Chapter II · Functions of real variables
Curves in a plane
Describing curves by an equation f(x, y) = 0 or by parametric equations x = f(t), y = F(t); families of curves through given points; and what elimination of the parameter gains and loses.
Why this matters
So far a curve has mostly been the graph of . But many curves are not graphs of one-valued functions (a circle fails the vertical line test), and many relations between and cannot be solved for at all, such as . §32 therefore adopts the equation as the standard way to describe a plane curve, and adds a second way: let both coordinates be functions of a third variable . Both descriptions are used throughout analysis, for instance for implicit functions in Chapter V and for lengths of curves in Chapter VI.
The idea
Two ways of describing the same curve:
- By one equation, : the curve is the set of points satisfying it. This includes as the special case , and also circles, conics and algebraic curves that cannot be solved for . Solving can even hide part of the curve: Hardy notes that solving the circle for gives , two formulas, while the original single equation describes the whole circle more simply.
- By parametric equations, , : as the parameter varies, the point moves and traces the curve. The circle is , ; as goes from to the point goes round once, and beyond that it goes round again.
Equations can also be combined. If and are two curves, any point on both satisfies for every number . So a single parameter gives a whole family of curves through the common points.
Try this. With the ellipse and hyperbola, move slowly from to . Look for the values of where the curve breaks into straight lines. Then try two circles and stop at .
- f + λφ = 0
- f = 0
- φ = 0
- common points of f = 0 and φ = 0
What to notice
Every member passes through the four marked points, the intersections of the two thin curves and . Between them the members change type: ellipses, hyperbolas and, at , and , pairs of straight lines. For two circles, cancels the squares and leaves the common chord .
Precise statements
The curve (or locus) is the set of points whose coordinates satisfy the equation. The equation defines as a (possibly many-valued) function of , and also as a function of .
If and , where and are functions of a variable , the set of points , for all for which both are defined, is the locus defined by the parametric equations. Eliminating between the two equations gives an equation satisfied by every point of the locus.
For every number , the curve passes through every common point of the curves and .
Let . As runs through all real numbers, the point given by
describes the ellipse with exactly one point missing, namely . Each other point of the ellipse arises from exactly one .
Elimination tells you that every point of the parametric locus lies on the eliminated curve; it does not tell you that every point of that curve is reached. This example shows the difference.
Try this. Move and watch the point; then widen the range step by step up to . Where does the traced arc end? Compare the circle , with range beyond .
- points for −T ≤ t ≤ T
- the point at t
- the point (0, −b): no t gives it
What to notice
gives the top , give , and as grows the point slides down both sides towards , getting ever closer but never arriving: the eliminated equation is the full ellipse, but the parametric locus lacks one point. The trigonometric circle, by contrast, covers every point, and covers it again and again.
Proofs
Substitute a common point into .
Take a common point
Let lie on both curves, so and .
Substitute
Then whatever is, so lies on .
What this gives in practice
Choosing cleverly simplifies the equation while keeping the common points. With two circles, removes and leaves a straight line through both common points; with two conics, a suitable gives a pair of lines. Solving that simpler equation with one of the originals finds the intersections (Examples XVIII, 1).
First check that every point given by the formulas is on the ellipse. Then solve for in terms of : the formula for works at every point of the ellipse except where its denominator vanishes, which is .
Every point is on the ellipse
is missed
would need , that is . Impossible, so no gives .
Recover from the point
From the formulas, , and dividing by it gives . So is determined by the point: different give different points.
Every other point is reached
Let be on the ellipse with , and put . Write , , so and . Then , using . Hence and : this gives exactly the point .
Geometrically, after scaling the ellipse to the unit circle , the line joining the missing point to has slope . Every line through meets the circle in exactly one more point, except the horizontal tangent there, which would need “”: that is why exactly one point is missed. This “rational parametrisation” is why the substitution turns trigonometric integrals into rational ones in Chapter VI.
Worked examples and exercises
Find the common points of the circles and .
Hint
Solution
Subtracting: , i.e. , so . Then , . The common points are and : finitely many isolated points, as Hardy says two such equations generally give.
Trace the curves , , .
Hint
Solution
means or : a pair of parallel straight lines, not a single curve. is the rectangular hyperbola , in the first and third quadrants, with the axes as asymptotes. is a rectangular hyperbola with vertices and asymptotes ; it is turned through half a right angle and shrunk by a factor . Indeed, in the coordinates , (axes turned through ) we have , so the curve is , that is .
What loci are represented by (α) , , and (β) , , as varies through all real values?
Hint
Solution
(α) Eliminating : . If and are not both , this is the straight line through in the direction , and every point of it is reached: the point comes from . If , the “locus” is the single point .
(β) By the theorem above, the ellipse without the point . (If it is a circle with one point removed.)
Hardy writes the circle as . For which is this defined, and what part of the circle does each sign give?
Hint
Solution
. So the formula is defined for , i.e. for between and , the horizontal extent of the circle. The sign gives the upper semicircle (above the centre’s level ), the sign the lower one; they meet at the two ends . Neither is the whole circle: the single equation is the better description, as Hardy says.
For the ellipse and the hyperbola , find every for which is a pair of straight lines, and use one of them to find the four common points.
Hint
Solution
is a pair of lines when and , have opposite signs (: , so ), or when one of , vanishes and the other has the same sign as (: , the lines ; : , the lines ). With : , and then . The four common points are , matching the marked points in the widget.
Check yourself
The locus is
means : two lines of slope . A square equal to allows two signs; forgetting one gives the last option.
In the parametrisation , , which value of gives the point ?
needs , and needs , so (while gives ). Check with .
If eliminating from , gives , then every point of the curve is for some .
False. Elimination only shows that the parametric points lie on . The rational parametrisation of the ellipse misses ; and , gives only the half-line of the line .
Why does pass through every common point of and ?
It is pure substitution, valid for any functions , and every ; is not chosen to make it work. What may fail is the converse: has other points too.
Hardy’s language
Summary
- The standard description of a plane curve is one equation ; it includes and covers curves that are not graphs or cannot be solved for .
- Parametric equations , trace a curve as varies; eliminating gives an equation the points satisfy, but the parametric locus may be only part of that curve.
- , gives the ellipse minus , and recovers .
- passes through all common points of and ; choosing well simplifies finding them.