Chapter X · The general theory of the logarithmic, exponential and circular functions
Logarithms and the inverse circular functions
arc tan, arc sin and arc cos are logarithms in disguise; the formula arc tan x = (1/2i) Log{(1 + ix)/(1 − ix)} is completely true.
Why this matters
In Chapter VI the integral of came out in two quite different forms: an inverse tangent when , a logarithm when . Two formulae for one integral, depending on the sign of a constant, suggest that the inverse tangent and the logarithm are really the same function. Now that the logarithm of a complex number is defined, §241 proves exactly that, and gives the companion formulae for and .
The idea
Since and are built from , and is inverted by , the inverse circular functions should be logarithms. For the tangent, take a real angle and look at the complex number : its amplitude is . Its conjugate has amplitude . So their quotient
has modulus and amplitude : it is . Taking logarithms and dividing by recovers , up to the usual ambiguity of a multiple of , which is precisely the ambiguity of .
Try this. Move from to . Watch (ochre, solid), (ochre, dashed) and their quotient (blue), and the values of on the right.
- 1 + ix (solid) and 1 − ix (dashed)
- w = (1 + ix)/(1 − ix), always on the unit circle
- angle 2y, and the principal arc tan x
- −½π and ½π
What to notice
always stays on the unit circle, at twice the angle of . As , approaches from above or below, and the principal value of approaches : the principal logarithm reproduces the principal value of , between and . The other values differ by multiples of , exactly like the other values of .
Precise statements
As in Chapter VI, (Hardy: ) denotes any angle whose tangent is , so it is many-valued; its principal value lies in . Likewise for and .
For real ,
is completely true: every value of either side is a value of the other. Taking principal values on both sides gives a true equation.
For real with ,
both completely true, each sign giving half of the values.
There is also the formula that motivated the section: for real and , every value of differs from a value of by a constant. So the two Chapter VI integrals of are one formula, read with real or imaginary.
Proofs
Compute all values of the right-hand side by substituting , and compare with all values of , which are .
Write
Every real is for one in ; the values of are then , any integer.
Simplify the quotient
.
Take all logarithms
The values of are (the number has modulus and amplitudes ). Dividing by : the values of the right-hand side are .
Compare
These are exactly the values of , so the equation is completely true.
Principal values
Since , the principal logarithm of is , giving : the principal value of .
Solve for by turning it into a quadratic equation for , then take logarithms.
The quadratic
means with , i.e. .
Solve it
, real square root since . Both roots have modulus and their product is .
Invert the exponential
means is a value of , i.e. . Every value of arises this way from one of the two roots, and conversely every such satisfies . So completely.
The values are real
Since , and , a real angle. With , , the roots are and the values are : exactly the values of . The formula for is proved in the same way from , which gives , .
Worked examples and exercises
Use the formula to compute the principal value of , and all its values.
Hint
Solution
. The values of are , so . Principal value ; all values . ✓
Derive for , following the proof for .
Hint
Solution
becomes , i.e. , i.e. . So . Then . Both roots have modulus , so all values are real; with , , the roots are , i.e. and , giving the values and of .
The derivation of the formula works for any complex if means either square root. Use it to find all solutions of , and check one of them.
Hint
Solution
. Then , and . Since , this is .
Check: , and . ✓ There are no real solutions, but infinitely many complex ones.
Show that never takes the values , and that for every other complex the solutions of are the values of .
Hint
Solution
From the definitions, with (and , where ). Solving for : , so .
If then and , so the equation reads , impossible since . If then and , so it reads , impossible. So are never values of .
Otherwise , which is neither nor , and must be a value of . Hence , and every such value is a solution. For real this is the theorem above.
Check yourself
For real , the values of are spaced
The values of are apart; dividing by makes them apart, and real. That matches the period of the tangent, which is why the equation is completely true.
For , every value of is real.
True: has modulus , so its logarithms are purely imaginary, , and multiplying by gives real numbers .
The solutions of are . Give to four decimals.
, the positive solution of (the third exercise).
Hardy’s language
Summary
- For real , , completely true, and true for principal values.
- and : solve a quadratic for , then take logarithms.
- The same method solves , and the like for complex values; never takes the values .
- The two Chapter VI forms of are one formula.