Chapter VI · Derivatives and integrals
Chapter VI problems
Eleven of Hardy's Miscellaneous Examples on Chapter VI, from derivatives and mean values to reduction formulas, lengths and areas, with graded hints and full solutions.
How to use this page
Hardy’s Miscellaneous Examples at the end of Chapter VI are hard and very varied: many come from the Cambridge Mathematical Tripos. We have chosen eleven that cover the whole chapter: four on derivatives and mean values, two on limits at infinity, three on integration and two on lengths and areas. Each problem is restated in our words with its number. Try each for a while before opening the first hint; the hints go from a gentle nudge to most of the idea.
Levels: one dot is routine once you know the relevant lesson, two dots need an idea, three dots are hard.
Derivatives and mean values
Let for , for , for , and for . Discuss the continuity of , and the existence of , at , and .
Hint
Hint
Solution
At . , but as . So is discontinuous at and has no derivative there.
At . , the limit from the left is and from the right , so is continuous. The left difference quotient is and the right one is . They differ, so does not exist: the graph has a corner.
At . , but as . So is discontinuous at and has no derivative.
Elsewhere exists: it is for , ; for ; and for .
Let for and write for the th derivative. Show that , and that for
Hence find the values of all the derivatives of at .
Hint
Hint
Hint
Solution
The first relation. , so . Differentiating, . Divide by (which is not identically zero; the identity then holds everywhere by continuity): .
The recurrence. Differentiate times (). By Leibniz’s theorem, since has derivatives , , :
and . Subtracting: , and .
Values at . , , and from the first relation . The recurrence at gives . So every odd derivative vanishes, and , , ; in general
A cubic has roots . Divide and each into six equal parts. Show that a root of lies in the fourth part counted from on each side. When can a root of fall exactly on a point of division?
Hint
Hint
Solution
With we get . Then
By the intermediate value theorem has a root strictly between and , which is the fourth sixth of counted from . The other side is the same computation with the roles of and exchanged (replace by ).
Neither value vanishes when , so the root never lies on a point of division. It does so only in the limiting case where two roots coincide: if , then . So a root of falls on a point of division exactly when the cubic has a double root (and then it falls on the point two sixths of the way from the simple root).
Let and be continuous on and differentiable on . Show that there is a in with
so that whenever the denominators are not zero.
Hint
Solution
is continuous on , differentiable inside, and . By Rolle’s theorem (§122) there is with . By the product rule,
and is the stated equation. Dividing by when it is not zero gives the quotient form. Unlike Cauchy’s theorem, the “increments” here are taken from opposite ends: from up to , from up to .
Behaviour at infinity
(i) If as , show that ; if , that ; and if , that .
(ii) Deduce that if (finite), then cannot tend to any limit other than .
Hint
Hint
Solution
(i) Let and choose with for all . For the mean value theorem gives with , so
With fixed, the first term tends to , so for all large . Hence : if this says , and if it says .
If , choose with for ; then .
(ii) If , part (i) gives , so , contradicting . (Likewise forces .) So the only possible limit of is . It need not have one at all: tends to while oscillates.
Suppose is differentiable and as . Prove that and .
Hint
Hint
Hint
Solution
Let ; then . Given , choose with for .
Case 1: has no zeros beyond some point . By Darboux’s theorem (§129) a derivative without zeros on an interval has constant sign there; say for all . Then increases on (§126), so tends to a finite limit or to . If then , contradicting . So , hence , and by Misc. Ex. 49 (previous problem) . So . The case is symmetric.
Case 2: has zeros beyond every point. Pick a zero . We show for all . Suppose for some . Then . Let be a point of where attains its maximum there (§103), so .
- is impossible: a maximum at the right end forces .
- inside is impossible: then , so .
- is impossible for the same reason, since .
So for ; the same argument with the minimum gives . Hence .
In both cases , and . (With the exponential function of Chapter IX there is a one-line proof: and Cauchy’s mean value theorem. The argument above uses only Chapter VI.)
Integration
Calculate (a) , (b) , (c) for (principal value, between and ).
Hint
Hint
Hint
Solution
(a) . Since , the integral is simply .
(b) . Now . So
(c) .
Each answer has been checked by differentiation.
Let . Show that for , and use it to find .
Hint
Hint
Solution
By parts, with and :
Hence . Starting from :
(As always, the reduction formula is an equation between families of integrals; with particular integrals chosen as above it holds exactly.)
Let be a positive integer and . Show that
Hint
Solution
For the formula says , which is true. Suppose it holds for :
Then , and . So
which is the stated formula (put ). The reduction formula itself comes from parts: .
Lengths and areas
Show that the length of a quadrant of (, ) is .
Hint
Hint
Solution
With , : , , so for
Put ; then , so an integral is . As goes from to , goes from to , and the length is
(For the curve is an astroid, and the limit is its quadrant length.)
A point lies inside a circle of radius , at distance from the centre. Show that the locus of the foot of the perpendicular from to a tangent of the circle encloses the area .
Hint
Hint
Solution
The distance from to the line is (as ), and the foot is reached from by moving that distance along the normal direction . So, with polar coordinates centred at , the locus is , : a limaçon without an inner loop, described once.
By the polar area formula of §148 (Ex. LIV. 18), its area is
since integrates to over a full turn and to . When is the centre () the locus is the circle itself.