Chapter II · Functions of real variables

Chapter II problems: Miscellaneous Examples

Miscellaneous examples 90 min

Eleven of Hardy’s Miscellaneous Examples on Chapter II, from functional equations and sawtooth graphs to counting roots and constructing the cube root of 2, with graded hints and full solutions.

Hardy’s Miscellaneous Examples on Chapter II are a mixture of graph sketching, counting roots, and classical geometry. The eleven below are chosen for variety and roughly ordered by difficulty within each group. Try each one before opening the hints; the hints are graded, so open them one at a time. Where a picture helps, there is an interactive figure, but in every case the solution is an argument, not a picture.

Functions and their graphs

Exercise A function that is its own inverse ●○○ Hardy: Misc. Examples II, 1

Show that if y=f(x)=ax+bcx−ay = f(x) = \dfrac{ax + b}{cx - a}, then x=f(y)x = f(y).

Hint
Clear the fraction and look at the symmetry of the resulting equation in xx and yy.
Hint
Watch for the case in which ff is constant.

Solution

y(cx−a)=ax+by(cx - a) = ax + b is equivalent (where cx≠acx \neq a) to cxy−ax−ay−b=0cxy - ax - ay - b = 0. This equation is symmetric: swapping xx and yy leaves it unchanged. Solving it for xx instead of yy gives x(cy−a)=ay+bx(cy - a) = ay + b, i.e. x=(ay+b)/(cy−a)=f(y)x = (ay + b)/(cy - a) = f(y), wherever cy≠acy \neq a.

The exception: if a2+bc=0a^2 + bc = 0, then ax+bax + b and cx−acx - a are proportional and ff is the constant a/ca/c (with c≠0c \neq 0), so the statement fails (indeed f(a/c)f(a/c) is meaningless). Otherwise ff is its own inverse, f(f(x))=xf(f(x)) = x, and its graph is symmetric about the line y=xy = x: it is a rectangular hyperbola with asymptotes x=a/cx = a/c and y=a/cy = a/c, both crossing y=xy = x at the same point.

Exercise Even plus odd ●○○ Hardy: Misc. Examples II, 2

ff is even if f(−x)=f(x)f(-x) = f(x) and odd if f(−x)=−f(x)f(-x) = -f(x), for all xx. Show that every function defined for all xx is the sum of an even function and an odd one, and that the decomposition is unique.

Hint
Hardy’s identity: f(x)=12{f(x)+f(−x)}+12{f(x)−f(−x)}f(x) = \tfrac12\{f(x) + f(-x)\} + \tfrac12\{f(x) - f(-x)\}.
Hint
For uniqueness, what can you say about a function that is both even and odd?

Solution

Let E(x)=12{f(x)+f(−x)}E(x) = \tfrac12\{f(x) + f(-x)\} and O(x)=12{f(x)−f(−x)}O(x) = \tfrac12\{f(x) - f(-x)\}. Then E(−x)=12{f(−x)+f(x)}=E(x)E(-x) = \tfrac12\{f(-x) + f(x)\} = E(x), O(−x)=12{f(−x)−f(x)}=−O(x)O(-x) = \tfrac12\{f(-x) - f(x)\} = -O(x), and E+O=fE + O = f.

If also f=E1+O1f = E_1 + O_1 with E1E_1 even and O1O_1 odd, then g=E−E1=O1−Og = E - E_1 = O_1 - O is both even and odd, so g(x)=g(−x)=−g(x)g(x) = g(-x) = -g(x) and g(x)=0g(x) = 0. So the decomposition is unique.

Example: for f(x)=[x]f(x) = [x], the even part is 12([x]+[−x])\tfrac12([x] + [-x]), which is 00 at the integers and −12-\tfrac12 everywhere else, and the odd part is 12([x]−[−x])\tfrac12([x] - [-x]).

Exercise Two sawtooth graphs ●●○ Hardy: Misc. Examples II, 5

Draw the graphs of x[1/x]x[1/x] and [x]/x[x]/x.

Hint
For [x]/x[x]/x, work on one interval n≤x<n+1n \le x < n + 1 at a time, where [x]=n[x] = n is constant. Treat 0<x<10 < x < 1 and x<0x < 0 separately.
Hint
Notice that x[1/x]=[1/x]/(1/x)x[1/x] = [1/x]/(1/x): the first function is the second evaluated at 1/x1/x.

Solution

h(x)=[x]/xh(x) = [x]/x (x≠0x \neq 0). For 0<x<10 < x < 1, [x]=0[x] = 0 and h=0h = 0. For n≤x<n+1n \le x < n + 1 (n≥1n \ge 1), h=n/xh = n/x falls from 11 (at x=nx = n, included) towards n/(n+1)n/(n+1) (not reached): a sawtooth just below 11, with teeth approaching 11 as x→∞x \to \infty. For −1≤x<0-1 \le x < 0, [x]=−1[x] = -1 and h=−1/x≥1h = -1/x \ge 1, rising without bound as x→0−x \to 0^-. For −(n+1)≤x<−n-(n+1) \le x < -n (n≥1n \ge 1), h=(n+1)/∣x∣h = (n+1)/|x| rises from 11 (at x=−(n+1)x = -(n+1)) towards (n+1)/n(n+1)/n: a sawtooth just above 11, again approaching 11.

g(x)=x[1/x]=h(1/x)g(x) = x[1/x] = h(1/x). Replace xx by 1/x1/x in the description above. For x>1x > 1: g=0g = 0. For 1n+1<x≤1n\frac{1}{n+1} < x \le \frac1n: g=nxg = nx, a segment rising from (but not including) (1n+1,nn+1)\bigl(\frac{1}{n+1}, \frac{n}{n+1}\bigr) to (1n,1)\bigl(\frac1n, 1\bigr). For x<−1x < -1: g=−xg = -x. For −1n<x≤−1n+1-\frac1n < x \le -\frac{1}{n+1}: g=−(n+1)xg = -(n+1)x, falling from near n+1n\frac{n+1}{n} to 11. So near 00 the graph consists of infinitely many shorter and shorter segments, all with values between 1−1n+11 - \frac{1}{n+1} and 1+1n1 + \frac1n: the function is not defined at 00, but its values crowd towards 11.

Explore The two sawtooth functions

Try this. Look at x[1/x]x[1/x] near x=0x = 0, dragging the trace point towards 00 from both sides; then compare with [x]/x[x]/x for large ∣x∣|x|.

Function
y=x[1x]y = x\left[\frac1x\right]
xy
  • the curve
  • trace point (drag)
At x=0.3x = 0.3: y=0.9y = 0.9
What to notice

Near 00, x[1/x]x[1/x] is made of infinitely many little segments whose values close in on 11, from below on the right and from above on the left. Far out, [x]/x[x]/x does the same. The two pictures are each other read through x↦1/xx \mapsto 1/x.

Exercise Graphing a function of a function ●●○ Hardy: Misc. Examples II, 7

Verify this construction of the graph of f{ϕ(x)}f\{\phi(x)\} from the graphs of y=f(x)y = f(x), y=ϕ(x)y = \phi(x) and the line y=xy = x: take OA=xOA = x along OXOX; draw ABAB parallel to OYOY to meet y=ϕ(x)y = \phi(x) in BB; BCBC parallel to OXOX to meet y=xy = x in CC; CDCD parallel to OYOY to meet y=f(x)y = f(x) in DD; and DPDP parallel to OXOX to meet ABAB in PP. Then PP is on the graph of f{ϕ(x)}f\{\phi(x)\}.

Hint
Write down the coordinates of AA, BB, CC, DD, PP in turn. Moving parallel to OYOY keeps the abscissa; moving parallel to OXOX keeps the ordinate.

Solution

A=(x,0)A = (x, 0). BB is above AA on y=ϕ(x)y = \phi(x): B=(x,ϕ(x))B = (x, \phi(x)). CC has the same ordinate and lies on y=xy = x: C=(ϕ(x),ϕ(x))C = (\phi(x), \phi(x)). The line y=xy = x has turned the value ϕ(x)\phi(x) into an abscissa. DD is on the vertical through CC and on y=f(x)y = f(x): D=(ϕ(x),f{ϕ(x)})D = (\phi(x), f\{\phi(x)\}). Finally PP has the ordinate of DD and lies on the vertical ABAB: P=(x,f{ϕ(x)})P = (x, f\{\phi(x)\}), a point of the graph of f{ϕ(x)}f\{\phi(x)\}. As xx varies, PP traces that graph.

Explore Hardy’s construction, step by step

Try this. Move xx slowly across the whole range and watch the path A → B → C → D → P; the blue points left behind are the graph of f{ϕ(x)}f\{\phi(x)\}.

f{ϕ(x)},ϕ(x)=12x2−1, f(x)=2sin⁡xf\{\phi(x)\},\quad \phi(x) = \tfrac12x^2 - 1,\ f(x) = 2\sin x
xy
  • y = φ(x)
  • y = f(x)
  • y = x
  • points P found so far (the graph of f{φ(x)})
A=(1.2,0)A = (1.2, 0), B=(x,ϕ(x))=(1.2,−0.28)B = (x, \phi(x)) = (1.2, -0.28), C=(ϕ(x),ϕ(x))C = (\phi(x), \phi(x)), D=(ϕ(x),f{ϕ(x)})=(−0.28,−0.553)D = (\phi(x), f\{\phi(x)\}) = (-0.28, -0.553), so P=(1.2,−0.553)P = (1.2, -0.553). Sweep xx to trace the composite graph.
What to notice

The line y=xy = x is the trick: it converts the height ϕ(x)\phi(x) into a horizontal position, so that the graph of ff can be read there. The same device, iterated, gives the “cobweb” pictures used to study repeated application of one function.

Exercise A polynomial through given points ●●○ Hardy: Misc. Examples II, 15–16

(a) Give a formula for the polynomial of degree at most n−1n - 1 that takes the values α1,…,αn\alpha_1, \dots, \alpha_n at the distinct points a1,…,ana_1, \dots, a_n, generalising Hardy’s formula for n=3n = 3.

(b) Find the polynomial pp of degree at most 22 with p(0)=1/cp(0) = 1/c, p(1)=1/(c+1)p(1) = 1/(c + 1), p(2)=1/(c+2)p(2) = 1/(c + 2), and show that p(c+2)=1/(c+1)p(c + 2) = 1/(c + 1). (Assume c≠0,−1,−2c \neq 0, -1, -2.)

Hint
(a) Build, for each ii, a polynomial that is 11 at aia_i and 00 at every other aja_j.
Hint
(b) You do not need pp explicitly. Consider q(x)=(x+c) p(x)−1q(x) = (x + c)\,p(x) - 1: what are its degree and its roots?
Hint
(b) Then q(x)=k x(x−1)(x−2)q(x) = k\,x(x-1)(x-2). Find kk by putting x=−cx = -c.

Solution

(a) Let Li(x)=∏j≠ix−ajai−ajL_i(x) = \displaystyle\prod_{j \neq i}\frac{x - a_j}{a_i - a_j}. Each LiL_i has degree n−1n - 1, Li(ai)=1L_i(a_i) = 1 and Li(aj)=0L_i(a_j) = 0 for j≠ij \neq i. So P(x)=∑i=1nαiLi(x)P(x) = \sum_{i=1}^n \alpha_iL_i(x) takes the value αi\alpha_i at aia_i. For n=3n = 3 this is Hardy’s formula. It is the only such polynomial: the difference of two of them has degree at most n−1n - 1 and nn roots, so it is identically zero. (This is Lagrange’s interpolation formula.)

(b) Let q(x)=(x+c)p(x)−1q(x) = (x + c)p(x) - 1, of degree at most 33. Then q(0)=c⋅1c−1=0q(0) = c\cdot\frac1c - 1 = 0, and similarly q(1)=q(2)=0q(1) = q(2) = 0. So q(x)=k x(x−1)(x−2)q(x) = k\,x(x - 1)(x - 2) for some constant kk. At x=−cx = -c: q(−c)=−1q(-c) = -1, so −1=k(−c)(−c−1)(−c−2)=−k c(c+1)(c+2)-1 = k(-c)(-c - 1)(-c - 2) = -k\,c(c + 1)(c + 2), giving k=1/{c(c+1)(c+2)}k = 1/\{c(c+1)(c+2)\}. At x=c+2x = c + 2: (2c+2) p(c+2)−1=k(c+2)(c+1)c=1(2c + 2)\,p(c + 2) - 1 = k(c + 2)(c + 1)c = 1, so p(c+2)=2/(2c+2)=1/(c+1)p(c + 2) = 2/(2c + 2) = 1/(c + 1).

Counting roots

Exercise A cubic by a parabola and a circle ●●○ Hardy: Misc. Examples II, 8

Show that the roots of x3+px+q=0x^3 + px + q = 0 are the abscissae of the points of intersection, other than the origin, of the parabola y=x2y = x^2 and the circle x2+y2+(p−1)y+qx=0x^2 + y^2 + (p - 1)y + qx = 0.

Hint
Substitute y=x2y = x^2 into the equation of the circle and factorise.

Solution

A point of the parabola is (x,x2)(x, x^2). It lies on the circle exactly when x2+x4+(p−1)x2+qx=0x^2 + x^4 + (p - 1)x^2 + qx = 0, i.e. x4+px2+qx=x(x3+px+q)=0x^4 + px^2 + qx = x(x^3 + px + q) = 0. So the common points are the origin (x=0x = 0) and the points (x,x2)(x, x^2) with x3+px+q=0x^3 + px + q = 0; conversely each real root xx gives such a point. (If q=0q = 0 the cubic itself has the root 00, which then corresponds to the origin.) The circle passes through the origin and has centre (−12q,12(1−p))\bigl(-\tfrac12q, \tfrac12(1 - p)\bigr), so a cubic can be solved with a fixed parabola and a compass, as with the quadratics of §30.

Exercise ●●○ Hardy: Misc. Examples II, 13

Show that the equation 23xsin⁡x=1\tfrac23x\sin x = 1 has four roots between −π-\pi and π\pi.

Hint
Write it as xsin⁡x=32x\sin x = \tfrac32. The function xsin⁡xx\sin x is even, so count roots in (0,π)(0, \pi) and double.
Hint
On (0,12π](0, \tfrac12\pi] both xx and sin⁡x\sin x increase. What is xsin⁡xx\sin x at 12π\tfrac12\pi, and at π\pi?

Solution

xsin⁡xx\sin x is even, and 00 at x=0x = 0, so it suffices to show there are exactly two roots in (0,π)(0, \pi).

On (0,12π](0, \tfrac12\pi], both factors are positive and increasing, so xsin⁡xx\sin x increases strictly from 00 to 12π≈1.571>1.5\tfrac12\pi \approx 1.571 > 1.5: exactly one root there (about 1.5031.503).

On [12π,π)[\tfrac12\pi, \pi), the function starts at 1.571>1.51.571 > 1.5 and falls to 00 at π\pi, so the graph crosses the level 1.51.5 at least once (about 2.4972.497). It crosses only once: the graph rises slightly to a single maximum (about 1.821.82 near x≈2.03x \approx 2.03) and then falls steadily, which is clear from the picture and is proved with the derivative in Chapter VI. So there are two roots in (0,π)(0, \pi), two more in (−π,0)(-\pi, 0) by symmetry: ±1.503\pm1.503 and ±2.497\pm2.497 approximately.

Exercise ●●● Hardy: Misc. Examples II, 11

Solve sec⁡θ+cosec⁡θ=22\sec\theta + \operatorname{cosec}\theta = 2\sqrt2, and show that sec⁡θ+cosec⁡θ=c\sec\theta + \operatorname{cosec}\theta = c has two roots between 00 and 2π2\pi if c2<8c^2 < 8 and four if c2>8c^2 > 8.

Hint
Put s=sin⁡θ+cos⁡θ=2sin⁡(θ+14π)s = \sin\theta + \cos\theta = \sqrt2\sin(\theta + \tfrac14\pi). Then sin⁡θcos⁡θ=12(s2−1)\sin\theta\cos\theta = \tfrac12(s^2 - 1).
Hint
The equation becomes 2s/(s2−1)=c2s/(s^2 - 1) = c, a quadratic in ss. The product of its roots is −1-1. How many values of θ\theta in [0,2π)[0, 2\pi) give a particular ss?

Solution

With s=sin⁡θ+cos⁡θs = \sin\theta + \cos\theta we have s2=1+2sin⁡θcos⁡θs^2 = 1 + 2\sin\theta\cos\theta, and the equation sin⁡θ+cos⁡θsin⁡θcos⁡θ=c\dfrac{\sin\theta + \cos\theta}{\sin\theta\cos\theta} = c becomes 2ss2−1=c\dfrac{2s}{s^2 - 1} = c, i.e. cs2−2s−c=0cs^2 - 2s - c = 0 (the values s=±1s = \pm1, where sin⁡θcos⁡θ=0\sin\theta\cos\theta = 0 and the equation is meaningless, never satisfy this, since they would give s=0s = 0).

Since s=2sin⁡(θ+14π)s = \sqrt2\sin(\theta + \tfrac14\pi), each ss with ∣s∣<2|s| < \sqrt2 comes from exactly two values of θ\theta in [0,2π)[0, 2\pi), s=±2s = \pm\sqrt2 from one, and ∣s∣>2|s| > \sqrt2 from none.

c=22c = 2\sqrt2. 22s2−2s−22=02\sqrt2 s^2 - 2s - 2\sqrt2 = 0 gives s=2s = \sqrt2 or s=−1/2s = -1/\sqrt2. s=2s = \sqrt2: θ=14π\theta = \tfrac14\pi. s=−1/2s = -1/\sqrt2: sin⁡(θ+14π)=−12\sin(\theta + \tfrac14\pi) = -\tfrac12, so θ+14π=76π\theta + \tfrac14\pi = \tfrac76\pi or 116π\tfrac{11}{6}\pi, giving θ=1112π\theta = \tfrac{11}{12}\pi or 1912π\tfrac{19}{12}\pi. The solutions are θ=14π,1112π,1912π\theta = \tfrac14\pi, \tfrac{11}{12}\pi, \tfrac{19}{12}\pi (plus multiples of 2π2\pi).

General cc. For c=0c = 0 the only root is s=0s = 0, giving two θ\theta. For c≠0c \neq 0 the two roots s1s_1, s2s_2 have product −1-1, so one of them, say s1s_1, has ∣s1∣<1|s_1| < 1 and gives two θ\theta. The other has ∣s2∣=1/∣s1∣=1+1+c2∣c∣|s_2| = 1/|s_1| = \dfrac{1 + \sqrt{1 + c^2}}{|c|}, and ∣s2∣<2|s_2| < \sqrt2 exactly when 1+c2<2∣c∣−1\sqrt{1 + c^2} < \sqrt2|c| - 1. This forces 2∣c∣−1>0\sqrt2|c| - 1 > 0, and then squaring is reversible: 1+c2<2c2−22∣c∣+11 + c^2 < 2c^2 - 2\sqrt2|c| + 1, i.e. ∣c∣>22|c| > 2\sqrt2 (which indeed makes 2∣c∣−1\sqrt2|c| - 1 positive). So ∣s2∣<2|s_2| < \sqrt2 exactly when c2>8c^2 > 8, and ∣s2∣=2|s_2| = \sqrt2 when c2=8c^2 = 8. So there are four roots when c2>8c^2 > 8, two when c2<8c^2 < 8, and three when c2=8c^2 = 8 (one of them double), as found above.

Exercise ●●● Hardy: Misc. Examples II, 12

Show that the equation 2x=(2n+1)π(1−cos⁡x)2x = (2n + 1)\pi(1 - \cos x), where nn is a positive integer, has 2n+32n + 3 roots and no more, and indicate roughly where they lie.

Hint
Write it as x=Ksin⁡212xx = K\sin^2\tfrac12x with K=(2n+1)πK = (2n + 1)\pi. The right side lies between 00 and KK, so every root lies in [0,K][0, K].
Hint
The curve y=Ksin⁡212xy = K\sin^2\tfrac12x has humps on the intervals [2mπ,2(m+1)π][2m\pi, 2(m+1)\pi], rising to KK at (2m+1)π(2m + 1)\pi. Compare it with the line y=xy = x at 2mπ2m\pi, at (2m+1)π(2m + 1)\pi and at 2(m+1)π2(m+1)\pi.
Hint
The last hump, m=nm = n, is special: its top is exactly on the line.

Solution

Since 1−cos⁡x=2sin⁡212x1 - \cos x = 2\sin^2\tfrac12x, the equation is x=Ksin⁡212xx = K\sin^2\tfrac12x with K=(2n+1)πK = (2n + 1)\pi. The right side lies in [0,K][0, K], so roots satisfy 0≤x≤K0 \le x \le K: they lie in the humps m=0,1,…,nm = 0, 1, \dots, n of the curve, where hump mm is [2mπ,(2m+2)π][2m\pi, (2m + 2)\pi] with its top KK at (2m+1)π(2m + 1)\pi.

The first hump. x=0x = 0 is a root. Just to the right of 00 the curve (≈Kx2/4\approx Kx^2/4) is below the line; at x=πx = \pi the curve (KK) is above it (as K≥3π>πK \ge 3\pi > \pi); at 2π2\pi the curve (00) is below. So there is a root in (0,π)(0, \pi) (close to 4/K4/K) and one in (π,2π)(\pi, 2\pi).

Humps 1≤m≤n−11 \le m \le n - 1. At 2mπ2m\pi the curve is 00, below the line; at (2m+1)π(2m + 1)\pi it is K>(2m+1)πK > (2m + 1)\pi, above; at (2m+2)π(2m + 2)\pi it is 00 again, below. One root on the rising side, one on the falling side.

The last hump, m=nm = n. At (2n+1)π=K(2n + 1)\pi = K the curve and the line both equal KK: this is a root. At 2nπ2n\pi the curve is below the line; just to the left of KK it is above (writing x=K−tx = K - t, the difference curve −- line is t−Ksin⁡212t>0t - K\sin^2\tfrac12t > 0 for small t>0t > 0). So there is one more root in (2nπ,K)(2n\pi, K). To the right of KK the line exceeds KK and there are no roots.

Total: 3+2(n−1)+2=2n+33 + 2(n - 1) + 2 = 2n + 3. (For example, with n=1n = 1 the roots are about 00, 0.430.43, 4.714.71, 8.998.99, 9.429.42.) One root is always exactly x=12Kx = \tfrac12K, because sin⁡214K=12\sin^2\tfrac14K = \tfrac12 there.

No more. On each falling side the curve decreases while the line increases, so they meet at most once. On each rising side, the difference “curve minus line” first decreases, then increases, then decreases again (its slope 12Ksin⁡x−1\tfrac12K\sin x - 1 changes sign twice; derivatives come in Chapter VI); combined with the signs found above, this allows only one crossing (apart from x=0x = 0 in the first hump). So the count is exact.

Explore Counting roots in the Miscellaneous Examples

Try this. For sec⁡θ+cosec⁡θ=c\sec\theta + \operatorname{cosec}\theta = c, move cc through ±22≈±2.83\pm2\sqrt2 \approx \pm2.83. For 2x=(2n+1)π(1−cos⁡x)2x = (2n+1)\pi(1 - \cos x), step nn and count. For xsin⁡x=cx\sin x = c, set c=1.5c = 1.5.

sec⁡θ+cosec⁡θ=2\sec\theta + \operatorname{cosec}\theta = 2Hardy: Misc. Examples II, 11
θy
  • y=sec⁡θ+cosec⁡θy = \sec\theta + \operatorname{cosec}\theta
  • y=cy = c
  • intersections and their abscissae (the roots)
2 roots in the window: 2.808, 5.0462.808,\ 5.046. c2=4<8c^2 = 4 < 8.
What to notice

The secant–cosecant count jumps from two to four as ∣c∣|c| passes 222\sqrt2, where the horizontal line touches the curve. The cosine equation always has 2n+32n + 3 roots, two of them at 12(2n+1)π\tfrac12(2n+1)\pi and (2n+1)π(2n+1)\pi. The equation xsin⁡x=1.5x\sin x = 1.5 has exactly four roots in (−π,π)(-\pi, \pi).

Constructions

Exercise Duplicating the cube with two parabolas ●●○ Hardy: Misc. Examples II, 25

OO is the vertex and SS the focus of the parabola y2=4xy^2 = 4x, and PP is its intersection (other than OO) with the parabola x2=2yx^2 = 2y. Show that OPOP meets the latus rectum of the first parabola in a point QQ with SQ=23SQ = \sqrt[3]{2}.

Hint
The focus of y2=4xy^2 = 4x is (1,0)(1, 0) and its latus rectum is the chord x=1x = 1 through the focus.
Hint
Substitute y=12x2y = \tfrac12x^2 into y2=4xy^2 = 4x.

Solution

From x2=2yx^2 = 2y, y=12x2y = \tfrac12x^2; then y2=4xy^2 = 4x gives 14x4=4x\tfrac14x^4 = 4x, so x(x3−16)=0x(x^3 - 16) = 0. Apart from OO, x=161/3=24/3x = 16^{1/3} = 2^{4/3} and y=12x2=25/3y = \tfrac12x^2 = 2^{5/3}. The line OPOP is y=(25/3/24/3)x=21/3xy = (2^{5/3}/2^{4/3})x = 2^{1/3}x. It meets the latus rectum x=1x = 1 at Q=(1,21/3)Q = (1, 2^{1/3}), while S=(1,0)S = (1, 0). So SQ=23SQ = \sqrt[3]{2}. Two parabolas do what ruler and compasses cannot: Hardy notes (Misc. Examples II, 22) that Euclidean constructions only produce lengths built from square roots, and 23\sqrt[3]2 is not one of them.

Exercise The cissoid of Diocles ●●● Hardy: Misc. Examples II, 26

Take a circle of unit diameter, a diameter OAOA and the tangent at AA. A chord OBCOBC meets the circle again at BB and the tangent at CC; on it take OM=BCOM = BC. With OO as origin and OAOA as axis of xx, show that the locus of MM is (x2+y2)x−y2=0(x^2 + y^2)x - y^2 = 0, and sketch it. Then take OD=2OD = 2 along the axis of yy; let ADAD cut the curve at PP and OPOP cut the tangent at AA in QQ. Show that AQ=23AQ = \sqrt[3]{2}.

Hint
Use polar coordinates: the circle is r=cos⁡θr = \cos\theta and the tangent at AA is rcos⁡θ=1r\cos\theta = 1.
Hint
For the second part, describe points of the curve by the slope tt of OMOM: put y=txy = tx in the equation of the curve.

Solution

The circle on OAOA (A=(1,0)A = (1, 0)) as diameter is x2+y2=xx^2 + y^2 = x, i.e. r=cos⁡θr = \cos\theta, and the tangent at AA is x=1x = 1, i.e. r=sec⁡θr = \sec\theta. On the ray at angle θ\theta (∣θ∣<12π|\theta| < \tfrac12\pi), OB=cos⁡θOB = \cos\theta and OC=sec⁡θOC = \sec\theta, so OM=BC=sec⁡θ−cos⁡θ=sin⁡2θ/cos⁡θOM = BC = \sec\theta - \cos\theta = \sin^2\theta/\cos\theta. Thus MM satisfies rcos⁡θ=sin⁡2θr\cos\theta = \sin^2\theta, i.e. x=y2/r2x = y^2/r^2, i.e. x(x2+y2)=y2x(x^2 + y^2) = y^2.

Sketch. The curve is symmetric about the axis of xx (only y2y^2 occurs), lies in 0≤x<10 \le x < 1 (since x=sin⁡2θx = \sin^2\theta), has a cusp at OO (near OO, y2≈x3y^2 \approx x^3), and approaches the tangent x=1x = 1 as an asymptote as θ→±12π\theta \to \pm\tfrac12\pi.

The cube root. Points of the curve other than OO with OMOM of slope tt: putting y=txy = tx gives x(1+t2)x2=t2x2x(1 + t^2)x^2 = t^2x^2, so x=t2/(1+t2)x = t^2/(1 + t^2), y=t3/(1+t2)y = t^3/(1 + t^2). The line ADAD through (1,0)(1, 0) and (0,2)(0, 2) is 2x+y=22x + y = 2. Substituting: (2t2+t3)/(1+t2)=2(2t^2 + t^3)/(1 + t^2) = 2, i.e. t3=2t^3 = 2. So OPOP has slope t=23t = \sqrt[3]2 and meets x=1x = 1 at Q=(1,23)Q = (1, \sqrt[3]2), giving AQ=23AQ = \sqrt[3]{2}. Diocles used this curve for exactly this purpose: to duplicate the cube.

Notes