Chapter VII · Additional theorems in the differential and integral calculus

The contact of plane curves

§155 35 min

How closely two curves touch, measured by how many derivatives agree, with inflexions and the circle of curvature as the main examples.

Why this matters

Two curves can meet at a point by crossing, by touching, or by touching “very closely”. §155 turns this into a number, the order of contact, using Taylor’s theorem: the more derivatives agree, the faster the gap between the curves closes. The tangent line is the straight line of closest contact; asking for one more order of contact defines points of inflexion; and the circle of closest contact, the circle of curvature, gives the curvature of a curve, the basic quantity of differential geometry.

The idea

Let two curves y=f(x)y = f(x) and y=ϕ(x)y = \phi(x) pass through the same point PP with abscissa ξ\xi. Move a distance hh to the right and measure the vertical gap QR=ϕ(ξ+h)−f(ξ+h)QR = \phi(\xi + h) - f(\xi + h) between them. If the curves merely cross, the gap is of the order of hh. If they touch (same tangent), Taylor’s theorem shows the gap is of the order of h2h^2. If also their second derivatives agree, it is of the order of h3h^3, and so on. The rate at which the gap closes is a measure of how closely the curves cling together.

There is a practical way to read off that rate: halve hh. A gap of order hkh^k shrinks by a factor of about 2k2^k.

Explore Halve hh and watch the gap

Try this. On the parabola y=x2y = x^2, compare with the tangent, then the circle, and read the last column of the table. Then put ξ=0\xi = 0 with the circle. Finally choose y=x3−xy = x^3 - x at ξ=0\xi = 0 and compare with the tangent.

y=x2y = x^2 at ξ=0.6\xi = 0.6 compared with its tangent line
xy
  • y = x²
  • tangent line
  • gap QR at x = ξ + h
  • point of contact P
Compare with
hgap QRgap(h) / gap(h/2)
0.50.254
0.250.06254
0.1250.015634
0.06250.003906
Halving hh divides the gap by about 222^{2}, so the gap is of order h2h^{2}: contact of order 1.
What to notice

Against the tangent the gap ratio is about 4=224 = 2^2 (order h2h^2, contact of order 11). Against the circle of curvature it is about 88 (contact of order 22), except at the vertex ξ=0\xi = 0, where it jumps to 1616: the circle fits unusually well there. At the inflexion of x3−xx^3 - x the tangent itself achieves ratio 88: the line crosses the curve while hugging it to second order.

Precise statements

Definition Contact of the nn-th order Hardy: §155

Let ff and ϕ\phi have derivatives of all the orders needed at x=ξx = \xi. If

f(ξ)=ϕ(ξ),f′(ξ)=ϕ′(ξ),…,f(n)(ξ)=ϕ(n)(ξ),butf(n+1)(ξ)≠ϕ(n+1)(ξ),f(\xi) = \phi(\xi),\quad f'(\xi) = \phi'(\xi),\quad \dots,\quad f^{(n)}(\xi) = \phi^{(n)}(\xi), \qquad\text{but}\qquad f^{(n+1)}(\xi) \ne \phi^{(n+1)}(\xi),

the curves y=f(x)y = f(x) and y=ϕ(x)y = \phi(x) have contact of the nn-th order at the point with abscissa ξ\xi. Contact of the first order is simply touching: a common point and a common tangent.

Theorem Order of contact and the size of the gap Hardy: §155

If the curves have contact of the nn-th order at ξ\xi, then

ϕ(ξ+h)−f(ξ+h)hn+1→ϕ(n+1)(ξ)−f(n+1)(ξ)(n+1)!≠0(h→0).\frac{\phi(\xi + h) - f(\xi + h)}{h^{n+1}} \to \frac{\phi^{(n+1)}(\xi) - f^{(n+1)}(\xi)}{(n+1)!} \ne 0 \qquad (h \to 0).

So the gap is of exactly the (n+1)(n+1)-th order of smallness in hh.

Two special cases recur constantly.

Definition Tangent and point of inflexion Hardy: Examples LIX, 1–2

The tangent to y=f(x)y = f(x) at ξ\xi is the line with contact of order at least 11: y−f(ξ)=(x−ξ)f′(ξ)y - f(\xi) = (x - \xi)f'(\xi). A point where the tangent has contact of order at least 22, that is, where f′′(ξ)=0f''(\xi) = 0, is a point of inflexion.

Definition Circle of curvature Hardy: Examples LIX, 8

If f′′(ξ)≠0f''(\xi) \ne 0, there is exactly one circle with contact of order at least 22 with y=f(x)y = f(x) at (ξ,η)(\xi, \eta). Writing η1=f′(ξ)\eta_1 = f'(\xi) and η2=f′′(ξ)\eta_2 = f''(\xi), its centre (a,b)(a, b) and radius ρ\rho are

a=ξ−η1(1+η12)η2,b=η+1+η12η2,ρ=(1+η12)3/2∣η2∣.a = \xi - \frac{\eta_1(1 + \eta_1^2)}{\eta_2}, \qquad b = \eta + \frac{1 + \eta_1^2}{\eta_2}, \qquad \rho = \frac{(1 + \eta_1^2)^{3/2}}{|\eta_2|}.

It is the circle of curvature, ρ\rho is the radius of curvature, and 1/ρ1/\rho (often with the sign of η2\eta_2) is the curvature.

Hardy points out a weakness of the definition: it depends on the axes, because it uses yy as a function of xx, and it breaks down when the tangent is vertical. The cure is to describe curves parametrically, x=x(t)x = x(t), y=y(t)y = y(t); the order of contact then turns out to be a geometric invariant. We stay with the simple version.

Proofs

Proof Order of contact and the size of the gap
Strategy

Apply Taylor’s theorem in the form of §151 to the difference g=ϕ−fg = \phi - f. Contact of order nn means precisely that gg and its first nn derivatives vanish at ξ\xi.

The difference vanishes to order nn

Let g(x)=ϕ(x)−f(x)g(x) = \phi(x) - f(x). By hypothesis g(ξ)=g′(ξ)=⋯=g(n)(ξ)=0g(\xi) = g'(\xi) = \cdots = g^{(n)}(\xi) = 0 and g(n+1)(ξ)≠0g^{(n+1)}(\xi) \ne 0.

Expand gg

By §151 with n+1n + 1 in place of nn, g(ξ+h)=hn+1(n+1)!{g(n+1)(ξ)+η}g(\xi + h) = \dfrac{h^{n+1}}{(n+1)!}\bigl\{g^{(n+1)}(\xi) + \eta\bigr\} with η→0\eta \to 0.

Divide by hn+1h^{n+1}

g(ξ+h)/hn+1={g(n+1)(ξ)+η}/(n+1)!→g(n+1)(ξ)/(n+1)!g(\xi + h)/h^{n+1} = \bigl\{g^{(n+1)}(\xi) + \eta\bigr\}/(n+1)! \to g^{(n+1)}(\xi)/(n+1)!, which is not zero. This is the statement. In particular, halving hh divides the gap by a factor tending to 2n+12^{n+1}, which is what the widget measures.

Proof The circle of curvature
Strategy

Write the circle as (x−a)2+(y−b)2=ρ2(x - a)^2 + (y - b)^2 = \rho^2, differentiate twice, and require that yy, y′y' and y′′y'' take the values η,η1,η2\eta, \eta_1, \eta_2 of the curve at x=ξx = \xi. Three conditions fix the three unknowns aa, bb, ρ\rho.

Differentiate the equation of the circle

Along the circle, yy is a function of xx (on the arc through the point) and

(x−a)+(y−b)y′=0,1+y′2+(y−b)y′′=0.(x - a) + (y - b)y' = 0, \qquad 1 + y'^2 + (y - b)y'' = 0.

Impose second-order contact

Put x=ξx = \xi, y=ηy = \eta, y′=η1y' = \eta_1, y′′=η2y'' = \eta_2. The second equation gives η−b=−(1+η12)/η2\eta - b = -(1 + \eta_1^2)/\eta_2, so b=η+(1+η12)/η2b = \eta + (1 + \eta_1^2)/\eta_2. The first gives ξ−a=−(η−b)η1=η1(1+η12)/η2\xi - a = -(\eta - b)\eta_1 = \eta_1(1 + \eta_1^2)/\eta_2, so a=ξ−η1(1+η12)/η2a = \xi - \eta_1(1 + \eta_1^2)/\eta_2.

Find the radius

ρ2=(ξ−a)2+(η−b)2=(1+η12)2η22 (η12+1)\rho^2 = (\xi - a)^2 + (\eta - b)^2 = \dfrac{(1 + \eta_1^2)^2}{\eta_2^2}\,(\eta_1^2 + 1), so ρ=(1+η12)3/2/∣η2∣\rho = (1 + \eta_1^2)^{3/2}/|\eta_2|. This needs η2≠0\eta_2 \ne 0; at a point of inflexion the “circle” degenerates into the tangent line.

The circle of curvature usually has contact of exactly order 22; it sits on the curve and, typically, crosses it. At special points (the vertices of a conic, for instance) the third derivatives agree as well, and the contact is of order 33.

Explore Curvature along an ellipse

Try this. Slide ξ\xi along the upper half of the ellipse 14x2+y2=1\tfrac14 x^2 + y^2 = 1 and watch the circle of curvature and its radius. Stop at ξ=0\xi = 0 and read the order of contact.

14x2+y2=1\tfrac14x^2 + y^2 = 1 at ξ=0.8\xi = 0.8 compared with its circle of curvature
xy
  • ellipse x²/4 + y² = 1 (upper half)
  • circle of curvature
  • gap QR at x = ξ + h
  • point of contact P
Compare with
hgap QRgap(h) / gap(h/2)
0.50.0051739.962
0.250.00051938.798
0.1255.902 × 10⁻⁵8.366
0.06257.055 × 10⁻⁶
Centre (0.096, −2.31)(0.096,\ -2.31), radius of curvature ρ=3.302\rho = 3.302, curvature 1/ρ=0.30281/\rho = 0.3028. Halving hh divides the gap by about 23.062^{3.06}, so the gap is of order h3h^{3}: contact of order 2.
What to notice

The circle is largest at the top, the flattest point (ρ=4\rho = 4), and shrinks towards the ends of the major axis, where the ellipse turns sharply. At ξ=0\xi = 0, an end of an axis, the gap ratio jumps from about 88 to about 1616: there the circle has contact of order 33. The ends of the axes are the only such points on an ellipse (Misc. Ex. 10 of this chapter).

Worked examples and exercises

Exercise Points of inflexion ●○○ Hardy: Examples LIX, 3

Find the points of inflexion of y=3x4−6x3+1y = 3x^4 - 6x^3 + 1, y=2x/(1+x2)y = 2x/(1 + x^2), y=sin⁡xy = \sin x, y=tan⁡xy = \tan x and y=arctan⁡xy = \arctan x.

Hint
Solve f′′(x)=0f''(x) = 0, and check that f′′f'' really changes sign (so that the tangent crosses the curve).

Solution
  • f′′=36x2−36x=36x(x−1)f'' = 36x^2 - 36x = 36x(x - 1): inflexions at (0,1)(0, 1) and (1,−2)(1, -2).
  • f′=2(1−x2)/(1+x2)2f' = 2(1 - x^2)/(1 + x^2)^2 and f′′=4x(x2−3)/(1+x2)3f'' = 4x(x^2 - 3)/(1 + x^2)^3: inflexions at (0,0)(0, 0) and (±3,±123)(\pm\sqrt3, \pm\tfrac12\sqrt3).
  • f′′=−sin⁡xf'' = -\sin x: inflexions at x=kπx = k\pi, on the axis.
  • f′′=2sec⁡2xtan⁡xf'' = 2\sec^2 x\tan x: inflexions at x=kπx = k\pi.
  • f′′=−2x/(1+x2)2f'' = -2x/(1 + x^2)^2: one inflexion, at the origin.

In each case f′′f'' changes sign at the point (and f′′′≠0f''' \ne 0 there), so the tangent has contact of order exactly 22 and crosses the curve.

Exercise Constant curvature ●●○ Hardy: Examples LIX, 9

Verify that a circle of radius cc has curvature 1/c1/c at every point. Then show that a curve y=f(x)y = f(x) whose curvature f′′/(1+f′2)3/2f''/(1 + f'^2)^{3/2} is a non-zero constant 1/c1/c is an arc of a circle of radius cc.

Hint
For the converse, put p=f′p = f'. Then p′/(1+p2)3/2=1/cp'/(1 + p^2)^{3/2} = 1/c. Integrate: what is the derivative of p/1+p2p/\sqrt{1 + p^2}?

Solution

For the lower semicircle y=−c2−x2y = -\sqrt{c^2 - x^2} we get y′=x/c2−x2y' = x/\sqrt{c^2 - x^2}, 1+y′2=c2/(c2−x2)1 + y'^2 = c^2/(c^2 - x^2) and y′′=c2/(c2−x2)3/2y'' = c^2/(c^2 - x^2)^{3/2}, so y′′/(1+y′2)3/2=1/cy''/(1 + y'^2)^{3/2} = 1/c. (For the upper semicircle the sign changes.)

Conversely, let p=f′p = f', so p′/(1+p2)3/2=1/cp'/(1 + p^2)^{3/2} = 1/c. Since ddxp1+p2=p′(1+p2)3/2\dfrac{d}{dx}\dfrac{p}{\sqrt{1 + p^2}} = \dfrac{p'}{(1 + p^2)^{3/2}}, we get p/1+p2=(x−a)/cp/\sqrt{1 + p^2} = (x - a)/c for a constant aa. Solving, p=(x−a)/c2−(x−a)2p = (x - a)/\sqrt{c^2 - (x - a)^2}, and integrating once more, y=b−c2−(x−a)2y = b - \sqrt{c^2 - (x - a)^2}. So (x−a)2+(y−b)2=c2(x - a)^2 + (y - b)^2 = c^2: an arc of a circle of radius cc.

Exercise Curvature of the parabola ●●○ Hardy: Examples LIX, 10

Find the centre and radius of curvature at any point of the parabola y2=4axy^2 = 4ax (a>0a > 0), and the radius at the vertex.

Hint
On the upper half, y=2axy = 2\sqrt{ax}, so η1=a/x\eta_1 = \sqrt{a/x} and η2=−12a x−3/2\eta_2 = -\tfrac12\sqrt a\, x^{-3/2}.

Solution

With η1=a/x\eta_1 = \sqrt{a/x}, 1+η12=(x+a)/x1 + \eta_1^2 = (x + a)/x and η2=−12a x−3/2\eta_2 = -\tfrac12 \sqrt a\,x^{-3/2}:

ρ=((x+a)/x)3/212a x−3/2=2(x+a)3/2a.\rho = \frac{\bigl((x + a)/x\bigr)^{3/2}}{\tfrac12\sqrt a\,x^{-3/2}} = \frac{2(x + a)^{3/2}}{\sqrt a}.

The centre is ac=x−η1(1+η12)/η2=x+2(x+a)=3x+2aa_c = x - \eta_1(1 + \eta_1^2)/\eta_2 = x + 2(x + a) = 3x + 2a and bc=y+(1+η12)/η2=2ax−2x (x+a)/a=−2x3/2/ab_c = y + (1 + \eta_1^2)/\eta_2 = 2\sqrt{ax} - 2\sqrt x\,(x + a)/\sqrt a = -2x^{3/2}/\sqrt a; by symmetry the lower half gives bc=+2x3/2/ab_c = +2x^{3/2}/\sqrt a. As x→0x \to 0 the radius tends to 2a2a, the radius of curvature at the vertex. (At the vertex itself the tangent is vertical and Hardy’s formula cannot be used directly; treating x=y2/4ax = y^2/4a as a function of yy gives ρ=2a\rho = 2a at once.)

Exercise Conics have no inflexions ●●● Hardy: Examples LIX, 4

Show that a non-degenerate conic ax2+2hxy+by2+2gx+2fy+c=0ax^2 + 2hxy + by^2 + 2gx + 2fy + c = 0 has no point of inflexion.

Hint
Differentiate the equation twice implicitly. At an inflexion y′′=0y'' = 0; what equation does that give for y′y'?

Solution

Write X=ax+hy+gX = ax + hy + g and Y=hx+by+fY = hx + by + f (half the partial derivatives of the left side). Differentiating, X+Yy′=0X + Yy' = 0, and again, a+2hy′+by′2+Yy′′=0a + 2hy' + by'^2 + Yy'' = 0. At an inflexion y′′=0y'' = 0, so a+2hy′+by′2=0a + 2hy' + by'^2 = 0 with y′=−X/Yy' = -X/Y, that is aY2−2hXY+bX2=0aY^2 - 2hXY + bX^2 = 0. Expanding (Hardy’s computation) gives (ab−h2){ax2+2hxy+by2+2gx+2fy}+af2−2fgh+bg2=0(ab - h^2)\{ax^2 + 2hxy + by^2 + 2gx + 2fy\} + af^2 - 2fgh + bg^2 = 0. On the conic, the brace equals −c-c, so the point would satisfy −c(ab−h2)+af2−2fgh+bg2=0-c(ab - h^2) + af^2 - 2fgh + bg^2 = 0, that is abc+2fgh−af2−bg2−ch2=0abc + 2fgh - af^2 - bg^2 - ch^2 = 0. That is exactly the condition for the conic to split into two lines. So a non-degenerate conic has no inflexion.

Check yourself

Check yourself Enter a number

What is the radius of curvature of y=x2y = x^2 at the origin?

Why

η1=0\eta_1 = 0 and η2=2\eta_2 = 2, so ρ=(1+0)3/2/2=12\rho = (1 + 0)^{3/2}/2 = \tfrac12. The circle of curvature is x2+(y−12)2=14x^2 + (y - \tfrac12)^2 = \tfrac14. Check it in the first widget.

Check yourself Choose one

Near a point PP, halving hh divides the gap between two touching curves by about 88. What is their order of contact at PP?

Why

A factor 8=238 = 2^3 means the gap is of order h3h^3, and contact of order nn gives a gap of order hn+1h^{n+1}. So n=2n = 2: the curves share value, first and second derivatives at PP, but not the third.

Check yourself True or false?

At a point of inflexion, the tangent has contact of order at least 22 with the curve, and yet (typically) crosses it there.

Why

True. If f′′(ξ)=0f''(\xi) = 0 and f′′′(ξ)≠0f'''(\xi) \ne 0, the gap between the curve and its tangent is about 16f′′′(ξ)h3\tfrac16 f'''(\xi)h^3, which changes sign with hh. Close contact and crossing are compatible: what matters for crossing is whether the order of the gap is odd or even, as in the test for maxima and minima.

Check yourself Choose one

Why does Hardy call his definition of contact unsatisfactory in general?

Why

At a point with vertical tangent, such as the vertex of y2=4axy^2 = 4ax, f′f' does not exist, so the definition cannot be applied. Using a parameter tt for both coordinates removes the dependence on the axes; Hardy refers to Fowler’s tract for that theory.

Hardy’s language

Summary

Summary
  • Contact of order nn at ξ\xi: values and first nn derivatives agree, the (n+1)(n+1)-th do not.
  • Then the gap ϕ(ξ+h)−f(ξ+h)\phi(\xi + h) - f(\xi + h) is of exact order hn+1h^{n+1} (Taylor’s theorem applied to ϕ−f\phi - f). Halving hh divides it by about 2n+12^{n+1}.
  • The tangent has contact of order ≥1\ge 1; where it has order ≥2\ge 2 (f′′(ξ)=0f''(\xi) = 0), there is a point of inflexion.
  • The circle of curvature has contact of order ≥2\ge 2; its radius is ρ=(1+f′2)3/2/∣f′′∣\rho = (1 + f'^2)^{3/2}/|f''|.