Chapter I · Real variables

The number 2\sqrt2

§12 20 min

A check that the construction works; the section called √2 really does square to 2, and the equation x² = 2 has exactly two real roots.

Why this matters

We built the section x2<2x^2 < 2, x2>2x^2 > 2 because 22 ought to have a square root, and called it 2\sqrt2. But a name is not a proof. Now that multiplication of sections is defined, §12 checks the claim: the product of this section with itself is the section for the rational number 22. This is the moment where the whole construction pays off: the equation x2=2x^2 = 2, which had no solution among the rationals, has solutions among the reals.

The idea

By the definition of products (§11), 2⋅2\sqrt2 \cdot \sqrt2 is found by multiplying lower members together and upper members together:

  • the lower products aa′a a', where aa and a′a' are positive rationals with squares less than 22, are all less than 22, since aa′≤max⁡(a,a′)2<2aa' \le \max(a, a')^2 < 2;
  • the upper products AA′A A', where A2>2A^2 > 2 and A′2>2A'^2 > 2, are all greater than 22.

So 22 itself is never one of these products. The question is whether anything else is missed, and the answer is no: products can be pushed as close to 22 as we like from both sides. So 22 is the single rational left out, and it goes into the upper class.

Explore Square the section 2\sqrt2

Try this. Increase the number of decimal places kk step by step. At each step read off the largest lower product c=a2c = a^2 and the smallest upper product C=A2C = A^2, and see where 22 is.

α=2, β=2\alpha = \sqrt2,\ \beta = \sqrt2: the classes (c)=(ab)(c) = (ab) and (C)=(AB)(C) = (AB)
(c)(C)1.71.81.92.02.12.22.32.42.52
  • products ab
  • products AB
  • the exact value (rational)
lower memberupper member
α\alphaa = 1.4A = 1.5
β\betab = 1.4B = 1.5
α⋅β\alpha \cdot \betac = 1.96C = 2.25
Gap: C−c=(A−a)B+a(B−b)=10−1(B+a)≈0.29C - c = (A - a)B + a(B - b) = 10^{-1}(B + a) \approx 0.29. Every rational below c is a sum (product) of members of the lower classes, every rational above C one of the upper classes; only the gap is undecided, and it shrinks to nothing as k grows. The rational 22 sits strictly inside every gap: it is the one rational that belongs to neither class. Hardy puts it in the upper class, so the section is the rational number 22, that is, 2⋅2=2\sqrt2 \cdot \sqrt2 = 2.
What to notice

The rational 22 is strictly inside every gap (c,C)(c, C), and the gap shrinks roughly tenfold each time. Any rational other than 22 is eventually outside the gap, on one side or the other. So the classes (aa′)(aa'), (AA′)(AA') miss exactly one rational, 22, and the product is the rational number 22.

Precise statements

As in §8, 2\sqrt2 now denotes the section of all rationals whose lower class is {x:x≤0 or x2<2}\{x : x \le 0 \text{ or } x^2 < 2\}.

Theorem 2\sqrt2 squares to 22 Hardy: §12

2⋅2=2\sqrt2 \cdot \sqrt2 = 2 and (−2)(−2)=2(-\sqrt2)(-\sqrt2) = 2. Hence the equation x2=2x^2 = 2 has the two real roots 2\sqrt2 and −2-\sqrt2, and no others.

The same argument gives the square roots of every positive rational that is not a square, and cube roots too: 3⋅3=3\sqrt3 \cdot \sqrt3 = 3, (73)3=7(\sqrt[3]{7})^3 = 7, and so on.

Proofs

Proof 2⋅2=2\sqrt2 \cdot \sqrt2 = 2
Strategy

Work with sections of the positive rationals, as the definition of products requires. Show that every lower product is below 22, every upper product above 22, and that every positive rational other than 22 is a lower or an upper product. Then 22 is the one leftover, and goes to the upper class.

Lower products are below 22, upper products above

If a,a′a, a' are positive with a2,a′2<2a^2, a'^2 < 2, then aa′≤max⁡(a,a′)2<2aa' \le \max(a, a')^2 < 2. If A2,A′2>2A^2, A'^2 > 2, then AA′≥min⁡(A,A′)2>2AA' \ge \min(A, A')^2 > 2.

Every positive rational r<2r < 2 is a lower product

By §4, there is a member aa of the lower class with 2−a2<2−r2 - a^2 < 2 - r, that is, a2>ra^2 > r. Put a′=r/aa' = r/a. Then a′<aa' < a, so a′2<a2<2a'^2 < a^2 < 2 and a′a' is in the lower class; and aa′=raa' = r.

Every rational r>2r > 2 is an upper product

In the same way choose AA in the upper class with A2<rA^2 < r, and put A′=r/A>AA' = r/A > A. Then A′2>A2>2A'^2 > A^2 > 2, so A′A' is in the upper class, and AA′=rAA' = r.

So 22 is the only rational left out

Every positive rational except 22 is in one of the two classes, and 22 is in neither. By the definition of the product, 22 is added to the upper class, where it is the least member. The resulting section is the rational number 22. (Adding 00 and the negatives to the lower class, as in §8, gives the same number among sections of all rationals.)

The negative root

By the sign rule (−α)(−β)=αβ(-\alpha)(-\beta) = \alpha\beta, we get (−2)(−2)=2 2=2(-\sqrt2)(-\sqrt2) = \sqrt2\,\sqrt2 = 2.

No other roots

If x2=2x^2 = 2 then x2−(2)2=0x^2 - (\sqrt2)^2 = 0, that is, (x−2)(x+2)=0(x - \sqrt2)(x + \sqrt2) = 0, using the laws of algebra established in §11. A product of real numbers is 00 only if a factor is 00 (multiply by the reciprocal of the other factor), so x=2x = \sqrt2 or x=−2x = -\sqrt2.

Notice what the proof did not need: any decimal expansion of 2\sqrt2, or any limit. Everything was a statement about which rationals lie in which class.

Worked examples and exercises

Exercise 3⋅3=3\sqrt3 \cdot \sqrt3 = 3 ●○○ Hardy: §12

Adapt the proof to show that 3⋅3=3\sqrt3 \cdot \sqrt3 = 3, where 3\sqrt3 is the section by x2<3x^2 < 3, x2>3x^2 > 3.

Hint
You need the fact, proved for 22 in §4, that lower members can have squares as close to 33 as we please. Check that the argument there did not use anything special about 22.

Solution

The argument of §4 works for any positive rational NN that is not a square: since no rational squares to NN, the condition x2<Nx^2 < N defines a section, members of the two classes can be found as close as we please, and (y−x)(y+x)(y - x)(y + x) bounds y2−x2y^2 - x^2. So for r<3r < 3 choose aa with r<a2<3r < a^2 < 3 and set a′=r/a<aa' = r/a < a; for r>3r > 3 choose AA with 3<A2<r3 < A^2 < r and set A′=r/A>AA' = r/A > A. Lower products are <3< 3 and upper ones >3> 3 as before. The only rational left out is 33, so 3⋅3=3\sqrt3 \cdot \sqrt3 = 3.

Exercise 2⋅3=6\sqrt2 \cdot \sqrt3 = \sqrt6 ●●○ Hardy: §12

Show that 2⋅3=6\sqrt2 \cdot \sqrt3 = \sqrt6.

Hint
Show that the lower class of the product is {x>0:x2<6}\{x > 0 : x^2 < 6\}. One inclusion: (ab)2=a2b2<6(ab)^2 = a^2b^2 < 6.

Solution

Positive lower products satisfy (ab)2=a2b2<2⋅3=6(ab)^2 = a^2 b^2 < 2 \cdot 3 = 6, and upper products (AB)2>6(AB)^2 > 6. Conversely let r>0r > 0 with r2<6r^2 < 6. Choose a lower member aa of 2\sqrt2 with a2>r2/3a^2 > r^2/3 (possible because r2/3<2r^2/3 < 2), and put b=r/ab = r/a. Then b2=r2/a2<3b^2 = r^2/a^2 < 3, so bb is a lower member of 3\sqrt3, and ab=rab = r. Similarly every rr with r2>6r^2 > 6 is an upper product. No rational has square 66 (66 is not a perfect square), so no rational is left out, and the product is exactly the section x2<6x^2 < 6, x2>6x^2 > 6, which is 6\sqrt6.

Exercise 1/2=1221/\sqrt2 = \tfrac12\sqrt2 ●●○ Hardy: §12

Using the definition of the reciprocal from §11, show that 1/21/\sqrt2 is the section of the positive rationals by x2<12x^2 < \tfrac12, x2>12x^2 > \tfrac12, and deduce that 1/2=1221/\sqrt2 = \tfrac12\sqrt2.

Hint
The lower class of 1/α1/\alpha is all 1/A1/A. If A2>2A^2 > 2, what is (1/A)2(1/A)^2?

Solution

The lower class of 1/21/\sqrt2 consists of the numbers 1/A1/A with A2>2A^2 > 2, that is, of the positive xx with (1/x)2>2(1/x)^2 > 2, which is x2<12x^2 < \tfrac12; similarly the upper class is x2>12x^2 > \tfrac12. On the other hand 122⋅122=14⋅2=12\tfrac12\sqrt2 \cdot \tfrac12\sqrt2 = \tfrac14 \cdot 2 = \tfrac12 (by the laws of algebra and the theorem above), and 122>0\tfrac12\sqrt2 > 0. Since x2=12x^2 = \tfrac12 has only one positive root (the argument of the last proof step), 1/21/\sqrt2 and 122\tfrac12\sqrt2, which are both positive with square 12\tfrac12, are equal.

Exercise A cube root ●●○ Hardy: §12

Let 23\sqrt[3]{2} be the section of the positive rationals by x3<2x^3 < 2, x3>2x^3 > 2. Show that (23)3=2(\sqrt[3]{2})^3 = 2, assuming that cubes of lower and upper members can be pushed as close to 22 as we please.

Hint
The cube is a product of three sections. Its lower class is all aa′a′′aa'a'', its upper class all AA′A′′AA'A''.

Solution

Each lower product aa′a′′aa'a'' is at most max⁡(a,a′,a′′)3<2\max(a, a', a'')^3 < 2 and each upper product exceeds 22, so 22 is left out. For a positive rational r<2r < 2 choose a lower member aa with a3>ra^3 > r and put a′=aa' = a, a′′=r/a2<aa'' = r/a^2 < a; then a′′3<a3<2a''^3 < a^3 < 2, so all three are lower members and their product is rr. Symmetrically every r>2r > 2 is an upper product. So 22 is the only rational left out, and the cube is 22.

Check yourself

Check yourself Choose one

In the product 2⋅2\sqrt2 \cdot \sqrt2, which rational belongs to neither (aa′)(aa') nor (AA′)(AA')?

Why

Lower products are below 22 and upper products above 22, so 22 is missed. Every other rational is reached (the proof shows how), so exactly one is missed, as the general theorem of §10 guarantees. The number 1.41421.4142 is in the lower class of 2\sqrt2, not of the product.

Check yourself Enter a number

With 22-place decimals, a=1.41a = 1.41 and A=1.42A = 1.42. What is the gap C−c=A2−a2C - c = A^2 - a^2?

Why

1.422−1.412=2.0164−1.9881=0.02831.42^2 - 1.41^2 = 2.0164 - 1.9881 = 0.0283, which also equals (A−a)(A+a)=0.01×2.83(A - a)(A + a) = 0.01 \times 2.83. The number 22 is inside: 1.9881<2<2.01641.9881 < 2 < 2.0164.

Check yourself True or false?

The proof that 2⋅2=2\sqrt2 \cdot \sqrt2 = 2 needs the decimal expansion of 2\sqrt2 and the notion of a limit.

Why

False. It only compares rational numbers: lower products are below 22, upper ones above, and every other rational is a lower or upper product. Decimals are a convenient way to see this, as in the widget, but the proof does not use them.

Hardy’s language

Summary

Summary
  • The product 2⋅2\sqrt2 \cdot \sqrt2 has lower class all aa′<2aa' < 2 and upper class all AA′>2AA' > 2.
  • Every rational other than 22 is a lower or an upper product; 22 is the single leftover, so the product is the number 22.
  • By the sign rule (−2)2=2(-\sqrt2)^2 = 2 too, and these are the only two real roots of x2=2x^2 = 2.
  • The same argument constructs N\sqrt N for any non-square positive rational NN, and cube roots similarly.