Chapter II · Functions of real variables
Loci in space
Why one equation in x, y, z gives a surface and two give a curve; cylinders, cones and surfaces of revolution; and Hardy’s curved surface built entirely from straight rods.
Why this matters
In the plane one equation gives a curve. In space it does not: one equation gives a surface, and it takes two equations to pin down a curve. §33 explains this by counting degrees of freedom, and then works through the standard families of surfaces: cylinders, cones, surfaces of revolution and ruled surfaces. The counting idea (each independent equation removes one degree of freedom) is the germ of the notion of dimension, and these surfaces are the stock examples of the calculus of several variables.
The idea
A point moving on a line has one degree of freedom: one number fixes its position. On a plane it has two, and in space three. An equation is a condition, and a condition generally removes one degree of freedom. So in space:
- one equation leaves two degrees of freedom: a surface;
- two equations leave one: a curve, for instance a circle as the intersection of a sphere and a plane;
- three equations leave none: generally a finite set of points.
The word “generally” matters: equations can be dependent or contradictory, and the locus can be smaller (or empty) than the count suggests.
Try this. Start with the sphere and the plane and move through ; turn and tilt the picture. Then choose the cylinder and switch between the three curves.
- sphere
- plane z = h
- their intersection
What to notice
Each equation alone is a surface; together they are satisfied only on the purple circle, which shrinks to a point at and disappears beyond. The cylinder shows the other side of the coin: the plane-curve equation , read in space, says nothing about , so it is satisfied on every vertical line through the circle. To get the circle itself you need the second equation .
Precise statements
The locus of a single equation (in particular ) is called a surface. The locus of two equations, and , is called a curve. Thus a straight line is given by two equations of the first degree, and a circle by , .
As Hardy says, a “surface” in this sense “may or may not satisfy our common-sense notion of what a surface should be”: is a single point.
A cylinder is the surface formed by the lines parallel to through the points of a plane curve , . A cone with vertex is a surface formed by straight lines through . A surface of revolution is formed by rotating a curve about an axis. A ruled surface is one formed by a moving straight line.
(i) Regarded as a locus in space, the single equation is the cylinder through the plane curve , .
(ii) The right circular cone with vertex , axis and semi-vertical angle is .
(iii) Rotating the curve , (with ) about gives the surface .
(iv) An equation that is unchanged when is replaced by for every represents a cone with vertex (together with itself, if satisfies it).
Proofs
For (i): an equation that does not mention cannot distinguish two points that differ only in . For (iii): a point is on the surface of revolution exactly when rotating it about into the half-plane , lands it on the curve; rotation keeps the height and the distance from the axis.
(i) Vertical lines
If satisfies then so does for every , since does not occur. And a point satisfies the equation only if does. So the locus consists of exactly the vertical lines through the points of the plane curve.
(iii) What rotation preserves
Rotating a point about moves it on a horizontal circle centred on the axis: its height and its distance from do not change. Every point can be rotated to the point of the half-plane , .
(iii) The condition
The point is on the surface exactly when is on the generating curve , that is, when . This is the rule: in the curve’s equation, replace by .
(ii) The cone as a special case
The cone is generated by the line , (and its mirror image , which gives the same surface). Rotating gives , i.e. , a cone “extending both ways from its vertex”.
Hardy’s most striking example is a curved surface made entirely of straight lines. Imagine a cylinder of radius built from straight rods of length joining two circular rings. Unfasten the top end of each rod and turn it round the ring through an angle , so that the rings move closer together to keep the rods straight. The rods now form a waisted surface like a napkin ring.
Try this. Start at and twist slowly towards ; turn the picture to look along the axis and from the side.
- straight rods
- one rod PQ′
- the circular end rings
- the waist
What to notice
Every rod stays straight, yet the surface curves: it narrows to a waist of radius halfway up, while the rings come closer together. At it is a cylinder; near the waist shrinks to almost nothing and the surface approaches a double cone.
Parametrise one rod, compute the distance from the axis of its point at height , and observe that it depends only on : the surface is a surface of revolution, whose equation we can then write down.
The rod and its points
Put the lower ring at height , so a rod runs from to . The chord between the feet of and has length , so , Hardy’s relation. The point a fraction of the way along is , at height .
Its distance from the axis
The horizontal part is with , of length at angle , so its squared length is . Writing and using , , this simplifies to .
It depends only on the height
Since , the distance from the axis depends on alone, the same for every rod (every ). So the surface is a surface of revolution, and by (iii) its equation is .
Name it
For this is with and positive constants , : a hyperboloid of one sheet, with its narrowest circle (radius ) halfway up. A surface curved in every direction, made of straight lines.
Worked examples and exercises
What is generally represented by three equations ? Three linear equations generally represent a single point: what are the exceptional cases?
Hint
Solution
Each equation removes one degree of freedom, so three equations generally leave a finite number of isolated points (for example a sphere, a plane and another plane meet in at most two points).
Three planes meet in a single point unless they are in special position: (a) two of them are parallel and distinct, or all three are, so there is no common point; (b) the three lines in which they meet in pairs are parallel (a “triangular prism”): no common point; (c) all three pass through one line: a whole line of common points; (d) two or three of them coincide, giving a line, a plane, or nothing. Algebraically, the exceptions are exactly the cases where the determinant of the coefficients of , , is zero.
What are the equations, in space, of the plane curve drawn in the plane ? And what does the single equation represent in space?
Hint
Solution
The curve is , : the second equation confines it to the plane . The single equation represents the right circular cylinder of radius about : all vertical lines through the unit circle. Hardy’s remark is that the plane-geometry habit of reading one equation as a curve must be dropped in space.
Verify that the right circular cone with vertex , axis and semi-vertical angle is .
Hint
Solution
Let . The distance from to the axis is and its height is , so the line makes an angle with the line (taken in both directions) where . is on the cone exactly when , i.e. . The vertex also satisfies the equation. Both nappes (above and below ) are included, as Hardy requires.
Show that if an equation is unchanged when is replaced by for every , its locus is made of whole lines through ; and that an equation of the form has this property.
Hint
Solution
If is on the locus, so is for every ; together these are the whole line (apart possibly from ). So the locus is a union of lines through : a cone with vertex . For , replacing by leaves and unchanged, so the equation is unchanged. (Points with or need care, since the ratios are then undefined; an equation homogeneous in , , , such as , avoids the problem.)
For Hardy’s twisted rods with , and , find the height between the rings and the radius of the waist.
Hint
Solution
, so and . The waist radius is . With measured from the waist, the surface is .
Contour maps (Examples XIX, 5) belong to this section too; they were introduced with functions of two variables. Here is the explorer again with Hardy’s surfaces of this section.
Try this. Compare the contour maps of the cone and of the saddle while moving the level.
- the surface z = f(x, y)
- the plane , its section, and the matching contour
- other contours, equally spaced in height
What to notice
The cone’s contours are equally spaced circles (it rises at a constant slope); the saddle’s are hyperbolas, crossing at the pass. A contour map identifies a surface of revolution at a glance: its contours are concentric circles.
Check yourself
In space, the single equation represents
The equation does not mention , so every point above or below the unit circle satisfies it. The circle needs a second equation, . Mixing up the plane and space readings of an equation is the commonest error in this section.
Rods on rings of radius are twisted through . What is the radius of the waist?
. The waist is halfway up, where each rod passes closest to the axis.
A surface made entirely of straight lines must be a plane, a cylinder or a cone.
False. Hardy’s twisted rods form a hyperboloid of one sheet, curved in every direction yet composed of straight lines. (It is even doubly ruled: twisting the other way gives a second family of lines on the same surface.)
Three equations , , in , , generally represent
Each independent condition removes one of the three degrees of freedom. “Generally” excludes dependent or inconsistent equations, such as three planes through one line.
Hardy’s language
A particle which moves along a straight line has only one degree of freedom.
Summary
- In space one equation gives a surface, two a curve, three (generally) points: each independent condition removes one degree of freedom.
- A plane-curve equation , read in space, is a cylinder; adding gives the curve.
- Rotating about gives ; the cone is a special case, and equations unchanged by are cones with vertex .
- Straight rods joining two circles, twisted through , form a hyperboloid of one sheet: a curved surface made of straight lines.