Since Chapter II we have been using sinx and cosx, differentiating them, and expanding them in series. But what is the number x in sinx? School trigonometry says “the angle in radians, the length of the arc”, and Hardy points out that we have never proved that a curved arc has a length. §163 repairs this with the tool of the previous lesson: it measures an angle by an area, which we can now define, and shows that this measure is given by a definite integral. That integral is the foundation on which Chapter IX builds the whole theory of the circular functions.
The idea
Everyone agrees on what an angle is: two rays OA and OP from a point. The difficulty is to attach a number to it. The usual answer is the length of the arc AP of the unit circle centred at O. A neat alternative is available. The sector AOP of a unit circle with arc length x has area 21x (a full circle has circumference 2π and area π). So “arc length” and “twice the sector area” are the same number, whenever both make sense; and we do know what area means, since §161.
Put OA along the positive x-axis and let OP be the ray y=mx with m>0. The sector is cut from the quarter disc by that ray. The widget computes its area from the definition, and compares twice that area with a quite different area: the region under y=1/(1+t2) from t=0 to t=m.
ExploreTwice a sector is an area under 1/(1+t2)
Try this.Drag P round the circle, or move the slider for the slope m. Compare the two numbers in the read-out: twice the sector area, and the area under the curve on the right. Then switch on Hardy’s split, and push m as far as it will go.
The unit circle and the ray y=1x
The curve y=1+t21, area from 0 to m
t
sector AOP
the ray y = mx (drag P)
Sector area ϕ(m)=21mμ2+∫μ11−x2dx=0.25+0.1427=0.392699
Twice that is 0.785398; and ∫0m1+t2dt=0.785398.
As m grows without bound the sector fills a quarter of the disc, so the angle tends to 2⋅4π=2π≈1.570796.
What to notice
The two numbers agree for every m, although one is an area inside a circle and the other an area under a quite different curve. With the split on you see how the sector is computed: a triangle plus the region under the arc. As m grows the sector creeps towards the full quarter disc, and the area under 1/(1+t2) creeps towards the same limit, about 1.5708, although the interval [0,m] is unbounded.
The agreement is not a coincidence, and the proof is a single differentiation. Write ϕ(m) for the area of the sector. If we can show that ϕ′(m)=2(1+m2)1, then since ϕ(0)=0 the fundamental theorem gives ϕ(m)=21∫0mdt/(1+t2). And ϕ′(m) is easy to find, because the sector splits into two pieces whose areas we can write down: a triangle, and a region under the arc y=1−x2.
Precise statements
DefinitionMeasure of an angleHardy: §163
Let A and P lie on the circle of radius 1 with centre O. The measure of the angle AOP is twice the area of the sector AOP.
TheoremThe sector area as an integralHardy: §163
Let OA be the positive x-axis and OP the ray y=mx, m≥0, and let ϕ(m) be the area of the sector AOP of the unit circle. Then
ϕ(m)=21∫0m1+t2dt.
So the measure of the angle between the x-axis and the ray y=mx is ∫0mdt/(1+t2). Since the tangent of that angle is m, this is the analytical form of the definition.
DefinitionThe inverse tangentHardy: §163
For every real m,
arctanm=∫0m1+t2dt.
This defines arctan as a genuine function of m with no geometry left in it, for negative m too. It is continuous and increasing, with derivative 1/(1+m2), and it is odd, because the integrand is even. It is also bounded: ∫0mdt/(1+t2)<∫01dt+∫1mdt/t2<2. So it tends to a limit as m→∞; that limit is twice the area of the quarter disc, and we call it 21π. Chapter IX defines tan as the inverse function of arctan, then cos and sin from tan, and recovers every property of the circular functions from this one integral.
Proofs
ProofThe sector area as an integral
Strategy
Split the sector into a triangle and a region under the arc, so that its area is an explicit function of the abscissa μ of P. Differentiate with respect to μ (the fundamental theorem handles the region under the arc), then convert to a derivative with respect to m by the chain rule. Finally integrate back, using ϕ(0)=0.
Locate P
P=(μ,mμ) lies on x2+y2=1, so μ2(1+m2)=1:
μ=1+m21,1−μ2=1+m2m=mμ.
Split the sector
Let N=(μ,0) be the foot of the perpendicular from P. The sector AOP is the triangle ONP, of area 21μ⋅mμ, together with the region between NA and the arc PA, which is the area under y=1−x2 from x=μ to x=1:
ϕ=21μ1−μ2+∫μ11−x2dx.
Differentiate with respect to μ
The derivative of ∫μ1g with respect to its lower limit is −g(μ) (§162). So
dμdϕ=211−μ2−21−μ2μ2−1−μ2=−21−μ21.
Change to m
From μ=(1+m2)−1/2 we get dμ/dm=−m(1+m2)−3/2. By the chain rule, and using 1−μ2=m/1+m2,
dmdϕ=21−μ21⋅(1+m2)3/2m=2(1+m2)1.
(For m=0 the same value follows by continuity, or by a one-sided difference quotient.)
Integrate back
ϕ and 21∫0mdt/(1+t2) have the same derivative, so they differ by a constant (§126). Both vanish at m=0, where the sector is a segment of zero area. So they are equal.
∎
Worked examples and exercises
These are from Hardy’s Examples LXIII, “calculation of the definite from the indefinite integral”: find an antiderivative F, then the integral is F(b)−F(a).
ExerciseWhich value of arctan?●○○Hardy: Examples LXIII, 3
Show that ∫ab1+x2dx=arctanb−arctana, and in particular ∫011+x2dx=41π. Explain why there is no ambiguity about which value of arctan is meant.
Hint
With the definition in this lesson, arctan is a single-valued function, and the additivity of the integral does the rest.
Hint
For arctan1: the ray y=x bisects the right angle, so its sector is half the quarter disc.
Solution
By the definition, arctanb−arctana=∫0b−∫0a=∫ab1+x2dx. For ∫01: the ray y=x makes the sector exactly half of the quarter disc, by symmetry in the line y=x. So the angle is half of the right angle, 21⋅21π=41π.
In the old view, arctanx is “an angle whose tangent is x”, which is ambiguous up to multiples of π. Hardy’s remark settles it: the integral is 0 at x=0 and increases continuously with x, so the value meant is the one between −21π and 21π, today called the principal value. In the same way ∫0xdt/1−t2=arcsinx with arcsinx between −21π and 21π, for −1<x<1.
for −1<x<1. G is continuous on [0,1], so ∫011−x2dx=G(1)−G(0)=21arcsin1=41π. (This agrees with the definition: the quarter disc is the sector of the right angle, and the angle is twice its area, 21π.)
For the second integral put x=au, dx=adu: ∫0aa2−x2dx=a2∫011−u2du=41πa2.
Exercise●●○Hardy: Examples LXIII, 4
Show that, if −π<α<π and α=0,
∫011+2xcosα+x2dx=2sinαα,
and that the value for α=0 is 21, the limit of the right-hand side as α→0.
Hint
Complete the square: 1+2xcosα+x2=(x+cosα)2+sin2α.
Hint
For 0<θ<π, arctan(cotθ)=21π−θ, because cotθ=tan(21π−θ) and 21π−θ lies in (−21π,21π).
Solution
Take first 0<α<π, so sinα>0. An antiderivative is sinα1arctansinαx+cosα. Hence the integral is
sinα1{arctansinα1+cosα−arctansinαcosα}.
Now sinα1+cosα=2sin21αcos21α2cos221α=cot21α, and by the second hint the bracket is (21π−21α)−(21π−α)=21α. So the integral is α/(2sinα).
If −π<α<0, the integrand is unchanged when α is replaced by −α, and so is α/(2sinα); the formula still holds. If α=0 the integral is ∫01(1+x)−2dx=1−21=21, which is limα→0α/(2sinα). (Check: α=1 gives 0.59420 both ways.)
ExerciseAn integral that changes formula●●○Hardy: Examples LXIII, 6
Show that ∫−111−2αx+α2dx equals 2 if ∣α∣<1 and 2/∣α∣ if ∣α∣>1.
Hint
For α=0, an antiderivative is −α11−2αx+α2.
Hint
At x=±1 the square root is (1∓α)2=∣1∓α∣, not 1∓α.
Solution
For α=0 the integral is ∫−11dx=2. For α=0, using the hints, it equals
−α1(∣1−α∣−∣1+α∣).
If ∣α∣<1 both 1±α are positive and this is −α1(−2α)=2. If α>1 it is −α1{(α−1)−(α+1)}=2/α. If α<−1 it is −α1{(1−α)−(−1−α)}=−2/α=2/∣α∣. (Hardy writes 2/α, having α>1 in mind.) The moral is in the second hint: u2=∣u∣, and forgetting this gives a wrong answer outside ∣α∣<1. The value is a continuous function of α (both formulae give 2 at α=±1), but it is given by different formulae on the two sides.
Let m and n be positive integers. Show that ∫02πcosmxsinnxdx=0, and that ∫02πcosmxcosnxdx and ∫02πsinmxsinnxdx are 0 unless m=n, when each is π.
Hint
Turn each product into a sum: 2cosAcosB=cos(A−B)+cos(A+B), 2sinAsinB=cos(A−B)−cos(A+B), 2cosAsinB=sin(A+B)−sin(A−B).
Hint
For an integer k=0, ∫02πcoskxdx=0 and ∫02πsinkxdx=0 (Examples LXIII, 2).
Solution
By Examples LXIII, 2, for every integer k=0, ∫02πcoskxdx=(sin2kπ−0)/k=0 and ∫02πsinkxdx=(1−cos2kπ)/k=0; also ∫02πsin0xdx=0.
cosmxsinnx=21{sin(n+m)x+sin(n−m)x}, and both terms integrate to 0. Next cosmxcosnx=21{cos(m−n)x+cos(m+n)x}. The second term integrates to 0 because m+n=0; the first integrates to 0 unless m=n, when it is 21cos0=21 and gives 21⋅2π=π. The sine–sine case is the same with a minus sign before the cos(m+n)x term. These “orthogonality relations” are what make Fourier series work: they pick out one coefficient at a time (Examples LXV, 5).
Check yourself
Check yourselfChoose one
Why does Hardy define the measure of an angle by an area rather than by the length of an arc?
Why
Arc length can be made rigorous, and once it is, it gives the same number as twice the sector area; so the two definitions agree. The point is order of construction: §161 has just made area precise, while length would need a separate and harder theory. Nothing here depends on knowing π in advance; on the contrary, π comes out of the construction.
Check yourselfEnter a number
What is the measure of the angle between the positive x-axis and the ray y=x? Give a decimal.
Why
It is arctan1=∫01dt/(1+t2)=41π≈0.7854: the sector is half the quarter disc, whose area is 41π, so the sector has area 81π and the angle is twice that.
Check yourselfTrue or false?
Since the interval [0,m] grows without bound as m→∞, so does ∫0mdt/(1+t2).
Why
False. The integrand falls off like 1/t2, and ∫1mdt/t2=1−1/m<1, so the integral stays below 2. It increases to the limit 21π: geometrically, the sector cut off by y=mx never exceeds the quarter disc.
Check yourselfChoose one
What is ∫−131+x2dx?
Why
The integral is arctan3−arctan(−1) with the principal values 31π and −41π. The integrand is positive, so the answer must be positive, which rules out the first option (it uses 43π, another angle with tangent −1). The third forgets the sign of arctan(−1); the fourth uses the value 34π for arctan3, which the integral never produces.
Hardy’s language
The whole difficulty lies in the question, what is the x which occurs in cos x and sin x?
— G. H. Hardy, §163
Summary
Summary
The measure of an angle is twice the area of the sector it cuts from the unit circle; this needs only the area of §161, not the length of a curve.
For the ray y=mx, the sector splits into a triangle and the region under 1−x2; differentiating gives ϕ′(m)=1/{2(1+m2)}.
Hence arctanm=∫0mdt/(1+t2), a single-valued, increasing, bounded function whose limit at infinity is 21π.
Definite integrals are computed as F(b)−F(a) from an antiderivative; with many-valued inverse functions, the integral itself decides which value is meant.