Chapter II · Functions of real variables
Graphs and the equation of a locus
Coordinates, the graph of a function, and why the general equation of the first degree is a straight line and a circle (or nothing).
Why this matters
A function is a rule; a graph is a picture of the rule. §21 sets up the picture: coordinates, the graph as the set of all points that the rule allows, and the reverse reading in which an equation describes a locus. Every sketch in the rest of the chapter, and every figure in the rest of the book, uses this dictionary between equations and sets of points.
The idea
Draw two perpendicular lines through a point , the axes. A point is fixed by two signed distances: measured along the axis of and along the axis of . We write and call the abscissa and the ordinate of .
If is a function of , then every pair “ has the value ” gives a point . The set of all these points is the graph of the function. If has several values , there are several points above , which is how the vertical line test of the last lesson works.
The same dictionary can be read the other way. Start with an equation in and , and collect every point whose coordinates satisfy it. That set is the locus of the equation, and the equation is said to represent the locus. A point is on the locus exactly when substituting its coordinates makes the equation true.
Try this. Drag the purple point along the line and watch the substitution stay at . Then change , , . Finally make exactly, and after that make .
- the locus
- a point on it (drag)
What to notice
Whenever the locus is a line that every vertical line crosses once: is a one-valued function of , defined everywhere. At the line turns vertical, and becomes a strange function: defined at one value of only, with every value there (Hardy’s footnote to §21). With the locus is either the whole plane or empty.
Hardy’s second example is the circle. Expanding gives an equation of the form . But not every equation of that form is a circle.
Try this. Move and and watch the centre. Then raise slowly until the circle shrinks to a point and disappears.
- the locus
- centre (−G, −F) and a radius
- a point on it (drag)
What to notice
The centre is always , and the radius squared is . The circle exists exactly while this is positive; at zero the locus is one point; below zero it is empty, because a sum of two squares cannot be negative. That is why Hardy adds the condition .
Precise statements
Let be a function of . Its graph is the set of all points such that is a value of for .
Given an equation , its locus is the set of all points with . The equation represents the locus, and is the equation of the locus.
If and are not both zero, the locus of is a straight line. Conversely, every straight line is the locus of such an equation.
The locus of is the circle with centre and radius if ; the single point if ; and empty if . Every circle has an equation of this form.
The general equation of the second degree, , represents a conic (ellipse, parabola or hyperbola) when its coefficients satisfy suitable inequalities, and otherwise a pair of lines, a point, or nothing. Hardy leaves conics to books on analytical geometry, and so do we; you will meet several in §32.
Proofs
Hardy calls these results familiar and refers to analytical geometry. Here are short proofs, since they are the model for every “find the locus” argument.
Use one fact from geometry: three points with different abscissae lie on one line exactly when the “slope” between the first two equals the slope between the first and the third (similar triangles). Show that all points of the locus have the same slope between them, and deal separately with vertical lines.
If , the locus is a vertical line
Then , and the equation says , with arbitrary. That is the vertical line through .
If , solve for
The equation is equivalent to with and . So for each there is exactly one point of the locus, namely .
All slopes are
For two points and with , the slope is . By the fact in the strategy, every point of the locus lies on the line through and .
Every point of is on the locus
The line is not vertical, since and have different abscissae. Let be any point of , with abscissa . The locus contains , which lies on by the previous step. Both points are on and on the vertical line through , and a non-vertical line meets a vertical line only once, so . Hence the locus is exactly .
Conversely, every line has such an equation
A vertical line is , that is . A non-vertical line through with slope consists of the points with , which is .
Complete the squares to turn the equation into a statement about the distance from , and use Pythagoras: the distance from to is .
Complete the squares
Since and , the equation is equivalent to .
Read the left side as a squared distance
By Pythagoras the left side is the square of the distance from to . So the locus is the set of points with .
Three cases
If , the locus is the set of points at distance from : the circle. If it is , then and the only point is the centre. If it is negative, no point qualifies, because .
Every circle has such an equation
The circle with centre and radius is ; expanding gives the form with , , , and then .
Worked examples and exercises
Hardy gives no numbered examples in §21; these practise its statements.
For the line , write as a function of and as a function of . Where does the line cross the axes?
Hint
Solution
and . Both are one-valued and defined everywhere, as they must be for a line that is neither vertical nor horizontal. Putting gives ; putting gives . So the line crosses the axes at and .
Find the centre and radius of , and decide what represents.
Hint
Solution
First: , , , so the centre is and : radius . Check by completing squares: .
Second: , , , and . The equation is , which no point satisfies: the locus is empty.
Hardy remarks that when the equation makes “a function of defined for one value only of , and then having all values”. Explain this in terms of the definition of a function, and say which of the characteristics (1), (2), (3) of §20 it has.
Hint
Solution
With (and ) the equation is , which does not mention . If it is true whatever is, so every real corresponds to this . If it is false whatever is, so no corresponds. Thus is defined only at , where it is infinitely many-valued. It lacks (1) and (2). It is given by an equation, so in the loose sense it has (3). It is still a function in Hardy’s sense, a very degenerate one.
For which values of is the locus of a circle, a point, or empty? For which does the circle pass through the origin?
Hint
Solution
. The locus is a circle with centre and radius when , the single point when , and empty when . It passes through when , that is , giving the circle of radius about . In polar coordinates this is , which reappears in the next lesson.
Check yourself
Every equation (with , not both zero) defines as a one-valued function of .
False. If the line is vertical: is then defined for a single only, and has every value there. When the statement is true.
What is the radius of the circle ?
, , , so the radius is . (The circle passes through the origin, since .)
The locus of is
Completing the square gives . Both squares must be zero, so and . In the notation of the theorem, . The first option forgets to subtract .
For the point , which statement is correct?
The abscissa is the first coordinate (measured along the axis of ), the ordinate the second. The distance from is , which is the polar coordinate of the next lesson.
Hardy’s language
Summary
- A point is fixed by its coordinates : abscissa and ordinate. The graph of a function is the set of all points with a value at .
- An equation represents its locus: the set of points whose coordinates satisfy it.
- (with , not both ) is a straight line, and every line has such an equation; gives a vertical line.
- is a circle about of radius when that is positive, a point when it is zero, and nothing when it is negative.