2mπ) is a strictly monotone function of m, so different m give different values: infinitely many.
The case η=0: when do two values agree?
Now every value has modulus σξ, and the values for m and n have amplitudes ξ(ψ+2mπ) and ξ(ψ+2nπ). They are equal if and only if 2πξ(m−n)=2πk for some integer k, that is, ξ(m−n) is an integer.
ξ irrational
Then ξ(m−n) is never an integer for m=n: all values are distinct, infinitely many.
ξ=p/q in lowest terms
p(m−n)/q is an integer exactly when q divides m−n (since p and q have no common factor). So the values repeat with period q in m, and m=0,1,…,q−1 give exactly q distinct values. (For ξ=0, q=1: the single value 1.)
∎
ProofConsistency (2): rational exponents
Strategy
Compare the values just found with the q-th roots of ap from Chapter III.
The values for ζ=p/q
With η=0, ξ=p/q: ap/q=σp/q{cosqp(ψ+2mπ)+isinqp(ψ+2mπ)}.
They are q-th roots of ap
Raising to the power q by De Moivre: modulus σp, amplitude pψ+2pmπ, i.e. ap. There are q distinct such numbers (previous proof), and ap has exactly q distinct q-th roots (§48), so the two sets coincide.
∎
Worked examples and exercises
Exercisei to the i●○○Hardy: Examples XCV, 1
Find all values of ii, and its principal value.
Hint
Logi=(2k+21)πi.
Solution
ii=exp(iLogi)=exp{i⋅(2k+21)πi}=exp{−(2k+21)π}=e−(2k+21)π, k any integer. Every value is real and positive. The principal value (k=0) is e−π/2≈0.2079. The other values are this number multiplied by e−2kπ, ranging from enormous (k very negative) to tiny.
ExerciseThe values lie on an equiangular spiral●●○Hardy: Examples XCV, 2
Writing a value of aζ as r(cosθ+isinθ) with θ=ηlogσ+ξ(ψ+2mπ) (and ξ=0), show that all the values lie on the spiral r=σ(ξ2+η2)/ξe−ηθ/ξ, and that the angle between this spiral and its radius vector does not depend on a.
Hint
Eliminate s=ψ+2mπ between logr=ξlogσ−ηs and θ=ηlogσ+ξs.
Solution
From θ=ηlogσ+ξs we get s=(θ−ηlogσ)/ξ. Then logr=ξlogσ−η(θ−ηlogσ)/ξ=ξξ2+η2logσ−ξηθ, which is the stated spiral. For a curve r=Ce−ηθ/ξ, r1dθdr=−η/ξ, and this is the cotangent of the angle between the tangent and the radius vector. It depends only on ζ, not on a. (Consecutive values differ by the fixed factor exp(2πiζ), so they are the vertices of an equiangular polygon inscribed in the spiral.)
ExerciseThe many values of e^ζ●●○Hardy: Examples XCV, 3
Show that the general value of eζ (with a=e in the definition) is eξ−2mπη{cos(η+2mπξ)+isin(η+2mπξ)}, and that its principal value is expζ. What are the values of e1/2?
Hint
Loge=1+2mπi, so σ=e, ψ=0.
Solution
ζLoge=(ξ+iη)(1+2mπi)=(ξ−2mπη)+i(η+2mπξ); exponentiate. With m=0 this is eξ(cosη+isinη)=expζ. For ζ=21: e1/2{cosmπ+isinmπ}=±e: the two square roots of e, of which the principal one is the positive one. This is why Hardy keeps the symbol expζ for the one-valued function.
ExerciseAdding exponents●●○Hardy: Examples XCV, 7
Show that every value of aζ+ζ′ is a value of aζ×aζ′, but not conversely in general; and that the equation is true for principal values.
Hint
On the left one logarithm is used; on the right two, possibly different, ones.
Solution
A value of the product aζaζ′ is exp{ζ(loga+2mπi)}exp{ζ′(loga+2nπi)}=exp{(ζ+ζ′)loga+2πi(mζ+nζ′)}, with m and n chosen independently. A value of aζ+ζ′ is exp{(ζ+ζ′)(loga+2kπi)}, which is the case m=n=k of the product. So every value of aζ+ζ′ is a value of aζaζ′.
With m=n the product generally has new values. Take a=1, ζ=ζ′=21: 11/2=±1, so the product 11/2×11/2 has the values 1 and −1, while 11=1 has only the value 1. So −1 is a value of the product but not of aζ+ζ′: the equation is not completely true. For principal values take m=n=k=0: both sides are exp{(ζ+ζ′)loga}.
ExerciseFind the fallacy●●○Hardy: Examples XCV, 11
“Since e2mπi=e2nπi=1 for all integers m, n, raising to the power i gives e−2mπ=e−2nπ.” What is wrong?
Hint
Which values of 1i and of (e2mπi)i are being compared?
Solution
The rule (ew)i=ewi silently picks one value of a many-valued power. Here 1i=exp(iLog1)=exp(i⋅2kπi)=e−2kπ: the number 1 raised to the power i has all the values e−2kπ. Raising both sides of e2mπi=e2nπi to the power i produces the same set of values on each side; the argument then wrongly equates one particular value from the left (e−2mπ, using the logarithm 2mπi) with one particular value from the right (e−2nπ, using 2nπi). An equation between many-valued expressions does not let you choose values independently on the two sides.
Check yourself
Check yourselfEnter a number
What is the principal value of ii (to four decimals)?
Why
logi=21πi, so the principal value is exp(i⋅21πi)=e−π/2≈0.2079.
Check yourselfChoose one
What is the principal value of (−8)1/3, in Hardy’s sense?
Why
log(−8)=log8+πi, so the principal value is exp{31(log8+πi)}=2(cos31π+isin31π)=1+i3. The real cube root −2 is one of the three values (take m=1), but not the principal one. School algebra’s choice of −2 is a different convention.
Check yourselfChoose one
How many distinct values has aζ when a=2 and ζ=46?
Why
Reduce first: 46=23 in lowest terms, so there are q=2 values, ±22. Counting by the unreduced denominator 4 would be wrong: the values for m and m+2 already coincide.
Check yourselfTrue or false?
Every value of ii is a real number.
Why
True: they are e−(2k+21)π. In the explorer, ii is the case Reζ=0, where the spiral degenerates to a ray, here the positive real axis.
Hardy’s language
Summary
Summary
aζ=exp(ζLoga) for a=0; principal value exp(ζloga).
The numbers ζLoga are equally spaced on a line; the values of aζ lie on its image, an equiangular spiral (a circle if ζ is real, a ray if ζ is imaginary).
Infinitely many values unless ζ is real and rational; exactly q values for ζ=p/q in lowest terms.
ii=e−(2k+21)π, all real; principal value e−π/2.
Identities between powers may hold completely, only for principal values, or neither: always check which.