Chapter III problems
Eleven of Hardy's Miscellaneous Examples on complex numbers, on geometry, equations, identities and transformations, with graded hints and full solutions.
These problems are chosen from the Miscellaneous Examples at the end of Hardy’s Chapter III, for variety rather than difficulty. Some are Cambridge Tripos questions. Try each one for a while before opening the first hint; the hints go from a gentle nudge to most of the idea. Throughout, , so that and , and .
Geometry by complex numbers
Show that the triangle with vertices is equilateral if and only if .
Hint
Hint
Solution
The triangle is equilateral exactly when the side is the side turned through or (equal lengths, and an angle of at ; two equal sides enclosing force the third side to be equal too). Since and , this says or .
The first is , i.e. (as ). Likewise the second is . So the triangle is equilateral iff , by the factor theorem. By Examples XXII, 3 this product is . (The degenerate case also satisfies the equation.)
Triangles , , are drawn on the sides of a triangle , all similar to one another (in the same sense). Show that and have the same centroid.
Hint
Solution
Let be the common ratio. Then , , . Adding, . The centroids and coincide, whatever the shape of the triangles on the sides. (Napoleon’s theorem, about equilateral triangles on the sides, is a famous relative.)
For any four points of the plane, prove that . What happens when the points lie on a circle?
Hint
Hint
Solution
Expanding, the twelve products in cancel in pairs, so the sum is . Hence , and by the triangle inequality and , .
Concyclic points. Call the three products (in the order of the identity), so . The quotient is minus the cross ratio ; if the four points are on a circle, every cross ratio is real (Examples XXI, 25), so is real and then so is . Three real multiples of adding to : the largest in modulus is the sum of the moduli of the other two. That is Ptolemy’s theorem: for four concyclic points, one of the three products , , equals the sum of the other two. (Which one is decided by the order of the points on the circle: it is the product of the two “diagonals”, the pair of chords that cross; we do not prove this here.) Conversely, equality in the inequality forces to be positive real, so the points are concyclic or collinear.
Prove that , and state it as a theorem about parallelograms.
Hint
Solution
, since the cross terms cancel. In the parallelogram with sides and from , the diagonals are and : the sum of the squares of the diagonals equals the sum of the squares of the four sides. Equivalently (Hardy’s form), if is the midpoint of then .
Equations and identities
Show that both roots of have modulus if and only if , and (amplitudes not necessarily principal, and the last condition dropped when ).
Hint
Hint
Solution
Necessity. Let the roots be , . Then , so , and (multiply out the right side to check). So , and if an amplitude of is or ; doubling either gives up to , an amplitude of .
Sufficiency. If the roots are the two square roots of , of modulus . Otherwise let with ; the hypothesis gives . Putting : . The real quadratic has discriminant , so its roots are conjugate (or equal to when ) with product ; a conjugate pair with product has . Hence for both roots.
Prove that , and use it to solve .
Hint
Hint
Solution
By Examples XXII, 3, the product is , and multiplying out gives (the mixed terms cancel and appears three times).
Take , : then , which is our cubic. So it factorises as , and the roots are Check with : has roots , the cube roots of .
If ( a positive integer), show that and .
Hint
Solution
With , . On the other hand , so by De Moivre . Equate real and imaginary parts. (For : and .) Misc. Ex. 16 develops the same trick with other roots of unity: averaging over the -th roots of unity picks out every -th coefficient.
Transformations
If , show that describes a circle as varies, unless , when it describes a straight line. (Assume .)
Hint
Solution
The map is bilinear, since . (If then is constant.) By the theorem on bilinear transformations it sends the unit circle to a circle or a straight line, and to a straight line exactly when the circle passes through the pole , i.e. when . In that case the point itself has no image; as approaches it, runs off to infinity along the line.
Let and real. Show that makes the inside of the unit circle in the -plane correspond to the inside of the unit circle in the -plane if , and to the outside if .
Hint
Solution
Expanding with : Since , for we get when (the difference is positive) and when . For the difference is , so the unit circle corresponds to the unit circle; and as the map is bilinear (hence one-to-one), the inside of corresponds to the whole of the inside, or the whole of the outside, of . The pole is outside the disc when , as it must be.
Try this. The purple circle is . Look at its image, then shrink and grow the circle a little.
- circles |z| = r and their images
- rays arg z = θ and their images
- circle (drag centre and rim) and its image
- w = 0
The unit circle goes to a cardioid.
What to notice
The image has a cusp at , the image of , where the derivative vanishes: a cardioid. Slightly smaller circles give smooth curves, slightly larger ones a curve with a small loop.
Show that if , the circle corresponds to a cardioid in the -plane.
Hint
Hint
Solution
. For , (check by multiplying out), so In polar coordinates centred at the point , the point has radius and angle . That is the cardioid , with its cusp at (from ).
Try this. With the polar grid, look at the images of the blue circles . Drag the purple circle’s rim towards radius .
- circles |z| = r and their images
- rays arg z = θ and their images
- circle (drag centre and rim) and its image
- w = 0
Circles |z| = r ≠ 1 become ellipses; the unit circle collapses onto [−1, 1].
What to notice
Every circle with becomes an ellipse, and all these ellipses have the same foci . The unit circle itself is flattened onto the segment from to , traversed twice. The rays become hyperbolas with the same foci.
Show that maps the circles to the ellipses
, and that these all have the foci .
Hint
Solution
With : . So , with , , and (for ). The distance from centre to focus of this ellipse is , so the foci are for every : the ellipses are confocal. The circles and give the same ellipse; for the “ellipse” is the segment .