The ratio of the increments of two functions equals the ratio of their derivatives at a single common point, which is the mean value theorem for a curve given by a parameter, and why one hypothesis cannot be dropped.
The mean value theorem compares the change in one function with the change in x. Often we need to compare the changes in two functions, ϕ and ψ, over the same interval: for example, to find the limit of ϕ(x)/ψ(x) when both tend to 0. §128 gives Cauchy’s generalisation, which provides a single point ξ at which the ratio of the derivatives equals the ratio of the increments. Hardy uses it in Chapter VII (§154) to evaluate limits of the form 0/0, the method usually called l’Hôpital’s rule.
The idea
Think of ψ and ϕ together as a curve in the plane, traced out as t runs from a to b: the point (ψ(t),ϕ(t)). The chord from the start to the end has slope
ψ(b)−ψ(a)ϕ(b)−ϕ(a),
and the tangent at the point with parameter t has slope ϕ′(t)/ψ′(t) (by Examples XLIV, 19). Cauchy’s theorem is the mean value theorem for such a curve: somewhere the tangent is parallel to the chord.
ExploreA tangent parallel to the chord of a curve
Try this.This is an ellipse traced by t. Move the start a and the end b of the arc with the sliders, and watch for the point where the tangent is parallel to the chord.
Curve (f(t),g(t))=(acost,bsint), on [0.3,2.4] (values of t)
xy
the curve
chord
tangent at c, parallel to the chord
Cauchy: {f(b)−f(a)}g′(c)={g(b)−g(a)}f′(c) for some c in (a,b): the tangent at c is parallel to the chord.
One point with the required tangent: c=1.35.
What to notice
Even though the arc can curl round, at least one point always has a tangent parallel to the chord. For the ellipse it is at the parameter halfway between a and b, as you can check. If the arc is long enough, there can be several such points.
Why not simply apply the mean value theorem to ϕ and to ψ separately and divide? Because that gives ϕ′(ξ1)/ψ′(ξ2) with two different points. For ϕ=x2 and ψ=x3 on [0,1]: ξ1=21 for ϕ, ξ2=1/3 for ψ, and the common point that Cauchy’s theorem promises is ξ=32, which is neither. The whole value of the theorem is that one point serves both functions.
Precise statements
TheoremCauchy’s mean value theoremHardy: §128
Suppose that (i) ϕ and ψ are continuous on [a,b] and differentiable in (a,b); (ii) ψ(b)=ψ(a); and (iii) ϕ′(x) and ψ′(x) never vanish for the same value of x. Then there is a ξ with a<ξ<b such that
ψ(b)−ψ(a)ϕ(b)−ϕ(a)=ψ′(ξ)ϕ′(ξ).
With ψ(x)=x, hypotheses (ii) and (iii) hold automatically (ψ′=1), and the theorem becomes the mean value theorem. A common modern version replaces (ii) and (iii) by the single condition “ψ′(x)=0 in (a,b)”. This implies (ii) by Rolle’s theorem and (iii) trivially.
Proofs
ProofCauchy’s mean value theorem
Strategy
As for the mean value theorem, build a combination of ϕ and ψ that vanishes at both ends, apply Rolle, and then use (iii) to show that the division at the end is legitimate.
The auxiliary function
Let χ(x)={ϕ(b)−ϕ(a)}{ψ(x)−ψ(a)}−{ψ(b)−ψ(a)}{ϕ(x)−ϕ(a)}. It is continuous on [a,b] and differentiable inside, and χ(a)=0 and χ(b)=0, the two products being equal at x=b.
Apply Rolle
For some ξ in (a,b), χ′(ξ)=0, that is,
{ϕ(b)−ϕ(a)}ψ′(ξ)={ψ(b)−ψ(a)}ϕ′(ξ).
This is the conclusion in cross-multiplied form, and it needs no extra hypothesis.
ψ′(ξ)=0
If ψ′(ξ)=0, the left side is 0, so {ψ(b)−ψ(a)}ϕ′(ξ)=0. By (ii) the first factor is not 0, so ϕ′(ξ)=0 as well: both derivatives vanish at ξ, contrary to (iii).
Divide
Since ψ′(ξ)=0 and ψ(b)−ψ(a)=0, we may divide by both, which gives the theorem.
∎
Hypothesis (iii) cannot be dropped. Hardy’s example is ϕ=x2, ψ=x3 on [−1,1]. Then ϕ(1)−ϕ(−1)=0 and ψ(1)−ψ(−1)=2, so the left side is 0, and we would need ϕ′(ξ)=2ξ=0, that is, ξ=0. But there ψ′(0)=0 too, and ϕ′(ξ)/ψ′(ξ) is 0/0.
ExploreWhere the theorem breaks: a cusp
Try this.The curve is (ψ(t),ϕ(t))=(t3,t2) for t from −1 to 1. Look for a tangent parallel to the horizontal chord. Then move a away from −1 and watch what happens.
Curve (f(t),g(t))=(t3,t2), on [−1,1] (values of t)
xy
the curve
chord
tangent at c, parallel to the chord
Cauchy: {f(b)−f(a)}g′(c)={g(b)−g(a)}f′(c) for some c in (a,b): the tangent at c is parallel to the chord.
Hypothesis fails: f′ and g′ both vanish at t = −3.57 × 10⁻¹⁷ (the curve has no tangent direction there).
No point c in (a, b) works.
What to notice
With a=−1, b=1 the only candidate is t=0, the sharp point (cusp) of the curve, where both ψ′ and ϕ′ vanish. The cross-multiplied form holds there trivially (0=0), but the curve has no tangent direction at the cusp, so the ratio form says nothing. Move a so that the interval no longer contains 0, and a genuine point c appears.
Worked examples and exercises
ExerciseOne point for both functions●○○Hardy: §128
For ϕ=x2 and ψ=x3 on [a,b], with 0<a<b, find the ξ of Cauchy’s theorem and check that it lies in (a,b).
Hint
b3−a3b2−a2=a2+ab+b2a+b, and ϕ′/ψ′=2/(3x).
Solution
We need a2+ab+b2a+b=3ξ2, so ξ=3(a+b)2(a2+ab+b2). Then ξ>a is equivalent to 2b2−ab−a2>0, that is, (2b+a)(b−a)>0, which is true. And ξ<b is equivalent to 2a2−ab−b2<0, that is, (2a+b)(a−b)<0, which is also true. For a=0, b=1 we get ξ=32, as stated in the text.
ExerciseThe ellipse●●○Hardy: §128
For the curve ψ(t)=pcost, ϕ(t)=qsint (an ellipse, p,q>0), show that on any interval [α,β] with 0<β−α<π the point of Cauchy’s theorem may be taken as ξ=21(α+β).
Hint
Use the sum-to-product formulas with m=21(α+β) and d=21(β−α).
Solution
ψ(β)−ψ(α)=p(cosβ−cosα)=−2psinmsind and ϕ(β)−ϕ(α)=q(sinβ−sinα)=2qcosmsind, with sind=0. In cross-multiplied form we need {ϕ(β)−ϕ(α)}ψ′(ξ)={ψ(β)−ψ(α)}ϕ′(ξ), that is, 2qcosmsind⋅(−psinξ)=−2psinmsind⋅qcosξ, or sinξcosm=cosξsinm, or sin(ξ−m)=0. So ξ=m works. (When sinm=0 we have ψ(β)=ψ(α), so hypothesis (ii) fails and only the cross-multiplied form is available; it still holds at ξ=m.)
ExerciseA limit of the form 0/0●●○Hardy: §§128, 154
Use Cauchy’s theorem to show that x21−cosx→21 as x→0.
Hint
Apply the theorem to ϕ(t)=1−cost and ψ(t)=t2 on [0,x] (for x>0). Both vanish at t=0.
Solution
Let 0<x<π. On [0,x], ψ′=2t vanishes only at t=0 (an end point), so (iii) holds in the open interval, and ψ(x)=ψ(0). Cauchy’s theorem gives ξ with 0<ξ<x and
x21−cosx=ψ(x)−ψ(0)ϕ(x)−ϕ(0)=2ξsinξ.
As x→+0, ξ→0 and sinξ/ξ→1, so the quotient tends to 21. The function is even, so the same holds as x→−0. Separate applications of the mean value theorem would give sinξ1/(2ξ2), with two different points, and no conclusion.
Exercisel’Hôpital’s rule, first form●●●Hardy: §128
Suppose ϕ(a)=ψ(a)=0, both are differentiable in (a,a+δ) and continuous at a, ψ′(x)=0 in (a,a+δ), and ϕ′(x)/ψ′(x)→l as x→a+0. Prove that ϕ(x)/ψ(x)→l as x→a+0.
Hint
Apply Cauchy’s theorem on [a,x] for a<x<a+δ. Why is ψ(x)=0?
Solution
For a<x<a+δ, ψ(x)=ψ(a)=0: otherwise Rolle’s theorem would give a zero of ψ′ in (a,x). Since ψ′=0, hypothesis (iii) holds. Cauchy’s theorem on [a,x] gives ξx with a<ξx<x and ϕ(x)/ψ(x)=ϕ′(ξx)/ψ′(ξx). As x→a+0, ξx→a+0, so the right side tends to l. Hence ϕ(x)/ψ(x)→l. Hardy develops this in Chapter VII.
Check yourself
Check yourselfEnter a number
For ϕ=x2, ψ=x3 on [0,1], what is the ξ of Cauchy’s mean value theorem?
Why
{ϕ(1)−ϕ(0)}/{ψ(1)−ψ(0)}=1, and ϕ′(ξ)/ψ′(ξ)=2ξ/(3ξ2)=2/(3ξ). So ξ=32.
Check yourselfTrue or false?
Cauchy’s theorem follows by applying the ordinary mean value theorem to ϕ and to ψ and dividing.
Why
False. That gives ϕ′(ξ1)/ψ′(ξ2) with two possibly different points: 21 and 1/3 in the example above. Cauchy’s theorem needs a single point, which is why its proof applies Rolle to a combination of ϕ and ψ.
Check yourselfChoose one
For ϕ=x2, ψ=x3 on [−1,1], which hypothesis of Cauchy’s theorem fails?
Why
Both functions are polynomials, and ψ(1)−ψ(−1)=2=0. But ϕ′(0)=ψ′(0)=0, and 0 is the only point where the cross-multiplied equation holds; there the ratio ϕ′/ψ′ is undefined.
Check yourselfTrue or false?
If ψ is continuous on [a,b] and ψ′(x)=0 for all x in (a,b), then ψ(b)=ψ(a).
Why
True, by Rolle’s theorem: if ψ(b)=ψ(a), then ψ′ would vanish somewhere in (a,b). This is why the modern form of the theorem needs only the single hypothesis ψ′=0.
Hardy’s language
Summary
Summary
Cauchy: under (i)–(iii), ψ(b)−ψ(a)ϕ(b)−ϕ(a)=ψ′(ξ)ϕ′(ξ) for one ξ in (a,b).
Geometrically: on the curve (ψ(t),ϕ(t)) some tangent is parallel to the chord.
Proof: Rolle applied to {ϕ(b)−ϕ(a)}{ψ(x)−ψ(a)}−{ψ(b)−ψ(a)}{ϕ(x)−ϕ(a)}.
Two separate mean value theorems give two different points; Cauchy gives one, which is what limits of the form 0/0 need.
Hypothesis (iii) is essential: at a cusp, where ϕ′=ψ′=0, the ratio is meaningless.