Chapter VIII · The convergence of infinite series and infinite integrals
Chapter VIII problems
Ten of Hardy’s Miscellaneous Examples on Chapter VIII, from comparison tests to power series and infinite integrals, with graded hints and full solutions.
How to use this page
These problems come from the Miscellaneous Examples at the end of Hardy’s Chapter VIII, chosen to cover the whole chapter: series of positive terms, telescoping sums, conditional convergence, power series, multiplication of series, recurrences and infinite integrals. Each is restated briefly; Hardy’s wording is in the book. Try each one before opening the first hint, and open the hints one at a time: the first only points in a direction, the last is nearly a solution. Dots show difficulty (one: routine; three: needs a real idea).
Series of positive terms
For which real does converge?
Hint
Hint
Solution
Write . Rationalising each bracket,
Each of the three factors in the denominator is , so and . The terms are all negative, and , so by comparison (in the limit form of §173) the series converges if and only if does, that is, if and only if :
Show that .
Hint
Hint
Solution
Evaluating the numerator over the other factors at each root of the denominator: at , ; at , ; at , ; at , . So
Both brackets telescope. , and . Hence the sum is .
Prove that .
Hint
Solution
Since decreases, for . Summing (and keeping the term separately on the right),
Multiplying by : , and the right-hand side tends to . So is about : it blows up exactly as fast as the integral does when .
Find the sum of , where
for every real for which the series converges.
Hint
Hint
Solution
For ,
so and . (For real the denominators never vanish: and have the same sign.)
- If , then , so and the sum is .
- If , every and the sum is .
- If , , and the partial sums alternate between and : the series oscillates finitely.
Signs, cancellation and rearrangement
Let be real. Discuss the convergence of
Hint
Hint
Solution
If every term is ; take , and by symmetry ( is odd, even) .
- for and , so by comparison with the series diverges (to ; to if ).
- : absolutely convergent.
- For , where increases, so decreases steadily to : convergent by the alternating series test, and only conditionally, by case 1.
- : convergent (absolutely).
- Here with . Since and for small , increases near ; so decreases steadily for large , and . The series is convergent, but only conditionally, since diverges like .
Show that , in which successive blocks of terms of the same sign have terms, converges; but that if the blocks have terms the series oscillates finitely.
Hint
Hint
Solution
Reduction. Let be the sum of the moduli of the -th block and the partial sum at the end of block . Inside block all terms have one sign, so every partial sum in it lies between and . Hence the series converges iff converges, and it is bounded iff is bounded.
Blocks . Block consists of for , where and . Comparing with ,
The two bounds differ by , and . So with . Then : the first converges by the alternating series test, the second absolutely. So converges, and so does the series.
Blocks . Block consists of for , so with . Now , so decreases. Comparing with again, for , so . By Examples LXXVIII, 5, oscillates finitely: its partial sums are bounded but the even and odd ones have limits differing by . By the reduction, the original series oscillates finitely too.
Power series and multiplication
Discuss the convergence of for complex .
Hint
Hint
Solution
With , , so the radius of convergence is (§200): absolute convergence for , no convergence for .
On the circle write , , so the series is with . Each factor is less than , so decreases. Since , , so . Since for and , , so diverges.
- At (): diverges.
- At every other point of the circle: the partial sums of are bounded by , and decreases steadily to , so the series converges by Dirichlet’s test (§196); it is not absolutely convergent, since diverges. (At this is the alternating series test.)
So the series converges exactly on the closed disc with the point removed, absolutely only inside. (Its sum is , a binomial series.)
Let , , and . Show that (i) converges to a sum ; (ii) ; (iii) oscillates finitely; (iv) ; (v) oscillates finitely.
Hint
Hint
Solution
(i), (ii). decreases steadily to , so converges (§195), and .
(iii). As in Examples LXXXI, 9, with . For an upper bound, put and , so . For , , so these terms total at most ; the terms with are the same by symmetry. So with alternating signs: bounded, and not convergent. (In fact .)
(iv). is the sum of over all . Grouping by : for each the run from to , giving .
(v). Write with . Then
by the estimate of (iii) (with ). So is bounded. It does not converge, because its terms do not tend to . Hence oscillates finitely: the Cauchy product of with itself oscillates, although .
A player scores for each head and for each tail of a fair coin, and plays until the score reaches or passes . Show that the probability of hitting exactly is .
Hint
Hint
Solution
The total is hit exactly iff either is hit and the next toss is a head, or is hit and the next toss is a tail. So (), , .
Since , converges absolutely for . Multiplying by (a product of power series, §202), every coefficient from on vanishes by the recurrence, and the first two are and . So
for . By the uniqueness of power series (§201), . As , : the average step is , and a random walk with that step hits a given total about of the time.
Infinite integrals
Show that for
Hint
Hint
Solution
The two integrands are equal because . The integral converges: the integrand is continuous on and , so it is less than , integrable at for .
Put , which increases from to as goes from to . Then , so and . By the substitution rule for infinite integrals (§186),
Where to go next
Chapter IX defines the logarithm, the exponential and the circular functions and expands them in power series. Almost every tool of this chapter is used there: the integral test for , the ratio test for , the multiplication theorem for , and the alternating series test and Abel’s theorem for the logarithmic and arctangent series on their circles of convergence.