Chapter VII · Additional theorems in the differential and integral calculus
Chapter VII problems
Eleven of the Miscellaneous Examples on Chapter VII, on Taylor expansions, functions of several variables and definite integrals, with graded hints and full solutions.
Hardy’s Miscellaneous Examples on Chapter VII are long and varied. They follow the chapter’s two halves: Taylor expansions and functions of several variables (Examples 1–30), then definite integrals (Examples 31–48). Eleven are collected here, in three groups, roughly in order of difficulty within each group. Try each one before opening the first hint; the hints go from a nudge to an outline, and every solution is complete. As in Hardy, assume that all the derivatives that occur are continuous.
Taylor expansions
Verify the first terms and .
Hint
Hint
Solution
By Taylor’s theorem in the form of §151, for some numbers : the even coefficients vanish because is odd, and the coefficient of is . Also and . Multiplying,
This equals , and two expansions of the same function in powers of up to have the same coefficients (subtract and divide by successive powers of ). So , giving ; and , giving .
In the same way gives and .
Prove that as .
Hint
Hint
Solution
By Examples LXVII, 1 with centre and , for some in . With , . So the expression equals
Since , we have , so the expression tends to .
(Alternatively, expand: , and in the bracket the terms in and cancel, leaving plus smaller terms.)
Functions of several variables
A function is homogeneous of degree if for all . Prove that then
Hint
Hint
Solution
Fix and let . The arguments are functions of with derivatives , so by the chain rule (valid since the partial derivatives are continuous)
On the other hand , so . Putting gives . Check: is homogeneous of degree , and .
Let for and . With and , show that . Hardy concludes that is a function of ; show by putting that . Then give a direct proof that does not rely on the (unproved) sufficiency of the Jacobian condition.
Hint
Hint
Solution
The Jacobian. . If, as Hardy argues (Misc. Ex. 15), this forces a relation , then putting gives and , so for every , and .
Directly. Fix and let . By the chain rule , so is constant (§126), and . Hence . Since is such a function (§162), this is the functional equation of . (The same direct argument, with , proves Hardy’s companion result for , , when .)
Three variables are connected by a relation which makes a function of and , with derivatives , and also makes a function of and , with derivatives . Prove that and .
Hint
Hint
Solution
For all in the relevant region, . Differentiate with respect to (with fixed), using the chain rule: . Differentiate with respect to (with fixed): . The first shows , so and .
This is Hardy’s computation with differentials ( and , with , independent) made explicit. Note the minus sign: is not in disguise. With the third relation one obtains the well-known . Check with : , , .
Definite integrals
Evaluate . For what values of is a discontinuous function of ?
Hint
Hint
Solution
If the integrand is (for ), so . Otherwise the denominator is positive on , and differentiating confirms the antiderivative in the first hint. So
using the oddness of for the lower limit. For , is in : the first term is and the second , so . For the first term is and the second is (the value of must lie in ), so . The integrand has period in , hence
is discontinuous exactly at the multiples of . The integrand is a perfectly good continuous function of for each fixed , but as it concentrates near into a spike of area ; this is why “the integral of a function continuous in each variable” need not be continuous in the parameter. (Near the spike is at .)
If , prove that .
Hint
Hint
Solution
With ( from to , , ), the integral becomes . By the identity in the second hint,
Integrating over : , , and by Examples LXIII, 7 with , . So the integral is . All integrands are continuous, since . (Check: gives .)
Prove, by the substitution , that .
Hint
Hint
Solution
, so with in , . On this increases from to , so increases from to , with a continuous derivative. Differentiating ,
and since ,
So the integrand is exactly , and by the substitution rule (§166) the integral is . (Numerically .)
For continuous , on , prove that .
Hint
Hint
Solution
Let , , . Expanding by linearity, for all real . If then (a continuous non-negative with zero integral, Misc. Ex. 43), so and the inequality holds. If , take and : then , that is, . It is the continuous version of Cauchy’s inequality (Misc. Examples I, 10), to which Riemann sums reduce it. Equality holds only if for some , that is, if and are proportional.
Let . Show that is a polynomial of degree and that for every polynomial of degree less than . Deduce that for .
Hint
Hint
Solution
has degree , so has degree (its leading coefficient is , not ), and is a polynomial of degree . Near , with a polynomial; by Leibniz’s rule each of still contains a factor , so they all vanish at , and likewise at .
Let have degree . Integrating by parts once,
since . Repeating times (possible since , and every bracket vanishes because it contains with ) gives , as . Dividing by the constant , .
If , is a polynomial of degree less than , so ; by symmetry the same holds if . (For : , and indeed .)
Let , be the roots of . Prove that for every polynomial of degree at most ,
Hint
Hint
Solution
In terms of the interval is , and the three points are with . Both sides are linear in , so check , .
Odd . , and the rule gives .
. and .
. , and .
. , and .
So the rule is exact for every quintic. It uses only three ordinates, like Simpson’s rule (§169), but is exact for polynomials of two degrees higher, because the outer points are placed cleverly rather than at the ends. It is the three-point Gauss–Legendre rule, and , , are the zeros of the Legendre polynomial of the previous problem on . It fails for : , while the rule gives .