Chapter IV · Limits of functions of a positive integral variable
Limits of complex sequences and series
A complex sequence converges when its real and imaginary parts do, or equivalently when its distance from the limit tends to zero; all the real theorems carry over.
Why this matters
Chapter III built the complex numbers; this chapter has so far dealt only with real sequences. The two meet in §85 and §86, and the meeting is needed at once: the next lesson studies and for complex , and Chapter X builds , and from complex series. The good news is that no new theory is required. A complex sequence is a pair of real sequences, and closeness in the plane can be measured by the modulus, which behaves like the absolute value.
The idea
Write each term as with and real. Plotting in the Argand diagram gives a sequence of points in the plane. “ is close to ” can be read in two ways: the point is in a small square around (both coordinates are close), or in a small disc around (the distance is small). Since every disc around contains a square around , and every square a disc, the two readings give the same notion of limit.
Try this. For , shrink and compare the three values of in the read-out: for the disc, for the real part alone, and for the imaginary part alone. Then look at , at the partial sums of , and finally at .
- φ(1), …, φ(40)
- disc |z − l| < δ
- square: |Re(z − l)| < δ and |Im(z − l)| < δ
What to notice
The disc’s is always at least as large as the other two, because the disc fits inside the square; but it is never much larger, because a slightly smaller square fits inside the disc. The partial sums of spiral into , and the real and imaginary parts each converge on their own. For the modulus is always but both parts oscillate: no limit.
Precise statements
Let with , real. If and , then converges to the limit , and we write .
A series of complex terms is convergent with sum if converges to and to ; equivalently, if its partial sums converge to .
For complex sequences Hardy does not try to classify the ways of failing to converge (divergence, finite or infinite oscillation) as he did for real ones: with two real parts behaving independently there are too many combinations. When needed he says what the real and imaginary parts do.
For complex sequences and series: changing the start (a shift , adding or removing finitely many terms of a series) does not affect convergence; limits of sums, constant multiples and products are the sums, multiples and products of the limits; the sum of two convergent series converges to the sum of the sums; the terms of a convergent series tend to ; and brackets may be inserted in a convergent series.
if and only if . More generally, if and only if .
So the familiar definition survives word for word: if for every there is with for , where now is the modulus.
Theorems 1 and 2 of §§83–84 hold for complex sequences and series: converges if and only if for every there is with whenever .
Proofs
Everything rests on two inequalities between a complex number and its parts, which say that the disc and the square nest inside each other:
The first two hold because ; the third because .
Apply the three inequalities to , whose real and imaginary parts are and .
If the parts converge, so does the modulus
If and , then (sum of two null sequences). Since , also .
If the modulus converges to , so do the parts
and . If the right-hand side is less than from on, so is each left-hand side.
Conclude
By the definition, means and , which by the two steps is equivalent to . The case is (10).
As an example of the theorems in (1)–(9), here is the product rule, the one Hardy works out.
Multiply out in real and imaginary parts and use the real theorems on each part.
Set up
Let and . Then .
Real part
By the real theorems on sums and products, .
Imaginary part
Similarly .
Conclude
So .
Necessity is the triangle inequality for the modulus. For sufficiency, the real and imaginary parts inherit Cauchy’s condition from , because each part of a complex number is at most its modulus; then use the real theorem on each part.
Necessary
If , choose with for . Then .
The parts satisfy the real condition
for , and the same for .
Sufficient
By the real criterion, tends to some and to some , so .
Worked examples and exercises
Show that , and that has no limit.
Hint
Solution
, so by (10).
The values of cycle through , so its real part runs through , which oscillates. Since the real part has no limit, neither has . Note that for every : a modulus that converges says nothing about the sequence itself unless its limit is .
Show that if , then and .
Hint
Solution
, so . The conjugate has real part and imaginary part , so .
The converse of the first statement is false: , but has no limit.
Show that the terms of a convergent complex series tend to , and deduce that does not converge.
Hint
Solution
If , then by (1), and by (3) and (4). Since does not tend to , does not tend to (by (10)), so cannot converge.
Find the sum of by splitting it into real and imaginary parts.
Hint
Solution
The even powers give the real terms , a geometric series with ratio and sum . The odd powers give the imaginary terms , with sum . (Strictly, the real and imaginary parts of the -th term are for odd and even respectively, and dropping zero terms does not affect convergence or sum.) So the sum is , which agrees with , the formula of the next lesson: .
Check yourself
If converges, then converges.
False: for every , but circles round for ever. The modulus throws away the direction. Theorem (10) only works for the limit , where the direction does not matter; in general one must use , which needs a candidate .
Suppose and . What is the best bound this gives for ?
. The cruder bound used in the proof is also fine for proving limits: any bound that tends to will do.
Why does Hardy not define “oscillates finitely” and “diverges to ” for complex sequences?
Each part could converge, diverge to , or oscillate finitely or infinitely, independently of the other. Instead Hardy describes the parts separately when needed. (Some later books do say “” when ; Hardy uses that idea in Chapter X.)
Hardy’s language
Summary
- means and .
- Equivalently : the definition of a limit reads as before, with the modulus for the absolute value. Discs and squares around nest inside each other.
- All the algebra of limits, the theorems on series, and Cauchy’s criterion hold for complex sequences.
- A convergent modulus does not make the sequence converge (), except when the limit of the modulus is .