Displacements in the plane are added by the parallelogram rule; asking what their product should be leads, through similar triangles, to one inevitable formula.
Why this matters
Before there are complex numbers there must be something for them to be. Hardy’s answer is the displacement: a move in the plane, recorded by the pair of numbers [x,y]. Adding displacements is natural. Multiplying them is not, and this lesson follows Hardy’s argument that there is essentially one good way to do it. The formula that comes out, [x,y][x′,y′]=[xx′−yy′,xy′+yx′], is the multiplication of complex numbers, discovered rather than postulated.
The idea
A real number x can be read in several ways: as a length, as the label of a point on a line, or as a move along the line by x units, forwards if x>0 and backwards if x<0. Hardy fixes on the last reading (§34). A move does not care where it starts: “three steps forward” is the same instruction wherever you stand. So the displacement from P to Q is determined by its length and its sense alone, and he writes it [x].
In the plane a move needs a direction as well. Two moves PQ and RS are counted as the same displacement if PQ and RS are equal in length, parallel, and run the same way. Slide PQ so that it starts at the origin O; it ends at a point A=(x,y), and the pair [x,y] records the move completely. If P=(ξ,η) and Q=(ξ′,η′) then PQ=[ξ′−ξ,η′−η].
Adding two moves means doing one and then the other (§36). Draw the second one starting where the first one ended: the result is the diagonal of a parallelogram, and its coordinates are the sums of the coordinates.
Multiplying is a real question. Hardy asks what any sensible product of displacements should satisfy (§37):
the product of two displacements is a displacement;
it agrees with the multiplication by numbers we already have: a real number α is the move [α,0] along the axis, and [α,0][x,y] should be α[x,y]=[αx,αy];
it obeys the commutative, associative and distributive laws.
The obvious guess [x,y][x′,y′]=[xx′,yy′] fails rule 2 at once: it gives [α,0][x,y]=[αx,0], not [αx,αy].
Hardy’s idea (§38) comes from similar triangles. Let A=(1,0) be the unit move. If triangles OAB and OCD are similar, then OD/OC=OB/OA, that is, OD=OB⋅OC when OA=1. So define the product OB⋅OC to be OD, where D is found by building on OC a triangle similar to OAB. There are two such triangles, mirror images of each other; take the one in which the angle COD equals the angle AOBwith its sign, so that the triangles are similar in the same sense.
ExploreAdd, then multiply, two displacements
Try this.Start in Add mode and drag B and C: check that the sum is the far corner of the parallelogram. Switch to Multiply. Drag B onto the positive x-axis, then onto the negative x-axis, and watch D. Then switch on the triangle in the opposite sense and put C on the x-axis.
xy
OB (drag B)
OC (drag C)
OB + OC
Operation
OB=[1.4,0.6],OC=[0.8,1.3] Sum: [1.4,0.6]+[0.8,1.3]=[2.2,1.9]. Going along OB and then along a copy of OC ends at the same point as going along OC first: the two routes are the two halves of the parallelogram.
What to notice
When B=(α,0) is on the axis, the triangle OAB is flat and D is just C stretched by α: rule 2 holds. In general D is C turned through the angle of B and stretched by its length. The mirror-image triangle gives a point D′ that, with C=(α,0) on the axis, is B reflected and stretched rather than α times B, and that changes when you swap the roles of B and C. That is why the sense of the angle matters.
Precise statements
DefinitionDisplacements and their equivalenceHardy: §§34–35 (1)
The displacement[x,y] is the move that carries the point (a,b) to (a+x,b+y), whatever (a,b) is. The displacement from (ξ,η) to (ξ′,η′) is [ξ′−ξ,η′−η], and
[x,y]=[x′,y′]if and only ifx=x′ and y=y′.
The zero displacement[0,0] is written 0.
DefinitionMultiplication by a number, addition, subtractionHardy: §§35–36 (2), (3), (5)
In particular [x,y]=[x,0]+[0,y]: the displacement is the resultant of its two components along the axes.
DefinitionProduct of two displacementsHardy: §38 (6)
Let A=(1,0), OB=[x,y] and OC=[x′,y′]. Construct on OC the triangle OCD similar to OAB in the same sense. The product is OB⋅OC=OD. In coordinates,
[x,y][x′,y′]=[xx′−yy′,xy′+yx′].
TheoremThe product behaves like a productHardy: §38
The product (6) satisfies Hardy’s three requirements: it is a displacement; [α,0][x,y]=[αx,αy]; and it is commutative, associative and distributive over addition.
Proofs
First, the geometric definition really does give the coordinate formula. The trick is to describe B and C by length and angle (polar coordinates), because similar triangles are about lengths and angles.
ProofFrom similar triangles to formula (6)
Strategy
Write B and C in polar coordinates. The similarity tells us the length and the angle of OD directly; then convert back with the addition formulas for cosine and sine.
Polar coordinates of B and C
Let B=(ρcosθ,ρsinθ) and C=(σcosϕ,σsinϕ), so x=ρcosθ, y=ρsinθ, x′=σcosϕ, y′=σsinϕ.
The length of OD is ρσ
Similarity of OCD and OAB gives OD/OC=OB/OA. With OA=1, OB=ρ and OC=σ, this is OD=ρσ.
The angle of OD is θ+ϕ
The angle COD equals the angle AOB, which is θ, with the same sign (same sense). Since OC makes the angle ϕ with the axis, OD makes the angle ϕ+θ.
Convert back to coordinates
D=(ρσcos(θ+ϕ),ρσsin(θ+ϕ)). Expanding,
ρσcos(θ+ϕ)=ρcosθσcosϕ−ρsinθσsinϕ=xx′−yy′ and
ρσsin(θ+ϕ)=ρsinθσcosϕ+ρcosθσsinϕ=yx′+xy′.
∎
Now the laws. Each one is a short computation with (6), and the polar picture from the last proof (“lengths multiply, angles add”) makes two of them obvious.
ProofThe product satisfies the requirements of §37
Strategy
Check each requirement against the formula [x,y][x′,y′]=[xx′−yy′,xy′+yx′], using polar form for associativity.
It is a displacement, and agrees with multiplication by numbers
The right-hand side is a pair of real numbers. With [x,y]=[α,0] it is [αx′−0,αy′+0]=[αx′,αy′]=α[x′,y′].
Commutative
Swapping (x,y) with (x′,y′) turns xx′−yy′ into x′x−y′y and xy′+yx′ into x′y+y′x: the same numbers.
Distributive
For fixed [x,y], both coordinates of the product are linear in (x′,y′). So multiplying [x,y] by [x′+x′′,y′+y′′] gives the sum of the products with [x′,y′] and with [x′′,y′′].
Associative
By the first proof, multiplying by OB multiplies lengths by OB and adds the angle of OB. In (OB⋅OC)⋅OE and in OB⋅(OC⋅OE) the length is OB⋅OC⋅OE and the angle is the sum of the three angles, in either order. Points with equal lengths and equal angles are equal.
∎
ExploreMultiplication as rotate and scale
Try this.In Multiply mode, keep B fixed and drag C around a full circle about O. Then put B at (0,1).
For a fixed B, the point D is always C turned through the angle AOB and stretched by the factor OB; the purple triangle is a scaled, turned copy of the blue one. With B=(0,1) the rule is a pure quarter turn, which is the first hint of i in the next lesson.
Worked examples and exercises
Exercise●○○Hardy: Examples XX, 1 (ii), (v)
Prove that addition of displacements is associative, and that α{[x,y]+[x′,y′]}=α[x,y]+α[x′,y′]. Say what each law means geometrically.
Hint
Reduce each side to a single bracket using the definitions, then compare coordinates.
Solution
Associativity.([x,y]+[x′,y′])+[x′′,y′′]=[(x+x′)+x′′,(y+y′)+y′′] and [x,y]+([x′,y′]+[x′′,y′′])=[x+(x′+x′′),y+(y′+y′′)]. The coordinates agree because addition of real numbers is associative. Geometrically: making three moves one after another lands you at the same point however you group them.
Distributivity.α([x,y]+[x′,y′])=α[x+x′,y+y′]=[αx+αx′,αy+αy′]=[αx,αy]+[αx′,αy′]. Geometrically: enlarging a parallelogram from O by the factor α gives a parallelogram, so the enlarged diagonal is the diagonal of the enlarged sides.
ExerciseDividing a segment in a given ratio●○○Hardy: Examples XX, 2
If M divides PQ so that PM:MQ=μ:λ (with λ+μ=0), show that
OM=λ+μλOP+λ+μμOQ. What does this say for the midpoint?
Hint
OM=OP+PM, and PM is a known multiple of PQ=OQ−OP.
Solution
Since M lies on PQ with PM:MQ=μ:λ, we have PM=λ+μμPQ. Hence
OM=OP+λ+μμ(OQ−OP)=λ+μλOP+λ+μμOQ.
For the midpoint, λ=μ and OM=21(OP+OQ): the midpoint’s coordinates are the averages of the endpoints’ coordinates.
ExerciseCentre of mass●○○Hardy: Examples XX, 3
Equal particles sit at P1,…,Pn, and G is their centre of mass. Show that OG=n1(OP1+⋯+OPn), and deduce that GP1+⋯+GPn=0.
Hint
The centre of mass of equal masses has as coordinates the averages of their coordinates. For the second part take O=G.
Solution
The centre of mass of equal particles at (xk,yk) is (n1∑xk,n1∑yk), which is exactly the coordinate form of OG=n1∑OPk. Since this holds for every choice of origin, take the origin at G itself: then OG=0, so ∑GPk=0. (Directly: GPk=OPk−OG, and summing gives ∑OPk−nOG=0.)
ExerciseCoordinates along two directions are unique●●○Hardy: Examples XX, 5
Let AB and AC be two displacements that are not in the same straight line. Show that if αAB+βAC=γAB+δAC then α=γ and β=δ.
Hint
Move everything to one side: (α−γ)AB=(δ−β)AC. What does it mean if a multiple of one is a multiple of the other?
Solution
The hypothesis gives (α−γ)AB=(δ−β)AC. If α=γ we could divide: AB=α−γδ−βAC, so B would lie on the line AC, contrary to hypothesis. Hence α=γ, so (δ−β)AC=0; since AC=0 (C=A, as the displacements are not collinear), δ=β. In words: every displacement can be written as a combination of two non-parallel ones in only one way, which is what makes “equate coefficients” a valid step in the next exercise.
ExerciseA trisection in a parallelogram●●○Hardy: Examples XX, 7
ABCD is a parallelogram and M is the midpoint of AB. Show that DM trisects AC and is trisected by it.
Hint
Put b=AB and d=AD, so AC=b+d and AM=21b. Write the general point of each line in terms of b and d.
Hint
A point of AC is t(b+d); a point of DM is d+s(21b−d). Equate the coefficients of b and d, using the last exercise.
Solution
With A as origin, the intersection P satisfies tb+td=2sb+(1−s)d. As b and d are not parallel, the coefficients agree: t=s/2 and t=1−s. So s=32 and t=31. Thus AP=31AC (DM cuts off a third of AC) and DP=32DM, so PM=31DM (AC cuts off a third of DM).
ExerciseCommutativity from the picture●●○Hardy: §38, Example
Show directly from the geometric definition, without coordinates, that OB⋅OC=OC⋅OB.
Hint
OB⋅OC=OD with OCD similar to OAB. The other product is OD1 with OBD1 similar to OAC. Show D1=D by checking that triangle OBD is similar to OAC.
Solution
Let OCD be similar to OAB in the same sense, so OD/OC=OB/OA and angle COD = angle AOB. Compare triangles OBD and OAC. Their angles at O: angle BOD = angle BOC + angle COD = angle BOC + angle AOB = angle AOC (signed angles add). Their sides at O: OD/OB=OC/OA, which is the same proportion OD⋅OA=OB⋅OC read the other way. Two triangles with one equal angle and the including sides in proportion are similar (here in the same sense), so OBD is similar to OAC. But OC⋅OB is defined as OD1 with OBD1 similar to OAC in the same sense, and that triangle is unique. Hence D1=D.
Check yourself
Check yourselfChoose one
P=(1,2), Q=(4,3), R=(−2,0), S=(1,1). Which is true?
Why
A displacement ignores its point of application: only length, direction and sense count, and these are recorded by the differences of coordinates, [4−1,3−2]=[3,1] and [1−(−2),1−0]=[3,1]. The third option confuses the displacement with the coordinates of its end point; that is only right when the start is O.
Check yourselfChoose one
Why does Hardy reject the definition [x,y][x′,y′]=[xx′,yy′]?
Why
The componentwise product is commutative, associative and distributive, and it is a pair of numbers, so it passes every test except one: it is inconsistent with the multiplication by real numbers we already had, once the real number α is identified with the move [α,0]. Requirement 2 is what forces the rotation into the definition.
Check yourselfEnter a number
Compute the first coordinate of [1,2][1,3].
Why
By (6) the product is [1⋅1−2⋅3,1⋅3+2⋅1]=[−5,5]. The minus sign in xx′−yy′ comes from the angle addition formula for cosine; in the next lesson it becomes i2=−1.
Check yourselfTrue or false?
In the construction of the product, it does not matter which of the two triangles on OC similar to OAB we choose.
Why
False. The mirror-image triangle gives the point D′ with length OB⋅OC and angle (angle of C) − (angle of B). That “product” is not commutative (swapping B and C reflects D′ in the axis), and when C=(α,0) is on the axis it gives D′=(αx,−αy) instead of α[x,y], so it cannot agree with multiplication by real numbers. The widget’s “opposite sense” switch shows both failures.
Hardy’s language
increasing experience of mathematics will reveal to him the great importance of distinguishing clearly between things which, however intimately connected, are not the same.
— G. H. Hardy, §34
Summary
Summary
A displacement [x,y] is a move in the plane; moves with the same length, direction and sense are equal, wherever they start.
Addition is “one move after the other”: the parallelogram rule, [x,y]+[x′,y′]=[x+x′,y+y′].
A good product must agree with multiplication by real numbers and obey the usual laws. Similar triangles in the same sense give one: lengths multiply and angles add.
In coordinates, [x,y][x′,y′]=[xx′−yy′,xy′+yx′]. The next lesson renames [x,y] as x+yi.