Chapter X · The general theory of the logarithmic, exponential and circular functions

Sine, cosine and the hyperbolic functions of a complex variable

§§237–240 40 min

cos ζ and sin ζ defined through the exponential, why every trigonometric identity survives, and the surprising new facts — they are unbounded, and cos iy = cosh y.

Why this matters

The sine and cosine of school trigonometry are defined by triangles and angles, which make sense only for real numbers. The formula exp⁡(iη)=cos⁡η+isin⁡η\exp(i\eta) = \cos\eta + i\sin\eta of the last lesson lets us turn this round: express sine and cosine through the exponential, and use that expression as the definition for complex arguments. §§237–240 carries this out. All the familiar identities survive, but some familiar facts do not: ∣sin⁡ζ∣≤1|\sin\zeta| \le 1 is false, and the circular and hyperbolic functions turn out to be the same functions seen along different axes.

The idea

Put ξ=0\xi = 0 in exp⁡(ξ+iη)=eξ(cos⁡η+isin⁡η)\exp(\xi + i\eta) = e^\xi(\cos\eta + i\sin\eta): exp⁡(iη)=cos⁡η+isin⁡η\exp(i\eta) = \cos\eta + i\sin\eta, and with −η-\eta, exp⁡(−iη)=cos⁡η−isin⁡η\exp(-i\eta) = \cos\eta - i\sin\eta. Adding and subtracting,

cos⁡η=12{exp⁡(iη)+exp⁡(−iη)},sin⁡η=−12i{exp⁡(iη)−exp⁡(−iη)}\cos\eta = \tfrac12\{\exp(i\eta) + \exp(-i\eta)\}, \qquad \sin\eta = -\tfrac12 i\{\exp(i\eta) - \exp(-i\eta)\}

for real η\eta. The right-hand sides make sense for every complex number, so we use them to define cos⁡ζ\cos\zeta and sin⁡ζ\sin\zeta for all ζ\zeta. On the real axis nothing changes. Off the real axis, one of exp⁡(iζ)\exp(i\zeta), exp⁡(−iζ)\exp(-i\zeta) has modulus e∣Im⁡ζ∣e^{|\operatorname{Im}\zeta|}, which grows exponentially, so the new functions are large there. The level curves ∣sin⁡ζ∣=k|\sin\zeta| = k show this at a glance; this is Hardy’s Fig. 56, drawn live.

Explore Where is |sin z| small, and where is it large?

Try this. Move the purple level kk from 0.10.1 up to 1010, and drag the ochre point off the real axis to read the values. Then switch to cos⁡z\cos z and to sin⁡z−c\sin z - c with c=0.5c = 0.5 and c=2c = 2.

∣sin⁡z∣=k|\sin z| = k
xy
  • Hardy’s levels k = 0.35, 0.5, 0.71, 1, 1.4, 2, 2.8, 4
  • your level k
  • zeros (|f| = 0)
  • a point z (drag it)
At z=1.2+0.8iz = 1.2 + 0.8i the value is 1.25+0.322i1.25 + 0.322i, of modulus 1.291.29. Small k: small closed curves round the zeros. Large k: the curves leave the window, because the modulus is unbounded.
What to notice

For small kk the curve ∣sin⁡z∣=k|\sin z| = k is a ring of small ovals round the zeros 0,±π,±2π,…0, \pm\pi, \pm2\pi, \dots, all on the real axis. At k=1k = 1 neighbouring ovals touch, and for k>1k > 1 the curves are wavy lines running along the whole axis, moving outwards as kk grows: ∣sin⁡z∣|\sin z| exceeds every bound once you go far enough from the real axis. For sin⁡z−2\sin z - 2 the zeros have left the real axis (Hardy's Fig. 59).

Precise statements

Definition Circular functions of a complex variable Hardy: §238 (1), (2)

For every complex ζ\zeta,

cos⁡ζ=12{exp⁡(iζ)+exp⁡(−iζ)},sin⁡ζ=−12i{exp⁡(iζ)−exp⁡(−iζ)},\cos\zeta = \tfrac12\{\exp(i\zeta) + \exp(-i\zeta)\}, \qquad \sin\zeta = -\tfrac12 i\{\exp(i\zeta) - \exp(-i\zeta)\},

and tan⁡ζ=sin⁡ζ/cos⁡ζ\tan\zeta = \sin\zeta/\cos\zeta, cot⁡ζ=cos⁡ζ/sin⁡ζ\cot\zeta = \cos\zeta/\sin\zeta, sec⁡ζ=1/cos⁡ζ\sec\zeta = 1/\cos\zeta, cosec⁡ζ=1/sin⁡ζ\operatorname{cosec}\zeta = 1/\sin\zeta. For real ζ\zeta these agree with the elementary definitions (§237).

Theorem All identities of elementary trigonometry remain true Hardy: §238 (3)–(6)

cos⁡\cos and sec⁡\sec are even, the other four odd. For all complex ζ\zeta, ζ′\zeta':

cos⁡2ζ+sin⁡2ζ=1,\cos^2\zeta + \sin^2\zeta = 1,cos⁡(ζ+ζ′)=cos⁡ζcos⁡ζ′−sin⁡ζsin⁡ζ′,sin⁡(ζ+ζ′)=sin⁡ζcos⁡ζ′+cos⁡ζsin⁡ζ′,\cos(\zeta + \zeta') = \cos\zeta\cos\zeta' - \sin\zeta\sin\zeta', \qquad \sin(\zeta + \zeta') = \sin\zeta\cos\zeta' + \cos\zeta\sin\zeta',

and cos⁡(ζ+12π)=−sin⁡ζ\cos(\zeta + \tfrac12\pi) = -\sin\zeta, sin⁡(ζ+12π)=cos⁡ζ\sin(\zeta + \tfrac12\pi) = \cos\zeta. Every identity of elementary trigonometry is an algebraic consequence of these, and so holds for complex values too.

Definition Hyperbolic functions of a complex variable Hardy: §239

cosh⁡ζ=12{exp⁡ζ+exp⁡(−ζ)}\cosh\zeta = \tfrac12\{\exp\zeta + \exp(-\zeta)\} and sinh⁡ζ=12{exp⁡ζ−exp⁡(−ζ)}\sinh\zeta = \tfrac12\{\exp\zeta - \exp(-\zeta)\} for every complex ζ\zeta. Then

cos⁡iζ=cosh⁡ζ,sin⁡iζ=isinh⁡ζ,cosh⁡iζ=cos⁡ζ,sinh⁡iζ=isin⁡ζ.\cos i\zeta = \cosh\zeta, \quad \sin i\zeta = i\sinh\zeta, \quad \cosh i\zeta = \cos\zeta, \quad \sinh i\zeta = i\sin\zeta.
Theorem Real and imaginary parts Hardy: §240

For all ξ\xi, η\eta (the interesting case being real ξ\xi, η\eta):

cos⁡(ξ+iη)=cos⁡ξcosh⁡η−isin⁡ξsinh⁡η,sin⁡(ξ+iη)=sin⁡ξcosh⁡η+icos⁡ξsinh⁡η.\cos(\xi + i\eta) = \cos\xi\cosh\eta - i\sin\xi\sinh\eta, \qquad \sin(\xi + i\eta) = \sin\xi\cosh\eta + i\cos\xi\sinh\eta.

Consequently ∣cos⁡(ξ+iη)∣2=cos⁡2ξ+sinh⁡2η|\cos(\xi + i\eta)|^2 = \cos^2\xi + \sinh^2\eta and ∣sin⁡(ξ+iη)∣2=sin⁡2ξ+sinh⁡2η|\sin(\xi + i\eta)|^2 = \sin^2\xi + \sinh^2\eta.

Corollary Zeros, periods and growth

The zeros of sin⁡ζ\sin\zeta are exactly ζ=kπ\zeta = k\pi and those of cos⁡ζ\cos\zeta exactly ζ=(k+12)π\zeta = (k + \tfrac12)\pi, kk an integer: there are no new, non-real zeros. Both functions have period 2π2\pi. On each horizontal line η=\eta = constant they are bounded, but ∣sin⁡ζ∣≥∣sinh⁡η∣|\sin\zeta| \ge |\sinh\eta| and ∣cos⁡ζ∣≥∣sinh⁡η∣|\cos\zeta| \ge |\sinh\eta|, so both tend to infinity as ∣η∣→∞|\eta| \to \infty, uniformly in ξ\xi. In particular neither is bounded in the plane.

Proofs

Proof All identities remain true
Strategy

Put t=exp⁡(iζ)t = \exp(i\zeta). Then exp⁡(−iζ)=1/t\exp(-i\zeta) = 1/t, and cos⁡ζ\cos\zeta, sin⁡ζ\sin\zeta are rational functions of tt. Identities between them become identities between rational functions, checkable by algebra. The addition theorem for exp⁡\exp handles sums of arguments.

Express in terms of tt

cos⁡ζ=12(t+t−1)\cos\zeta = \tfrac12(t + t^{-1}) and sin⁡ζ=−12i(t−t−1)\sin\zeta = -\tfrac12 i(t - t^{-1}). Evenness and oddness: replacing ζ\zeta by −ζ-\zeta replaces tt by 1/t1/t, which fixes t+t−1t + t^{-1} and changes the sign of t−t−1t - t^{-1}.

cos⁡2+sin⁡2=1\cos^2 + \sin^2 = 1

cos⁡2ζ+sin⁡2ζ=14{(t+t−1)2−(t−t−1)2}=14⋅4=1\cos^2\zeta + \sin^2\zeta = \tfrac14\{(t + t^{-1})^2 - (t - t^{-1})^2\} = \tfrac14 \cdot 4 = 1.

The addition formula

With t′=exp⁡(iζ′)t' = \exp(i\zeta'), the addition theorem gives exp⁡{i(ζ+ζ′)}=tt′\exp\{i(\zeta + \zeta')\} = tt', so cos⁡(ζ+ζ′)=12(tt′+1tt′)\cos(\zeta + \zeta') = \tfrac12(tt' + \tfrac{1}{tt'}). On the other hand cos⁡ζcos⁡ζ′−sin⁡ζsin⁡ζ′=14{(t+1t)(t′+1t′)−(t−1t)(t′−1t′)}\cos\zeta\cos\zeta' - \sin\zeta\sin\zeta' = \tfrac14\{(t + \tfrac1t)(t' + \tfrac1{t'}) - (t - \tfrac1t)(t' - \tfrac1{t'})\}. Multiplying out, the terms t/t′t/t' and t′/tt'/t cancel and what is left is 14{2tt′+2/(tt′)}\tfrac14\{2tt' + 2/(tt')\}. The sine formula is proved in the same way.

Quarter periods

exp⁡(12πi)=i\exp(\tfrac12\pi i) = i, so ζ+12π\zeta + \tfrac12\pi corresponds to t↦itt \mapsto it: cos⁡(ζ+12π)=12(it+1it)=12i(t−t−1)=−sin⁡ζ\cos(\zeta + \tfrac12\pi) = \tfrac12(it + \tfrac{1}{it}) = \tfrac12 i(t - t^{-1}) = -\sin\zeta. Similarly for sin⁡\sin.

Everything else

Every identity of elementary trigonometry is derived from these by algebra alone (no appeal to triangles or to the size of angles), so the same derivations work for complex arguments.

Proof Real and imaginary parts, and the zeros
Strategy

Use the addition formula with ζ′=iη\zeta' = i\eta, compute cos⁡iη\cos i\eta and sin⁡iη\sin i\eta from the definitions, then take moduli.

cos⁡iη\cos i\eta and sin⁡iη\sin i\eta

From the definitions, cos⁡iη=12{exp⁡(−η)+exp⁡η}=cosh⁡η\cos i\eta = \tfrac12\{\exp(-\eta) + \exp\eta\} = \cosh\eta and sin⁡iη=−12i{exp⁡(−η)−exp⁡η}=isinh⁡η\sin i\eta = -\tfrac12 i\{\exp(-\eta) - \exp\eta\} = i\sinh\eta.

Addition formula

cos⁡(ξ+iη)=cos⁡ξcos⁡iη−sin⁡ξsin⁡iη=cos⁡ξcosh⁡η−isin⁡ξsinh⁡η\cos(\xi + i\eta) = \cos\xi\cos i\eta - \sin\xi\sin i\eta = \cos\xi\cosh\eta - i\sin\xi\sinh\eta, and likewise sin⁡(ξ+iη)=sin⁡ξcosh⁡η+icos⁡ξsinh⁡η\sin(\xi + i\eta) = \sin\xi\cosh\eta + i\cos\xi\sinh\eta.

Moduli

∣sin⁡(ξ+iη)∣2=sin⁡2ξcosh⁡2η+cos⁡2ξsinh⁡2η=sin⁡2ξ(1+sinh⁡2η)+cos⁡2ξsinh⁡2η=sin⁡2ξ+sinh⁡2η|\sin(\xi + i\eta)|^2 = \sin^2\xi\cosh^2\eta + \cos^2\xi\sinh^2\eta = \sin^2\xi(1 + \sinh^2\eta) + \cos^2\xi\sinh^2\eta = \sin^2\xi + \sinh^2\eta, using cosh⁡2−sinh⁡2=1\cosh^2 - \sinh^2 = 1. The cosine is the same with cos⁡2ξ\cos^2\xi in place of sin⁡2ξ\sin^2\xi.

Zeros

sin⁡ζ=0\sin\zeta = 0 exactly when sin⁡2ξ+sinh⁡2η=0\sin^2\xi + \sinh^2\eta = 0, i.e. sin⁡ξ=0\sin\xi = 0 and sinh⁡η=0\sinh\eta = 0, i.e. ξ=kπ\xi = k\pi and η=0\eta = 0. The cosine is similar.

Growth

∣sin⁡ζ∣2≥sinh⁡2η|\sin\zeta|^2 \ge \sinh^2\eta, and ∣sinh⁡η∣→∞|\sinh\eta| \to \infty as ∣η∣→∞|\eta| \to \infty; the same holds for cos⁡\cos.

The formula cos⁡(ξ+iη)=cos⁡ξcosh⁡η−isin⁡ξsinh⁡η\cos(\xi + i\eta) = \cos\xi\cosh\eta - i\sin\xi\sinh\eta also explains the picture of cos⁡\cos as a mapping: on a horizontal line η=\eta = constant the image point (cos⁡ξcosh⁡η,−sin⁡ξsinh⁡η)(\cos\xi\cosh\eta, -\sin\xi\sinh\eta) runs round an ellipse with semi-axes cosh⁡η\cosh\eta and ∣sinh⁡η∣|\sinh\eta|, and on a vertical line it runs along a hyperbola. All these conics have foci ±1\pm1.

Explore cos maps a grid to confocal ellipses and hyperbolas

Try this. Look at the images of the blue horizontal lines and the ochre vertical lines. Then drag the purple circle so that it surrounds z=12πz = \tfrac12\pi, a zero of cos⁡\cos.

w=cos⁡zw=\cos z
z-plane
xy
w-plane, w = f(z)
uv
  • horizontal lines and their images
  • vertical lines and their images
  • circle (drag centre and rim) and its image
  • w = 0
Grid
Circle: centre 1.571.57, radius 0.60.6 (z = 0 is outside it). Its image winds 1 time round w=0w = 0 (counter-clockwise counts +).
What to notice

Horizontal lines go to ellipses and vertical lines to hyperbolas, all with foci at ±1\pm1 (compare Misc. Examples X, 16). A circle round a single zero of cos⁡\cos has an image winding once round 00; a circle that surrounds no zero has an image that does not wind round 00.

Worked examples and exercises

Exercise When is cos ζ real? ●○○ Hardy: Examples XCVI, 1

Find all ζ=ξ+iη\zeta = \xi + i\eta for which cos⁡ζ\cos\zeta is (i) real, (ii) purely imaginary.

Hint
Im⁡cos⁡ζ=−sin⁡ξsinh⁡η\operatorname{Im}\cos\zeta = -\sin\xi\sinh\eta, Re⁡cos⁡ζ=cos⁡ξcosh⁡η\operatorname{Re}\cos\zeta = \cos\xi\cosh\eta.

Solution

(i) cos⁡ζ\cos\zeta is real when sin⁡ξsinh⁡η=0\sin\xi\sinh\eta = 0: either η=0\eta = 0 (the real axis) or ξ=kπ\xi = k\pi (vertical lines through the multiples of π\pi, where cos⁡ζ=±cosh⁡η\cos\zeta = \pm\cosh\eta). (ii) Purely imaginary (or zero) when cos⁡ξcosh⁡η=0\cos\xi\cosh\eta = 0, i.e. cos⁡ξ=0\cos\xi = 0, ξ=(k+12)π\xi = (k + \tfrac12)\pi, since cosh⁡η≥1\cosh\eta \ge 1. On those vertical lines cos⁡ζ=∓isinh⁡η\cos\zeta = \mp i\sinh\eta.

Exercise Solving cos ζ = α for real α ●●○ Hardy: Examples XCVI, 8

Find all solutions of cos⁡ζ=α\cos\zeta = \alpha for real α\alpha. In particular solve cos⁡ζ=−53\cos\zeta = -\tfrac53.

Hint
Equate real and imaginary parts: cos⁡ξcosh⁡η=α\cos\xi\cosh\eta = \alpha and sin⁡ξsinh⁡η=0\sin\xi\sinh\eta = 0.

Solution

From sin⁡ξsinh⁡η=0\sin\xi\sinh\eta = 0: either η=0\eta = 0 or ξ=mπ\xi = m\pi.

If η=0\eta = 0: cos⁡ξ=α\cos\xi = \alpha, possible only for −1≤α≤1-1 \le \alpha \le 1, giving ζ=2kπ±arccos⁡α\zeta = 2k\pi \pm \arccos\alpha with 0≤arccos⁡α≤π0 \le \arccos\alpha \le \pi.

If ξ=mπ\xi = m\pi: cos⁡ξ=(−1)m\cos\xi = (-1)^m, so cosh⁡η=(−1)mα\cosh\eta = (-1)^m\alpha. Since cosh⁡η≥1\cosh\eta \ge 1 this needs α≥1\alpha \ge 1 with mm even or α≤−1\alpha \le -1 with mm odd; if ∣α∣=1|\alpha| = 1 then η=0\eta = 0 and we are back in the first case. For ∣α∣>1|\alpha| > 1, cosh⁡η=∣α∣\cosh\eta = |\alpha| gives η=±log⁡{∣α∣+α2−1}\eta = \pm\log\{|\alpha| + \sqrt{\alpha^2 - 1}\}. So ζ=2kπ±ilog⁡{α+α2−1}\zeta = 2k\pi \pm i\log\{\alpha + \sqrt{\alpha^2 - 1}\} for α>1\alpha > 1, and ζ=(2k+1)π±ilog⁡{−α+α2−1}\zeta = (2k + 1)\pi \pm i\log\{-\alpha + \sqrt{\alpha^2 - 1}\} for α<−1\alpha < -1.

For α=−53\alpha = -\tfrac53: −α+α2−1=53+43=3-\alpha + \sqrt{\alpha^2 - 1} = \tfrac53 + \tfrac43 = 3, so ζ=(2k+1)π±ilog⁡3\zeta = (2k + 1)\pi \pm i\log 3. Check: cos⁡(π+ilog⁡3)=−cosh⁡log⁡3=−12(3+13)=−53\cos(\pi + i\log 3) = -\cosh\log 3 = -\tfrac12(3 + \tfrac13) = -\tfrac53. ✓

Exercise tan ζ = α has only real roots ●●○ Hardy: Examples XCVI, 12

Show that if α\alpha is real, every solution of tan⁡ζ=α\tan\zeta = \alpha is real.

Hint
tan⁡ζ=α\tan\zeta = \alpha means sin⁡ζ−αcos⁡ζ=0\sin\zeta - \alpha\cos\zeta = 0. Write α=tan⁡β\alpha = \tan\beta with β\beta real.

Solution

Let α=tan⁡β\alpha = \tan\beta with −12π<β<12π-\tfrac12\pi < \beta < \tfrac12\pi. Then tan⁡ζ=α\tan\zeta = \alpha means sin⁡ζcos⁡β−cos⁡ζsin⁡β=0\sin\zeta\cos\beta - \cos\zeta\sin\beta = 0 (multiply by cos⁡ζcos⁡β\cos\zeta\cos\beta, both non-zero at a solution), i.e. sin⁡(ζ−β)=0\sin(\zeta - \beta) = 0. By the corollary the zeros of sin⁡\sin are real, so ζ−β=kπ\zeta - \beta = k\pi and ζ=β+kπ\zeta = \beta + k\pi, all real.

Exercise Behaviour at infinity ●●○ Hardy: Examples XCVI, 16–17

Let ζ→∞\zeta \to \infty along a ray from the origin that is not part of the real axis. Show that ∣cos⁡ζ∣→∞|\cos\zeta| \to \infty and ∣sin⁡ζ∣→∞|\sin\zeta| \to \infty, and that tan⁡ζ→i\tan\zeta \to i if the ray lies in the upper half-plane and tan⁡ζ→−i\tan\zeta \to -i if it lies in the lower half-plane.

Hint
On such a ray ∣η∣→∞|\eta| \to \infty. For tan⁡\tan write it in terms of exp⁡(2iζ)\exp(2i\zeta).

Solution

On a non-horizontal ray, η=ρsin⁡α\eta = \rho\sin\alpha with sin⁡α≠0\sin\alpha \ne 0, so ∣η∣→∞|\eta| \to \infty and ∣cos⁡ζ∣,∣sin⁡ζ∣≥∣sinh⁡η∣→∞|\cos\zeta|, |\sin\zeta| \ge |\sinh\eta| \to \infty.

For tan⁡\tan: tan⁡ζ=sin⁡ζcos⁡ζ=−i exp⁡(iζ)−exp⁡(−iζ)exp⁡(iζ)+exp⁡(−iζ)=−i exp⁡(2iζ)−1exp⁡(2iζ)+1\tan\zeta = \dfrac{\sin\zeta}{\cos\zeta} = -i\,\dfrac{\exp(i\zeta) - \exp(-i\zeta)}{\exp(i\zeta) + \exp(-i\zeta)} = -i\,\dfrac{\exp(2i\zeta) - 1}{\exp(2i\zeta) + 1}. Now ∣exp⁡(2iζ)∣=e−2η|\exp(2i\zeta)| = e^{-2\eta}. In the upper half-plane η→+∞\eta \to +\infty, so exp⁡(2iζ)→0\exp(2i\zeta) \to 0 and tan⁡ζ→−i⋅(−1)=i\tan\zeta \to -i \cdot (-1) = i. In the lower half-plane ∣exp⁡(2iζ)∣→∞|\exp(2i\zeta)| \to \infty, so the fraction tends to 11 and tan⁡ζ→−i\tan\zeta \to -i.

(Hardy’s printed statement of Ex. 17 has the two signs the other way round; the computation above, which a numerical check confirms, e.g. tan⁡(10i)=itanh⁡10≈0.99999999 i\tan(10i) = i\tanh 10 \approx 0.99999999\,i, gives +i+i above the axis.)

Exercise Osborn's rule explained ●○○ Hardy: §239

Use cos⁡iζ=cosh⁡ζ\cos i\zeta = \cosh\zeta and sin⁡iζ=isinh⁡ζ\sin i\zeta = i\sinh\zeta to turn cos⁡2ζ=cos⁡2ζ−sin⁡2ζ\cos 2\zeta = \cos^2\zeta - \sin^2\zeta and sin⁡2ζ=2sin⁡ζcos⁡ζ\sin 2\zeta = 2\sin\zeta\cos\zeta into identities for cosh⁡\cosh and sinh⁡\sinh.

Hint
Replace ζ\zeta by iζi\zeta in each identity.

Solution

cos⁡2iζ=cos⁡2iζ−sin⁡2iζ\cos 2i\zeta = \cos^2 i\zeta - \sin^2 i\zeta becomes cosh⁡2ζ=cosh⁡2ζ−(isinh⁡ζ)2=cosh⁡2ζ+sinh⁡2ζ\cosh 2\zeta = \cosh^2\zeta - (i\sinh\zeta)^2 = \cosh^2\zeta + \sinh^2\zeta. And sin⁡2iζ=2sin⁡iζcos⁡iζ\sin 2i\zeta = 2\sin i\zeta\cos i\zeta becomes isinh⁡2ζ=2isinh⁡ζcosh⁡ζi\sinh 2\zeta = 2i\sinh\zeta\cosh\zeta, i.e. sinh⁡2ζ=2sinh⁡ζcosh⁡ζ\sinh 2\zeta = 2\sinh\zeta\cosh\zeta. The sign change wherever a product of two sines occurs is the old “Osborn’s rule”; here it is simply i2=−1i^2 = -1.

Check yourself

Check yourself True or false?

∣sin⁡ζ∣≤1|\sin\zeta| \le 1 for every complex ζ\zeta.

Why

False. ∣sin⁡(ξ+iη)∣2=sin⁡2ξ+sinh⁡2η|\sin(\xi + i\eta)|^2 = \sin^2\xi + \sinh^2\eta, which is unbounded. For example sin⁡(i)=isinh⁡1≈1.175i\sin(i) = i\sinh 1 \approx 1.175i, of modulus greater than 11. The bound holds only on the real axis.

Check yourself Enter a number

Compute cos⁡i\cos i (it is real).

Why

cos⁡i=12{exp⁡(−1)+exp⁡(1)}=cosh⁡1≈1.5431\cos i = \tfrac12\{\exp(-1) + \exp(1)\} = \cosh 1 \approx 1.5431. Cosine of an imaginary number is the hyperbolic cosine, and it is greater than 11.

Check yourself Choose one

Which statement about the zeros of sin⁡ζ\sin\zeta in the complex plane is correct?

Why

∣sin⁡ζ∣2=sin⁡2ξ+sinh⁡2η|\sin\zeta|^2 = \sin^2\xi + \sinh^2\eta vanishes only when sin⁡ξ=0\sin\xi = 0 and η=0\eta = 0. exp⁡\exp never vanishes, but sin⁡\sin is a difference of exponentials, which vanishes where exp⁡(2iζ)=1\exp(2i\zeta) = 1, i.e. ζ=kπ\zeta = k\pi. The points kπik\pi i are zeros of sinh⁡\sinh, not of sin⁡\sin.

Check yourself Choose one

What is Re⁡cos⁡(ξ+iη)\operatorname{Re}\cos(\xi + i\eta), for real ξ\xi, η\eta?

Why

By the addition formula, cos⁡(ξ+iη)=cos⁡ξcos⁡iη−sin⁡ξsin⁡iη\cos(\xi + i\eta) = \cos\xi\cos i\eta - \sin\xi\sin i\eta, and cos⁡iη=cosh⁡η\cos i\eta = \cosh\eta, sin⁡iη=isinh⁡η\sin i\eta = i\sinh\eta. So the real part is cos⁡ξcosh⁡η\cos\xi\cosh\eta and the imaginary part −sin⁡ξsinh⁡η-\sin\xi\sinh\eta. The last option is cosh⁡(ξ+iη)\cosh(\xi + i\eta)‘s real part.

Hardy’s language

Summary

Summary
  • cos⁡ζ=12{exp⁡(iζ)+exp⁡(−iζ)}\cos\zeta = \tfrac12\{\exp(i\zeta) + \exp(-i\zeta)\}, sin⁡ζ=−12i{exp⁡(iζ)−exp⁡(−iζ)}\sin\zeta = -\tfrac12 i\{\exp(i\zeta) - \exp(-i\zeta)\} define the circular functions for all ζ\zeta.
  • Every identity of elementary trigonometry remains true, because it is algebra in t=exp⁡(iζ)t = \exp(i\zeta).
  • cos⁡iζ=cosh⁡ζ\cos i\zeta = \cosh\zeta, sin⁡iζ=isinh⁡ζ\sin i\zeta = i\sinh\zeta: circular and hyperbolic functions are one family.
  • cos⁡(ξ+iη)=cos⁡ξcosh⁡η−isin⁡ξsinh⁡η\cos(\xi + i\eta) = \cos\xi\cosh\eta - i\sin\xi\sinh\eta; ∣sin⁡∣2=sin⁡2ξ+sinh⁡2η|\sin|^2 = \sin^2\xi + \sinh^2\eta.
  • No new zeros, but no bound either: ∣sin⁡ζ∣|\sin\zeta| and ∣cos⁡ζ∣|\cos\zeta| grow like 12e∣η∣\tfrac12 e^{|\eta|} away from the real axis.