Chapter VIII · The convergence of infinite series and infinite integrals

Series of complex terms

§197 25 min

A complex series is two real series side by side; it is absolutely convergent exactly when the series of moduli converges, and then it behaves like a series of positive terms.

Why this matters

Power series, the subject of the next lessons, are series of complex numbers: ∑anzn\sum a_n z^n with zz anywhere in the plane. Before studying them, §197 settles what convergence and absolute convergence mean for complex series, and shows that nothing really new is needed. The key fact is that absolute convergence can be tested with a single real series of positive terms, ∑∣un∣\sum |u_n|, so every test from the first half of the chapter becomes a test for complex series.

The idea

A complex series ∑un\sum u_n with un=vn+iwnu_n = v_n + i w_n can be pictured as a walk in the Argand plane: start at 00, take the step u1u_1, then u2u_2, and so on. The partial sum sns_n is where you stand after nn steps. The series converges if you home in on a point. Since a complex sequence converges exactly when its real and imaginary parts do (§87), the series converges exactly when ∑vn\sum v_n and ∑wn\sum w_n both converge.

There are two quite different ways to home in on a point. Either the walk has finite total length, ∑∣un∣<∞\sum |u_n| < \infty, in which case it cannot help settling down; or it has infinite length but keeps turning back on itself, spiralling in, as a conditionally convergent real series zigzags.

Explore The walk of the partial sums

Try this. Start with ∑einθ/ns\sum e^{in\theta}/n^s at s=1s = 1 and vary θ\theta. Compare the distance travelled with the length of the path in the read-out as you raise the number of terms. Then set ss to 1.51.5, and to 0.60.6. Finally switch to ∑zn/n!\sum z^n/n! and increase ∣z∣|z|.

∑n≥1einθn\sum_{n\ge1} \frac{e^{in\theta}}{n}
ReIm
  • path of partial sums (each step is one term)
  • s after 200 terms
  • the sum
Series
After 200 terms the partial sum is −0.11732+0.97195 i-0.11732 + 0.97195\,i, at distance 0.9790.979 from 0, while the path so far has length ∑∣un∣=5.878\sum |u_n| = 5.878. The length grows without bound, yet the path spirals in to a point: the series converges, but only conditionally.
What to notice

For s=1s = 1 the path length grows like log⁡N\log N without bound, but the path curls up onto the sum: conditional convergence. For s>1s > 1 the length itself is finite: absolute convergence. At θ=0\theta = 0 every step points the same way and the series diverges. The exponential series always has finite length, however large ∣z∣|z| is: the path first swings far out, then the steps shrink factorially.

Precise statements

Definition Convergence of a complex series Hardy: §197

The series ∑un\sum u_n, with un=vn+iwnu_n = v_n + iw_n (vnv_n, wnw_n real), converges to s=σ+iτs = \sigma + i\tau if its partial sums tend to ss; equivalently, if ∑vn\sum v_n converges to σ\sigma and ∑wn\sum w_n converges to τ\tau.

Definition Absolute convergence of a complex series Hardy: §197

The complex series ∑un\sum u_n is absolutely convergent if the real series ∑vn\sum v_n and ∑wn\sum w_n are both absolutely convergent.

Theorem The test by moduli Hardy: §197

∑un\sum u_n is absolutely convergent if and only if ∑∣un∣\sum |u_n| converges, where ∣un∣=vn2+wn2|u_n| = \sqrt{v_n^2 + w_n^2}.

Corollary Consequences Hardy: §197

An absolutely convergent complex series converges, and ∣∑un∣≤∑∣un∣\big|\sum u_n\big| \le \sum |u_n|. Its terms may be rearranged without changing the sum. Every test for series of positive terms (comparison, ratio, root, …), applied to ∣un∣|u_n|, is a test for absolute convergence of a complex series.

Today the theorem is usually taken as the definition: ∑un\sum u_n is absolutely convergent if ∑∣un∣\sum |u_n| converges. Hardy’s definition and the modern one say the same thing, by the theorem.

Proofs

Proof The test by moduli
Strategy

Compare the three positive series ∑∣vn∣\sum |v_n|, ∑∣wn∣\sum |w_n| and ∑∣un∣\sum |u_n|, using two elementary inequalities between a complex number and its real and imaginary parts.

Two inequalities

For every nn: ∣vn∣≤∣un∣|v_n| \le |u_n| and ∣wn∣≤∣un∣|w_n| \le |u_n| (a side of a right-angled triangle is at most the hypotenuse), and ∣un∣≤∣vn∣+∣wn∣|u_n| \le |v_n| + |w_n| (the hypotenuse is at most the sum of the other two sides).

If ∑∣un∣\sum|u_n| converges

Then ∑∣vn∣\sum |v_n| and ∑∣wn∣\sum |w_n| converge by comparison, with the first inequality. So ∑vn\sum v_n and ∑wn\sum w_n are absolutely convergent: ∑un\sum u_n is absolutely convergent by definition.

If ∑un\sum u_n is absolutely convergent

Then ∑(∣vn∣+∣wn∣)\sum(|v_n| + |w_n|) converges, and by the second inequality and comparison, so does ∑∣un∣\sum |u_n|.

Proof The consequences
Strategy

Everything reduces to the real series ∑vn\sum v_n and ∑wn\sum w_n, to which §191 and §192 apply.

Convergence

∑vn\sum v_n and ∑wn\sum w_n are absolutely convergent real series, so they converge; hence ∑un\sum u_n converges.

The inequality

∣sN∣=∣u1+⋯+uN∣≤∣u1∣+⋯+∣uN∣≤∑∣un∣|s_N| = |u_1 + \cdots + u_N| \le |u_1| + \cdots + |u_N| \le \sum |u_n| by the triangle inequality; let N→∞N \to \infty.

Rearrangement

A rearrangement of ∑un\sum u_n rearranges ∑vn\sum v_n and ∑wn\sum w_n in the same way, and neither of their sums changes (§192). So the real and imaginary parts of the sum do not change.

Dirichlet’s test also carries over: if the complex partial sums of ∑an\sum a_n are bounded and φn\varphi_n is real and tends steadily to 00, the proof of §196 works word for word, with moduli in place of absolute values. That is how the series in the figure above were shown to converge for 0<s≤10 < s \le 1.

Worked examples and exercises

Exercise Directly from Cauchy’s principle ●○○ Hardy: §197

Hardy leaves this to the reader: prove that an absolutely convergent complex series converges, using the general principle of convergence for complex sequences (§87) rather than real and imaginary parts.

Hint
Copy the argument of Examples LXXVII, 1, with the triangle inequality for complex numbers.

Solution

Let δ>0\delta > 0. Since ∑∣un∣\sum |u_n| converges, there is n0n_0 such that ∣un1+1∣+⋯+∣un2∣<δ|u_{n_1+1}| + \cdots + |u_{n_2}| < \delta whenever n2>n1≥n0n_2 > n_1 \ge n_0 (Cauchy’s principle for the real series). By the triangle inequality in the complex plane,

∣sn2−sn1∣=∣un1+1+⋯+un2∣≤∣un1+1∣+⋯+∣un2∣<δ.|s_{n_2} - s_{n_1}| = |u_{n_1+1} + \cdots + u_{n_2}| \le |u_{n_1+1}| + \cdots + |u_{n_2}| < \delta .

So the complex partial sums satisfy Cauchy’s principle, which is sufficient for convergence of a complex sequence. In the picture: the stretch of path after step n1n_1 is shorter than δ\delta, so its two ends are less than δ\delta apart.

Exercise Powers of ii ●●○ Hardy: §197, §88

Show that ∑n≥1in/n\sum_{n \ge 1} i^n/n is convergent but not absolutely convergent, and find its real and imaginary parts as real series.

Hint
Write out i,−1,−i,1,i,…i, -1, -i, 1, i, \dots and separate even and odd nn.

Solution

∣in/n∣=1/n|i^n/n| = 1/n, so ∑∣un∣\sum |u_n| diverges: not absolutely convergent. For odd n=2k+1n = 2k+1, in=(−1)kii^n = (-1)^k i; for even n=2kn = 2k, in=(−1)ki^n = (-1)^k. So the real part is ∑k≥1(−1)k/(2k)=−12+14−16+⋯\sum_{k \ge 1} (-1)^k/(2k) = -\tfrac12 + \tfrac14 - \tfrac16 + \cdots and the imaginary part is ∑k≥0(−1)k/(2k+1)=1−13+15−⋯\sum_{k\ge0} (-1)^k/(2k+1) = 1 - \tfrac13 + \tfrac15 - \cdots. Both converge by the alternating series test, so ∑in/n\sum i^n/n converges. (Their sums turn out to be −12log⁡2-\tfrac12\log 2 and π/4\pi/4; in the figure, this is θ=π/2\theta = \pi/2, s=1s = 1.)

Exercise Domination in the plane ●○○ Hardy: §197

Show that ∑zn/n2\sum z^n/n^2 is absolutely convergent for every ∣z∣≤1|z| \le 1, and that ∑zn/n!\sum z^n/n! is absolutely convergent for every complex zz.

Hint
For the second, apply d’Alembert’s ratio test (§175) to ∣z∣n/n!|z|^n/n!.

Solution

For ∣z∣≤1|z| \le 1: ∣zn/n2∣≤1/n2|z^n/n^2| \le 1/n^2, and ∑1/n2\sum 1/n^2 converges.

For any z≠0z \ne 0: with un=∣z∣n/n!u_n = |z|^n/n!, un+1/un=∣z∣/(n+1)→0<1u_{n+1}/u_n = |z|/(n+1) \to 0 < 1, so ∑∣z∣n/n!\sum |z|^n/n! converges by the ratio test; for z=0z = 0 there is nothing to prove. By the theorem both complex series converge absolutely. This is the first example of §198.

Exercise The terms must tend to zero ●○○ Hardy: §197

Show that if a complex series ∑un\sum u_n converges then un→0u_n \to 0. Deduce that ∑zn\sum z^n does not converge when ∣z∣≥1|z| \ge 1.

Solution

un=sn−sn−1u_n = s_n - s_{n-1}, and both sns_n and sn−1s_{n-1} tend to the sum ss, so un→s−s=0u_n \to s - s = 0. If ∣z∣≥1|z| \ge 1 then ∣zn∣=∣z∣n≥1|z^n| = |z|^n \ge 1 for every nn, so zn↛0z^n \not\to 0 and ∑zn\sum z^n cannot converge. (For ∣z∣<1|z| < 1 it converges absolutely, being dominated by the geometric series ∑∣z∣n\sum |z|^n.)

Check yourself

Check yourself True or false?

A complex series converges if and only if its real part and its imaginary part both converge.

Why

True: a complex sequence (here, of partial sums) converges if and only if its real and imaginary parts converge, and the partial sums of the real part are the real parts of the partial sums.

Check yourself Choose one

Which condition is equivalent to the absolute convergence of ∑(vn+iwn)\sum (v_n + iw_n)?

Why

That is the theorem. The first option is plain convergence, which allows conditional convergence of the parts. The third is again only convergence of the series. The fourth is necessary for convergence but far from sufficient.

Check yourself True or false?

If the partial sums of a complex series stay inside a bounded region of the plane, the path they trace has finite length.

Why

False. For ∑einθ/n\sum e^{in\theta}/n (with θ\theta not a multiple of 2π2\pi) the partial sums converge, so they are bounded, but the length is ∑1/n=∞\sum 1/n = \infty. Finite length is absolute convergence, which is stronger.

Hardy’s language

Summary

Summary
  • ∑(vn+iwn)\sum (v_n + iw_n) converges if and only if ∑vn\sum v_n and ∑wn\sum w_n both converge.
  • It is absolutely convergent if and only if ∑∣un∣\sum |u_n| converges: the path of partial sums has finite length.
  • Absolutely convergent complex series converge, satisfy ∣∑un∣≤∑∣un∣|\sum u_n| \le \sum |u_n|, and may be rearranged freely.
  • So every test for positive series, applied to ∣un∣|u_n|, tests complex series; Dirichlet’s test also carries over.