Chapter I · §§1–19

Real variables

What is a number? Starting from the rationals, Hardy shows that they leave gaps (no rational squares to 2), fills the gaps with Dedekind sections, and arrives at the continuum of real numbers, its points of accumulation and Weierstrass's theorem.

What you will be able to do

  • explain why the rational numbers leave gaps, and prove that no rational number squares to 2
  • define a real number as a section of the rationals and compute with such sections
  • state and use Dedekind's theorem and Weierstrass's theorem on points of accumulation

Start with “Rational numbers and the line” →

Why the book starts here

Calculus is about quantities that vary continuously, and limits that are approached. Both ideas quietly assume that the number line has no holes: that there is a number at the end of every process that ought to have an end. Chapter I asks whether that assumption is justified, and answers it. The rational numbers, the fractions p/qp/q, turn out to be full of holes (there is no fraction whose square is 22). Hardy fills the holes with a construction due to Dedekind, a section of the rationals, and then proves that the enlarged system, the real numbers, has no holes left. Everything in later chapters, from the existence of limits in Chapter IV to the intermediate value theorem in Chapter V, rests on that last fact.

The chapter is short, but its style is different from a school textbook. Hardy is not computing; he is deciding what numbers are. Read it slowly, and use the interactive figures to make each definition concrete before you read the proof that goes with it.

The chapter in four stages

  1. Rationals and their gaps (§§1–5). Fractions on a line; they are dense (between any two there are infinitely many), yet no fraction squares to 22. The positive fractions split into those with x2<2x^2 < 2 and those with x2>2x^2 > 2, with nothing in between.
  2. Real numbers as sections (§§6–12). A section (a Dedekind cut) is a division of the rationals into a lower and an upper class. Hardy defines a real number to be such a section, and then defines order, sums and products of sections so that the ordinary rules of algebra hold. As a check, the section called 2\sqrt2 really does square to 22.
  3. Surds and the variety of numbers (§§13–16). Quadratic surds such as a+ba + \sqrt b, which are exactly the lengths you can build with ruler and compasses from square roots, and how special they are among all real numbers; then what Hardy means by a “variable”.
  4. Completeness (§§17–19). Dedekind’s theorem: a section of the real numbers always has a real number at the cut, so no new gaps appear. From it, Weierstrass’s theorem: an infinite bounded set always has a point of accumulation.

How to work through it

  • Hardy offers a shortcut: you may simply assume that numbers like 2\sqrt2 exist and obey the usual rules, and skip from §5 to §13. Do not take it. The construction in stage 2 is the clearest example in the book of a definition doing real work, and stage 4 depends on it.
  • Stage 2 is where readers most often lose the thread. Keep one picture in mind throughout: a real number is a place on the line where the rationals can be split into “left” and “right”. Every definition (order, sum, product) is a statement about the two classes.
  • The Examples in this chapter are mostly short algebra. Do a few from each lesson; the problems page collects harder ones from the end of the chapter, including the inequality between arithmetic and geometric means.
  • Stage 4 is used constantly later. Make sure you can state Dedekind’s theorem and Weierstrass’s theorem, and explain why each fails for the rational numbers alone.

Lessons

13 pages · about 455 minutes of reading, plus time with the book.

  1. §§1–2 Rational numbers and the line ✓ done Fractions in lowest terms, how to list all of them in a single sequence, and how they are placed as points on a line.
  2. §§3–7 Irrational numbers and sections ✓ done The rationals are dense but full of holes; Hardy splits them into two classes at each hole and takes the split itself as the new number.
  3. §8 Real numbers ✓ done Sections of all the rationals, not only the positive ones, give the real numbers, with zero, positive and negative numbers distinguished by where 0 falls.
  4. §9 Order, negatives and modulus ✓ done When one section is less than another, why any two can be compared, and how to define −α-\alpha and ∣α∣|\alpha| from the classes.
  5. §§10–11 Arithmetic with real numbers ✓ done How to add, subtract, multiply and divide sections, and why the result is always a well-defined real number.
  6. §12 The number 2\sqrt2 ✓ done A check that the construction works; the section called √2 really does square to 2, and the equation x² = 2 has exactly two real roots.
  7. §13 Quadratic surds ✓ done Numbers like 3\sqrt3 and 2−52 - \sqrt5, the roots of quadratic equations, and the lengths that ruler and compasses can construct.
  8. §14 Theorems on quadratic surds ✓ done Similar and dissimilar surds, why A+B=C+DA + \sqrt B = C + \sqrt D forces A=CA = C and B=DB = D, and why q\sqrt q and −q-\sqrt q are indistinguishable to arithmetic.
  9. §§15–16 The continuum and the real variable ✓ done How few real numbers are surds, how a section defines numbers that no formula can express, and what Hardy means by a variable.
  10. §17 Sections of the reals and Dedekind's theorem ✓ done Cutting the real numbers produces nothing new; every section of the reals has a real number at the join.
  11. §18 Points of accumulation ✓ done When points of a set crowd arbitrarily close to a given point, and why "arbitrarily close" forces "infinitely many".
  12. §19 Weierstrass's theorem ✓ done Every infinite set inside a bounded interval has a point of accumulation, proved from Dedekind's theorem and, alternatively, by repeated bisection.
  13. Problems Chapter I problems ✓ done Twelve of the Miscellaneous Examples on Chapter I, on rational and irrational numbers, surds and the classical inequalities, with graded hints and full solutions.