A complex number x+yi is the displacement [x,y] under a new name; its arithmetic follows the usual rules with i2=−1, and multiplying by i is a quarter turn.
The last lesson produced a sum and a product of displacements. This one gives them a better notation, x+yi, and shows that the notation is honest: with it, you calculate exactly as in school algebra, except that i2 is replaced by −1. Hardy also proves the two facts that make algebra work: you can divide by anything except 0, and a product is 0 only if a factor is 0. Finally he reads multiplication by i geometrically, as a turn through a right angle, which is the most useful single picture of complex numbers.
The idea
Hardy now writes x+yi for the pair [x,y] (§39). At this stage the + and the i are just ink: “x+yi” is a label for a displacement, and the label was chosen because it will turn out to calculate correctly. Sums and products of complex numbers are defined as the sums and products of the displacements from the last lesson:
Now look at three special cases. Pairs of the form x+0i add and multiply exactly like the real numbers x, so we may simply write x. Pairs 0+yi are written yi, and 0+1i is written i. And by the product rule,
i⋅i=(0+1i)(0+1i)=(0⋅0−1⋅1)+(0⋅1+1⋅0)i=−1.
So i2=−1 is not an assumption; it is what the similar-triangle product gives for the unit move along the y-axis multiplied by itself. Geometrically, i is the quarter turn: the triangle OAB with B=(0,1) has a right angle at O, so multiplying by i turns any displacement through 90∘ without stretching it. Two quarter turns make a half turn, and a half turn is multiplication by −1.
ExplorePowers of i
Try this.Here z=i and the widget plots 1,z,z2,z3,z4. Read off i2, i3 and i4. Then drag z a little way off i, keeping it on the unit circle.
ReIm
z (drag)
z, z², …, zⁿ
unit circle
z=i=1(cos1.57+isin1.57) De Moivre: z4=r4(cos4θ+isin4θ) with r=1, θ=1.57: each multiplication by z turns through θ and scales by r. z4=1.
What to notice
i,−1,−i,1: each multiplication by i is a quarter turn, so the powers cycle with period 4. For other points of the unit circle the powers still step round the circle by equal angles, which is De Moivre’s theorem, two lessons ahead.
Hardy also notes (§42) that the whole theory could have been built from this picture. If i means “turn through a right angle”, then yi is a move of length y along the y-axis, and to multiply z=x+yi by w=x′+y′i we should add “z stretched by x′” to “z turned through a right angle and stretched by y′”. That sum is exactly the product formula.
ExploreThe product as a sum of two pieces
Try this.Drag w onto the real axis, then onto the imaginary axis, then anywhere. Watch the two green pieces z⋅x′ and z⋅y′i, placed nose to tail.
On the real axis the second piece vanishes and zw is z stretched. On the imaginary axis the first piece vanishes and zw is iz stretched. In general zw is their sum, which is the distributive law z(x′+y′i)=zx′+zy′i seen as a picture. Either way zw ends up at the angle of z plus the angle of w.
The practical rule that comes out of all this (§41): calculate with x+yi as with an ordinary algebraic expression in a letter i, and replace i2 by −1 wherever it appears. For example
A complex number is a pair of real numbers (x,y), written x+yi. Two complex numbers are equal when both their parts are equal:
x+yi=x′+y′i if and only if x=x′ and y=y′. Sum and product are
We write x for x+0i, yi for 0+yi, and i for 0+1i. The numbers x+yi and x−yi are conjugate.
TheoremThe laws of algebraHardy: §39
Addition and multiplication of complex numbers are commutative and associative, and multiplication is distributive over addition. Subtraction is always possible, and (x+yi)−(x′+y′i)=(x−x′)+(y−y′)i.
These hold because they hold for displacements (previous lesson). Division is the interesting case.
TheoremDivisionHardy: §39 (4)
If x′+y′i=0, there is exactly one complex number ξ+ηi with (ξ+ηi)(x′+y′i)=x+yi, namely
x′+y′ix+yi=x′2+y′2xx′+yy′+x′2+y′2yx′−xy′i.
Division by 0 is impossible.
TheoremThe factor theoremHardy: §40
A product of two complex numbers is 0 only if one of the factors is 0.
PropositionMultiplication by iHardy: §§41–42
i2=(−i)2=−1. Multiplying a complex number by i turns the corresponding displacement through a positive right angle: (x+yi)i=−y+xi.
Proofs
ProofDivision
Strategy
Treat ξ and η as unknowns. Equating real and imaginary parts turns one complex equation into two real linear equations, and the conjugate of the divisor gives a quick way to solve them.
Two real equations
(ξ+ηi)(x′+y′i)=(ξx′−ηy′)+(ξy′+ηx′)i. This equals x+yi exactly when
ξx′−ηy′=x and ξy′+ηx′=y.
Solve them
Multiply the first equation by x′ and the second by y′ and add: ξ(x′2+y′2)=xx′+yy′. Multiply the first by −y′ and the second by x′ and add: η(x′2+y′2)=yx′−xy′.
Divide, which needs x′2+y′2=0
If x′+y′i=0 then x′ and y′ are not both 0, so x′2+y′2>0. Dividing gives the stated ξ and η, and they are the only possible values. Substituting back confirms they work.
The same answer, quickly
Multiply top and bottom by the conjugate x′−y′i: the bottom becomes (x′+y′i)(x′−y′i)=x′2+y′2, a positive real number, and the top becomes (xx′+yy′)+(yx′−xy′)i.
Why not 0
If x′=y′=0 the two equations read 0=x and 0=y. When x+yi=0 there is no solution; when x+yi=0 every ξ+ηi is a solution. Either way there is no single answer, so (x+yi)/0 means nothing.
∎
ProofThe factor theorem
Strategy
Suppose zw=0 and w=0. Dividing by w is allowed, and dividing 0 by anything nonzero gives 0.
Set up
Let z=ξ+ηi and w=x′+y′i=0, with zw=0.
z is the quotient 0/w
zw=0 says exactly that z is the number which multiplied by w gives 0+0i. By the division theorem there is only one such number, and the formula with x=y=0 gives it as ξ=0, η=0.
Conclude
So z=0. Hence if zw=0, then w=0 or z=0.
∎
The quarter-turn statement is one line: (x+yi)i=xi+yi2=−y+xi, and the point (−y,x) is (x,y) turned through +90∘ about O (same length, and the two directions are perpendicular because x⋅(−y)+y⋅x=0).
Worked examples and exercises
Exercise●○○Hardy: Examples XXI, 6
Write in the form A+Bi, where λ,μ are real and not both 0:
For quotients, multiply top and bottom by the conjugate of the bottom.
Hint
For the last one, call the first fraction w. Then the second fraction is 1/w, and also the conjugate of w. What is w2−wˉ2?
Solution
(1+i)2=1+2i+i2=2i.
1−i1+i=(1−i)(1+i)(1+i)2=22i=i, and similarly 1+i1−i=2(1−i)2=2−2i=−i. Squaring, (1−i1+i)2=i2=−1 and (1+i1−i)2=(−i)2=−1.
λ−μiλ+μi=λ2+μ2(λ+μi)2=λ2+μ2λ2−μ2+λ2+μ22λμi.
For the last, let w be that fraction. Its conjugate is (λ−μi)/(λ+μi), so the expression is w2−wˉ2, which is 2i times the imaginary part of w2. Writing w=p+qi with p=(λ2−μ2)/(λ2+μ2) and q=2λμ/(λ2+μ2), the imaginary part of w2 is 2pq. Hence
w2−wˉ2=4pqi=(λ2+μ2)28λμ(λ2−μ2)i.
Check: λ=2, μ=1 gives w=(3+4i)/5, w2=(−7+24i)/25, and w2−wˉ2=48i/25, which matches 8⋅2⋅1⋅3/25.
ExerciseConjugates●○○Hardy: §39, Example (2)
Show that (x+yi)(x−yi)=x2+y2, and use it to derive the division formula.
Hint
Multiply out with i2=−1; the cross terms cancel.
Solution
(x+yi)(x−yi)=x2−xyi+xyi−y2i2=x2+y2, a real number, and positive unless x=y=0. So
x′+y′ix+yi=(x′+y′i)(x′−y′i)(x+yi)(x′−y′i)=x′2+y′2(xx′+yy′)+(yx′−xy′)i,
where the numerator was multiplied out with the usual rule. Multiplying top and bottom by the same nonzero number c is legitimate: if q=(ac)/(bc) then qbc=ac, so (qb−a)c=0, and since c=0 the factor theorem below gives qb=a, that is, q=a/b.
ExerciseDivision as a construction●●○Hardy: §39, Example (1)
Describe geometrically how to find OD/OC, and explain why it fails exactly when C=O.
Hint
Division undoes multiplication, and OB⋅OC=OD was built from triangles OAB and OCD similar in the same sense.
Solution
We want B with OB⋅OC=OD, that is, with triangles COD and AOB similar in the same sense (A=(1,0)). So make the angle AOB equal to the signed angle COD, and the length OB=OD/OC. This determines B uniquely provided OC=0. If C=O the “triangle” COD has no angle at O and the ratio OD/OC is meaningless, matching the fact that division by 0 is impossible.
Exercise●○○Hardy: Examples XXI, 7 (part)
With z=x+yi, write z2, z3 and 1/z in the form X+Yi with X,Y real.
Hint
Nothing is assumed: i is the pair (0,1), and i2=−1 is then computed from the product rule. Calling it −1 is a later convenience (Hardy uses it in §43), and it needs care, since −i also squares to −1.
Check yourselfEnter a number
What is i100?
Why
The powers of i cycle with period 4: i,−1,−i,1. Since 100=4×25, i100=(i4)25=1. Geometrically: 100 quarter turns are 25 full turns.
Check yourselfChoose one
What is the real part of 3+4i1?
Why
3+4i1=9+163−4i=253−254i. The real part of a quotient is not the quotient of the real parts; −4/25 is the imaginary part, and 3/5 forgets to square the modulus.
Check yourselfTrue or false?
If z2=0 for a complex number z, then z=0.
Why
True, by the factor theorem with both factors equal to z. This is not automatic for every way of multiplying pairs: with the rejected componentwise product, [1,0][0,1]=[0,0] although neither factor is zero.
Hardy’s language
an ‘imaginary number’ is no more ‘imaginary’, in any ordinary sense of the word, than a ‘real’ number or any other mathematical object.