Chapter VI · §§111–149

Derivatives and integrals

The derivative as a limit of chord slopes, the rules for differentiating, Rolle's theorem and the mean value theorems, maxima and minima, and the systematic techniques of integration, with areas and lengths of curves.

What you will be able to do

  • differentiate from first principles and by the rules
  • recognise the ways in which a continuous function can fail to have a derivative
  • state and apply Rolle's theorem and the mean value theorem
  • find maxima and minima from the sign of the first derivative or the second derivative
  • integrate rational functions and use substitution and integration by parts
  • integrate square roots of quadratics, trigonometric and inverse functions by choosing the right method
  • find areas and lengths of curves, and explain why the derivative of an area is the ordinate

Start with “The derivative” →

Where this chapter sits

Chapter V made precise what it means for a curve to be unbroken. Chapter VI asks for more: that the curve should have a definite direction at each point. The direction is the limit of the slopes of chords, and its value is the derivative. Everything you may know from school calculus reappears here, but now each rule is proved from the definition of a limit, and the chapter is careful about exactly when the rules hold and when they break down.

The chapter has two halves. The first (§§111–129) is about differentiation: the definition, the rules, and the general theorems (Rolle’s theorem and the mean value theorem) that turn information about ϕ′\phi' into information about ϕ\phi. The second (§§130–149) runs the process backwards: given ϕ′\phi', find ϕ\phi. This is integration in Hardy’s first sense, the search for a function with a given derivative. Hardy treats it as a practical art with a small number of systematic methods. The definite integral as an area comes in Chapter VII.

Hardy writes ϕ(x)\phi(x) for a function and ϕ′(x)\phi'(x) for its derivative, and he calls the derivative a “differential coefficient”. We keep his notation in formulas and translate his vocabulary as we go (see the notation guide).

The chapter in six stages

  1. The derivative (§§111–116). The tangent as the limit of chords; the definition of ϕ′(x)\phi'(x); functions that are continuous but have no derivative at a point; the rules for sums, products, quotients, composite and inverse functions; complex-valued functions; the notation dy/dxdy/dx.
  2. Standard forms (§§117–121). Derivatives of polynomials, rational functions, algebraical functions such as xp/qx^{p/q}, and the trigonometrical functions and their inverses; second and higher derivatives, and Leibniz’s theorem.
  3. The general theorems (§§122–129). What the sign of ϕ′\phi' says about ϕ\phi; Rolle’s theorem; maxima and minima; the mean value theorem and its form due to Cauchy; Darboux’s theorem that a derivative, continuous or not, takes every intermediate value.
  4. Integration as the inverse problem (§§130–134). Integrals of polynomials and rational functions, with partial fractions.
  5. Techniques of integration (§§135–147). Algebraical functions; substitution and rationalisation; integrals connected with conics; integration by parts; integrals of trigonometrical functions.
  6. Areas and lengths (§§148–149). How derivatives and integrals measure plane areas and the lengths of curves.

How to work through it

  • Stage 1 depends on Chapter V. If “lim⁡h→0q(h)=l\lim_{h \to 0} q(h) = l” is not yet comfortable, revise §§93–97 first: the derivative is exactly such a limit, of a function q(h)q(h) that is not defined at h=0h = 0.
  • In stage 2 the rules matter more than the long lists of examples. Do a few examples of each kind by hand, and use the drills to check yourself.
  • Stage 3 is the theoretical heart of the chapter. Rolle’s theorem, the mean value theorem and Darboux’s theorem all follow from one idea: a continuous function on a closed interval attains its bounds (§103), and at an interior maximum or minimum the derivative, if it exists, is zero. Watch for that idea in every proof.
  • Stages 4–6 are practical: technique comes from doing many examples. Keep the result of §127 in mind throughout. Two functions with the same derivative on an interval differ by a constant, and that is why every integral carries a “+ C+\,C”.

Lessons

22 pages · about 835 minutes of reading, plus time with the book.

  1. §§111–113 The derivative ✓ done The tangent as the limit of chords, the derivative as the limit of a difference quotient, and the ways in which a continuous function can fail to have one.
  2. §114 The rules of differentiation ✓ done Sums, products, quotients, composite and inverse functions, each rule proved from the definition, including the case that most proofs of the chain rule get wrong.
  3. §115 Derivatives of complex-valued functions ✓ done A complex function of a real variable is differentiated part by part; its derivative is the velocity of a moving point in the Argand diagram, and rules (1)–(5) still hold.
  4. §116 The notation dy/dx ✓ done Why the derivative is written dy/dx, what that symbol does and does not mean, and the rules of differentiation restated in Leibniz’s notation.
  5. §§117–118 Derivatives of polynomials and rational functions ✓ done Polynomials differentiated term by term and factor by factor, what the derivative reveals about repeated roots, and rational functions through partial fractions, with a first proof that 1/x is not the derivative of any rational function.
  6. §§119–120 Derivatives of algebraical and trigonometrical functions ✓ done Rational powers, implicit functions, the six trigonometrical functions and their inverses, with the sign conventions that Hardy’s many-valued inverse functions require.
  7. §121 Repeated differentiation ✓ done Second and higher derivatives, the few functions whose nth derivative has a closed form, and Leibniz’s theorem for the nth derivative of a product.
  8. §122 The sign of the derivative and Rolle’s theorem ✓ done What a positive derivative says at a point and on an interval, Rolle’s theorem, and why the hypotheses are “continuous on the closed interval, differentiable on the open one”.
  9. §§123–125 Maxima and minima ✓ done Local maxima and minima, the necessary condition φ′(ξ) = 0, the sign-change and second-derivative tests, and the examples of §125 that show which assumptions really matter.
  10. §§126–127 The mean value theorem ✓ done Somewhere between a and b the tangent is parallel to the chord. The proof is Rolle’s theorem applied to the gap between curve and chord, and the consequences include “zero derivative means constant”.
  11. §128 Cauchy’s mean value theorem ✓ done The ratio of the increments of two functions equals the ratio of their derivatives at a single common point, which is the mean value theorem for a curve given by a parameter, and why one hypothesis cannot be dropped.
  12. §129 Darboux’s theorem ✓ done A derivative, whether or not it is continuous, takes every value between any two of its values, so a function with a jump can never be a derivative.
  13. §§130–131 Integration and the logarithmic function ✓ done Integration as the inverse of differentiation, why every integral carries an arbitrary constant, the first standard forms, and the logarithm as the integral of 1/x1/x.
  14. §132 Linearity, and integrals of polynomials ✓ done The integral of a sum is the sum of the integrals, constants come outside, and so every polynomial can be integrated term by term; how to check any integral by differentiating it.
  15. §§133–134 Integrating rational functions ✓ done Partial fractions reduce every real rational function to pieces we can integrate, and the answer is always a rational function plus logarithms plus inverse tangents, provided we can factor the denominator.
  16. §§135–136 Substitution and rationalisation ✓ done Changing the variable of integration, seen as a picture and as the chain rule; and the strategy of choosing a new variable that turns an algebraical integrand into a rational one.
  17. §§137–140 Integrals connected with conics ✓ done Why every integral ∫R(x,ax2+2bx+c) dx\int R(x, \sqrt{ax^2+2bx+c})\,dx can be rationalised (a line through a point of a conic meets it once more), and the standard forms for 1/X1/\sqrt{X} and (λx+μ)/X(\lambda x + \mu)/\sqrt{X}.
  18. §§141–142 Integration by parts, and the general integral ∫R(x,X) dx\int R(x, \sqrt X)\,dx ✓ done The product rule read backwards, seen as two areas that fill a rectangle; its use for ∫X dx\int\sqrt{X}\,dx; and Hardy's plan for integrating any rational function of xx and the square root of a quadratic.
  19. §§143–147 Integrating transcendental functions ✓ done The classes of trigonometric, inverse and logarithmic integrands that can always be integrated: products of sines and cosines, xncos⁡xx^n\cos x, rational functions of cos⁡x\cos x and sin⁡x\sin x via t=tan⁡12xt = \tan\frac12 x, and inverse functions by parts.
  20. §148 Areas of plane curves ✓ done Why the derivative of the area under a curve is the height of the curve, how that turns area problems into integration problems, and how to find areas of loops given parametrically or in polar coordinates.
  21. §149 Lengths of plane curves ✓ done Why length is harder to pin down than area, the formula S′(x)=1+ϕ′(x)2S'(x) = \sqrt{1 + \phi'(x)^2} and what it assumes, and its parametric and polar forms.
  22. Problems Chapter VI problems ✓ done Eleven of Hardy's Miscellaneous Examples on Chapter VI, from derivatives and mean values to reduction formulas, lengths and areas, with graded hints and full solutions.