Chapter VIII · The convergence of infinite series and infinite integrals

The circle of convergence and uniqueness

§§200–201 35 min

Every power series has a radius of convergence R; it converges absolutely inside the circle |z| = R and not at all outside, with anything possible on the circle; and a function has at most one power series.

Why this matters

The previous lesson showed that convergence of a power series at one point spreads inwards. §200 pushes this to its conclusion: the region of convergence is always a disc, the inside of the circle of convergence, possibly together with some points of its boundary. This one number, the radius RR, is the first thing to find about any power series, and the ratio and root tests usually find it at once. §201 then proves that the coefficients of a power series are determined by its sum, which is what makes “the power series of a function” a meaningful phrase.

The idea

Fix a series and walk out from 00 along the positive real axis. By Theorem B, once the series fails to converge at some point rr, it fails at every point beyond it (otherwise convergence further out would spread back to rr). So the points of the positive axis split into an initial stretch where the series converges and a final stretch where it does not, separated by a single number RR. Theorem B again, applied in every direction, turns the stretch [0,R)[0, R) into the open disc ∣z∣<R|z| < R.

On the circle ∣z∣=R|z| = R itself, the argument is silent, and the examples show that it has to be.

Explore Inside, outside, and on the circle

Try this. Drag zz around inside the green circle, then outside it, for ∑zn\sum z^n. Then drag it onto the circle (it snaps there) and compare four series: ∑zn\sum z^n, the logarithmic series (try zz near −1-1), ∑zn/n2\sum z^n/n^2, and the binomial series. Use N=1000N = 1000 on the circle.

1+z+z2+⋯1 + z + z^2 + \cdots
z-plane: drag z
Re zIm z
w-plane: partial sums s₀, s₁, …, s_N
ReIm
  • circle of convergence, R = 1
  • z, and the partial sum s_N
  • path of partial sums
  • the sum f(z)
z = 0.6+0.45i0.6 + 0.45i. |z| = 0.75 < R = 1: the series converges absolutely, and the path homes in on the sum 1.1034+1.2414i1.1034 + 1.2414i.
What to notice

Inside, the path of partial sums closes in on the sum f(z)f(z); outside, the terms grow and the path runs off. On the circle the four series behave in four ways: ∑zn\sum z^n never converges; the logarithmic series converges everywhere except at z=−1z = -1, though the path is infinitely long; ∑zn/n2\sum z^n/n^2 and the binomial series converge absolutely all round the circle.

Precise statements

Theorem The circle of convergence Hardy: §200

A power series ∑anzn\sum a_n z^n either

  1. converges for z=0z = 0 and for no other zz; or
  2. converges absolutely for every zz; or
  3. converges absolutely for every zz with ∣z∣<R|z| < R, and does not converge for any zz with ∣z∣>R|z| > R, for a certain number R>0R > 0.

In case 3 the circle ∣z∣=R|z| = R is the circle of convergence and RR the radius of convergence. It is convenient to say R=0R = 0 in case 1 and R=∞R = \infty in case 2. The theorem gives no information about points on the circle.

Theorem Finding the radius Hardy: Examples LXXX, 3

If ∣an+1∣/∣an∣→λ|a_{n+1}|/|a_n| \to \lambda, or if ∣an∣1/n→λ|a_n|^{1/n} \to \lambda, then the radius of convergence is R=1/λR = 1/\lambda (meaning R=∞R = \infty if λ=0\lambda = 0, and R=0R = 0 if λ=∞\lambda = \infty).

Theorem Behaviour near the centre Hardy: §201

If ∑anzn\sum a_n z^n has radius of convergence R>0R > 0 and sum f(z)f(z) for ∣z∣<R|z| < R, then for every m≥0m \ge 0

f(z)=a0+a1z+⋯+amzm+O(∣z∣m+1)(z→0).f(z) = a_0 + a_1 z + \cdots + a_m z^m + O(|z|^{m+1}) \qquad (z \to 0).
Corollary Uniqueness of power series Hardy: §201

If ∑anzn=∑bnzn\sum a_n z^n = \sum b_n z^n for all zz with ∣z∣<μ|z| < \mu (some μ>0\mu > 0), then an=bna_n = b_n for every nn. The same function cannot be represented by two different power series. It is even enough that the two sums agree for real positive zz near 00.

Proofs

Hardy splits the positive real axis into two classes, as in a Dedekind section (§17). The same argument can be put in terms of a supremum.

Proof The circle of convergence
Strategy

Define RR as the supremum of the radii r≥0r \ge 0 at which the series converges, and use Theorem B to show that the series converges absolutely inside ∣z∣=R|z| = R and not at all outside.

Define RR

Let SS be the set of real r≥0r \ge 0 at which ∑anrn\sum a_n r^n converges; 0∈S0 \in S. Put R=sup⁡SR = \sup S, with R=∞R = \infty if SS is unbounded. Case 1 is R=0R = 0, case 2 is R=∞R = \infty.

Absolute convergence inside

Let ∣z∣<R|z| < R. Since ∣z∣|z| is less than the supremum, some r∈Sr \in S has r>∣z∣r > |z|. The series converges at rr, so by Theorem B it converges absolutely at zz.

No convergence outside

Let ∣z∣>R|z| > R and suppose the series converged at zz. Choose a real rr with R<r<∣z∣R < r < |z|. By Theorem B the series would converge (absolutely) at rr, so r∈Sr \in S and r≤Rr \le R, a contradiction.

The three cases

If R=0R = 0, the second step is empty and the third says the series converges only at 00. If R=∞R = \infty, the third step is empty and the second gives absolute convergence everywhere. Otherwise we are in case 3.

Proof Finding the radius by the ratio test
Strategy

Apply d’Alembert’s test to the moduli ∣anzn∣|a_n z^n|.

The ratio of consecutive terms

For z≠0z \ne 0: ∣an+1zn+1∣∣anzn∣=∣an+1∣∣an∣ ∣z∣→λ∣z∣\dfrac{|a_{n+1}z^{n+1}|}{|a_n z^n|} = \dfrac{|a_{n+1}|}{|a_n|}\,|z| \to \lambda|z|.

Inside

If λ∣z∣<1\lambda|z| < 1, the ratio test (§175) makes ∑∣anzn∣\sum |a_n z^n| converge.

Outside

If λ∣z∣>1\lambda|z| > 1, the ratio exceeds 11 from some nn on, so ∣anzn∣|a_n z^n| increases from then on and cannot tend to 00; the series cannot converge.

Conclude

The series converges absolutely for ∣z∣<1/λ|z| < 1/\lambda and does not converge for ∣z∣>1/λ|z| > 1/\lambda, so R=1/λR = 1/\lambda. The root test (§174) gives the same with ∣anzn∣1/n→λ∣z∣|a_n z^n|^{1/n} \to \lambda|z|.

Proof Behaviour near the centre, and uniqueness
Strategy

The tail ∑n>manzn\sum_{n > m} a_n z^n is dominated, near 00, by a geometric series whose first term is of size ∣z∣m+1|z|^{m+1}.

A bound on the coefficients

Fix μ\mu with 0<μ<R0 < \mu < R. The series converges at μ\mu, so its terms are bounded: ∣an∣μn≤K|a_n|\mu^n \le K for all nn.

Estimate the tail

For ∣z∣<μ|z| < \mu,

∣f(z)−∑n=0manzn∣≤∑n>m∣an∣∣z∣n≤K∑n>m(∣z∣μ)n=K∣z∣m+1μm(μ−∣z∣).\Big|f(z) - \sum_{n=0}^{m} a_n z^n\Big| \le \sum_{n > m} |a_n||z|^n \le K\sum_{n>m}\Big(\frac{|z|}{\mu}\Big)^n = \frac{K|z|^{m+1}}{\mu^m(\mu - |z|)} .

For ∣z∣≤μ/2|z| \le \mu/2 the right-hand side is at most 2Kμm+1∣z∣m+1\dfrac{2K}{\mu^{m+1}}|z|^{m+1}, which is O(∣z∣m+1)O(|z|^{m+1}).

Uniqueness

Let cn=an−bnc_n = a_n - b_n, so that ∑cnzn=0\sum c_n z^n = 0 for ∣z∣<μ|z| < \mu. If not all cnc_n were 00, let cmc_m be the first that is not. By the previous step applied to ∑cnzn\sum c_n z^n (whose sum is 00), 0=cmzm+O(∣z∣m+1)0 = c_m z^m + O(|z|^{m+1}). Dividing by zmz^m gives cm=O(∣z∣)c_m = O(|z|), and letting z→0z \to 0 (along the positive reals, if we like) gives cm=0c_m = 0: a contradiction.

The figure below is the logarithmic series of Examples LXXX, 4. Its radius is 11, and it shows the most delicate behaviour possible on the circle.

Explore The logarithmic series on its circle

Try this. With zz on the circle, move it slowly towards −1-1 from above, with N=1000N = 1000. Then go back inside the circle.

z−z22+z33−⋯z - \tfrac{z^2}{2} + \tfrac{z^3}{3} - \cdots
z-plane: drag z
Re zIm z
w-plane: partial sums s₀, s₁, …, s_N
ReIm
  • circle of convergence, R = 1
  • z, and the partial sum s_N
  • path of partial sums
  • the sum f(z)
z = −0.8+0.6i-0.8 + 0.6i. z is on the circle of convergence: the series converges here (conditionally, by Dirichlet’s test), although the path has infinite length.
What to notice

Everywhere on the circle except −1-1 the path spirals in to log⁡(1+z)\log(1 + z), the hollow point; the closer zz is to −1-1, the further away that point is and the slower the spiral. At z=−1z = -1 itself the series is −(1+12+13+⋯ )-(1 + \tfrac12 + \tfrac13 + \cdots) and diverges.

Worked examples and exercises

Exercise A geometric series ●○○ Hardy: Examples LXXX, 1

Let a>0a > 0. Show that 1+az+a2z2+⋯1 + az + a^2z^2 + \cdots has radius of convergence 1/a1/a, and that it does not converge anywhere on its circle of convergence: it diverges at z=1/az = 1/a and oscillates finitely at the other points of the circle.

Hint
Put w=azw = az. On the circle, ∣w∣=1|w| = 1.

Solution

With w=azw = az the series is ∑wn\sum w^n, which converges exactly when ∣w∣<1|w| < 1, that is ∣z∣<1/a|z| < 1/a. So R=1/aR = 1/a. On the circle ∣w∣=1|w| = 1 and the terms have modulus 11, so the series cannot converge. At w=1w = 1 (that is, z=1/az = 1/a) it is 1+1+⋯1 + 1 + \cdots, which diverges. At any other ww on the unit circle, ∣1+w+⋯+wn∣=∣1−wn+1∣/∣1−w∣≤2/∣1−w∣|1 + w + \cdots + w^{n}| = |1 - w^{n+1}|/|1 - w| \le 2/|1 - w|: bounded partial sums without a limit, finite oscillation.

Exercise Radii by the ratio test ●○○ Hardy: Examples LXXX, 2–3

Find the radius of convergence of (i) ∑zn/n2\sum z^n/n^2, (ii) ∑zn/(2n+3n)\sum z^n/(2^n + 3^n), (iii) ∑nnzn\sum n^n z^n. For (i), describe what happens on the circle.

Hint
(ii): divide numerator and denominator of the ratio by 3n3^n. (iii): use the root test.

Solution

(i) ∣an+1/an∣=n2/(n+1)2→1|a_{n+1}/a_n| = n^2/(n+1)^2 \to 1, so R=1R = 1. On ∣z∣=1|z| = 1, ∣zn/n2∣=1/n2|z^n/n^2| = 1/n^2, so the series converges absolutely at every point of the circle (Examples LXXX, 2).

(ii) an+1an=2n+3n2n+1+3n+1=(2/3)n+12(2/3)n+3→13\dfrac{a_{n+1}}{a_n} = \dfrac{2^n + 3^n}{2^{n+1} + 3^{n+1}} = \dfrac{(2/3)^n + 1}{2(2/3)^n + 3} \to \tfrac13, so R=3R = 3.

(iii) ∣an∣1/n=n→∞|a_n|^{1/n} = n \to \infty, so R=0R = 0: the series converges only at z=0z = 0.

Exercise The logarithmic series ●●○ Hardy: Examples LXXX, 4

Show that z−12z2+13z3−⋯z - \tfrac12 z^2 + \tfrac13 z^3 - \cdots has radius of convergence 11, converges at every point of the circle ∣z∣=1|z| = 1 except z=−1z = -1, and is not absolutely convergent anywhere on the circle.

Hint
On the circle write z=cos⁡θ+isin⁡θz = \cos\theta + i\sin\theta, and look at the real and imaginary parts as series of the kind treated in the previous lesson.
Hint
(−1)n−1cos⁡nθ=−cos⁡n(θ+π)(-1)^{n-1}\cos n\theta = -\cos n(\theta + \pi).

Solution

∣an+1/an∣=n/(n+1)→1|a_{n+1}/a_n| = n/(n+1) \to 1, so R=1R = 1. On the circle ∣anzn∣=1/n|a_n z^n| = 1/n, so there is no absolute convergence there. With z=cos⁡θ+isin⁡θz = \cos\theta + i\sin\theta the real and imaginary parts are

∑(−1)n−1cos⁡nθn=−∑cos⁡n(θ+π)n,∑(−1)n−1sin⁡nθn=−∑sin⁡n(θ+π)n.\sum \frac{(-1)^{n-1}\cos n\theta}{n} = -\sum\frac{\cos n(\theta + \pi)}{n}, \qquad \sum \frac{(-1)^{n-1}\sin n\theta}{n} = -\sum\frac{\sin n(\theta + \pi)}{n} .

By Dirichlet’s test (§196, Examples LXXIX, 3 with s=1s = 1) both converge unless θ+π\theta + \pi is a multiple of 2π2\pi (for the cosine series), that is, unless z=−1z = -1. At z=−1z = -1 the series is −1−12−13−⋯-1 - \tfrac12 - \tfrac13 - \cdots, which diverges to −∞-\infty.

Exercise Even functions ●●○ Hardy: §201

Suppose f(z)=∑anznf(z) = \sum a_n z^n for ∣z∣<R|z| < R and f(−z)=f(z)f(-z) = f(z) there. Show that an=0a_n = 0 for every odd nn.

Hint
Write down the power series of f(−z)f(-z) and use uniqueness.

Solution

For ∣z∣<R|z| < R, f(−z)=∑an(−z)n=∑(−1)nanznf(-z) = \sum a_n(-z)^n = \sum (-1)^n a_n z^n. Since f(−z)=f(z)f(-z) = f(z), the two power series ∑(−1)nanzn\sum (-1)^n a_n z^n and ∑anzn\sum a_n z^n have the same sum on the disc ∣z∣<R|z| < R, so by uniqueness (−1)nan=an(-1)^n a_n = a_n for every nn. For odd nn this gives an=−ana_n = -a_n, so an=0a_n = 0. (Example: the series for cos⁡z\cos z, which you will meet in Chapter IX, contains only even powers.)

Check yourself

Check yourself Enter a number

What is the radius of convergence of ∑n≥0n23n zn\sum_{n\ge0} \dfrac{n^2}{3^n}\,z^n?

Why

∣an+1∣∣an∣=(n+1)23n2→13\dfrac{|a_{n+1}|}{|a_n|} = \dfrac{(n+1)^2}{3n^2} \to \tfrac13, so R=3R = 3. Polynomial factors such as n2n^2 never change the radius.

Check yourself Choose one

A power series has radius of convergence 11. What can you conclude about its behaviour at z=1z = 1?

Why

On the circle everything is possible: ∑zn/n2\sum z^n/n^2 converges at 11, ∑zn\sum z^n diverges there, and ∑zn/n\sum z^n/n diverges at 11 but converges at −1-1, which also rules out the last option.

Check yourself True or false?

The set of points where a power series converges is always an open disc (or the whole plane, or the single point 00).

Why

False: the set always contains the open disc and lies inside the closed disc, but it may include some, all or none of the boundary circle. For the logarithmic series it is the closed disc minus the single point −1-1.

Check yourself True or false?

If two power series have the same sum for every real xx with 0<x<0.0010 < x < 0.001, their coefficients are equal.

Why

True. Hardy notes that the estimate f(z)=∑n≤manzn+O(∣z∣m+1)f(z) = \sum_{n \le m} a_n z^n + O(|z|^{m+1}) holds in particular for real positive zz, and the uniqueness proof only lets z→0z \to 0, so agreement on any interval (0,ϵ)(0, \epsilon) is enough.

Hardy’s language

Summary

Summary
  • Every power series has a radius of convergence R∈[0,∞]R \in [0, \infty]: absolute convergence for ∣z∣<R|z| < R, no convergence for ∣z∣>R|z| > R.
  • On the circle ∣z∣=R|z| = R anything can happen: ∑zn\sum z^n (nowhere), the logarithmic series (everywhere except −1-1), ∑zn/n2\sum z^n/n^2 (everywhere, absolutely).
  • If ∣an+1/an∣→λ|a_{n+1}/a_n| \to \lambda or ∣an∣1/n→λ|a_n|^{1/n} \to \lambda, then R=1/λR = 1/\lambda.
  • Near 00, f(z)=a0+⋯+amzm+O(∣z∣m+1)f(z) = a_0 + \cdots + a_m z^m + O(|z|^{m+1}); hence a function has at most one power series about 00.