Chapter VIII · The convergence of infinite series and infinite integrals
Power series and where they converge
A power series converges everywhere, nowhere but at 0, or somewhere in between; and convergence at one point forces absolute convergence at every point nearer the origin.
Why this matters
The functions of the next two chapters (the exponential, logarithm, sine and cosine, ) are all given by power series , and much of their theory comes from general facts about such series. §198 and §199 prove the first and most important fact: the set of where a power series converges cannot be arbitrary. Its shape is forced by a comparison with the geometric series, and the next lesson shows that it is always a disc.
The idea
At a point the terms of have sizes , which depend only on . Multiplying by a factor multiplies the -th term by . So shrinking a little, by a factor , damps the terms by a geometric factor, which is enough to make almost anything converge. That is the whole idea of Theorem B: if the terms are merely bounded at radius , then at any smaller radius they are dominated by a convergent geometric series.
On a logarithmic scale a geometric sequence is a straight line of slope , so geometric decay is easy to see.
Try this. For , keep just below and move . Then move above . Then look at and for small and large , and at with .
- |aₙ| rⁿ at your r
- |aₙ| r₁ⁿ at r₁
- K (r/r₁)ⁿ
What to notice
Whenever the hollow ochre points (the terms at ) are bounded, the blue points at a smaller lie under the dashed straight line , which falls geometrically. For the terms eventually plunge for every ; for they eventually climb for every : the two extreme cases of Theorem A.
Precise statements
A power series in is a series , where the coefficients are fixed (real or complex) numbers and is a complex variable.
Every power series converges at , where its sum is . Beyond that, anything from “nowhere else” to “everywhere” can happen.
A power series may converge for all values of , for a certain region of values, or for no value except . For example:
- converges (absolutely) for every ;
- converges for no except ;
- converges (absolutely) for and for no with .
If converges at , then it converges absolutely at every with . The same holds if the series only oscillates finitely at , or indeed if only its terms are bounded.
In Hardy’s words: if the series converges at a point , it converges absolutely at all points nearer to the origin than . Notice what the theorem does not say: nothing about other points at the same distance , and nothing about points further out.
Proofs
Apply d’Alembert’s ratio test (§175) to the moduli of the terms, and use the fact that the terms of a convergent series tend to .
converges for every
For and , . So converges by the ratio test, and the series converges absolutely (§197).
converges only at
For and , . So from some on the ratio exceeds and at least doubles at every step; hence , and the series cannot converge.
For it is dominated by the convergent geometric series . For , , so the terms do not tend to (§88).
Bounded terms at radius give . At radius this makes , the terms of a convergent geometric series.
The terms at are bounded
If converges then , and a convergent sequence is bounded: there is with for all , where . If the series only oscillates finitely, its partial sums satisfy , so : again bounded. (We may assume , or there is nothing to prove.)
Compare at a smaller radius
Let . Then
Conclude
Since , is a convergent geometric series. By comparison converges, so converges absolutely.
The proof uses the size of only, never its direction, which is why the conclusion holds in a whole disc. And it gives more than convergence: at radius the terms decay at least as fast as , so the series converges fast well inside.
Worked examples and exercises
Show that Theorem B remains true if oscillates finitely, and give an example where this version is needed.
Hint
Solution
If for all , then (with ), and the proof goes through with for . Example: at is , which oscillates finitely, and the conclusion (absolute convergence for ) is correct, though we could not get it from a point of convergence on the circle , because there is none.
The series converges at . Does it converge at ? What does Theorem B tell you?
Hint
Solution
At it is minus the alternating harmonic series, which converges. At it is the harmonic series, which diverges. Theorem B gives absolute convergence for only: it says nothing about other points of the circle , and this example shows that nothing can be said in general.
Let be a positive integer. Show that converges absolutely for and does not converge for .
Hint
Solution
For : , so the series of moduli converges by the ratio test. For : , so the terms do not tend to . The polynomial factor , however large is, cannot compete with the geometric factor: this is why Theorem B leaves so much room.
Prove directly, without the ratio test, that for every .
Hint
Solution
Fix and an integer with . For , . Hence for every , and since , . So the terms do not tend to , and cannot converge.
Check yourself
If a power series converges at , it converges at .
False. Theorem B only reaches points strictly nearer the origin. For instance (from ) converges at (alternating harmonic) and diverges at (harmonic). It does converge absolutely at every .
A power series converges at . At which of these points must it converge absolutely?
Only points with are covered by Theorem B, in any direction: qualifies. and lie on the same circle (no information), and is further out.
converges at . Theorem B bounds at by . What is ?
. The terms at radius decay at least like .
Hardy’s language
If the series converges at P then it converges absolutely at all points nearer to the origin than P.
Summary
- A power series always converges at ; it may converge everywhere (), nowhere else (), or in a disc ().
- Theorem B: bounded terms at (in particular, convergence at ) give absolute convergence at every with .
- The proof: , a convergent geometric series.
- It says nothing about other points with .