Chapter V · Limits of functions of a continuous variable. Continuous and discontinuous functions
Chapter V problems
Eleven of Hardy’s Miscellaneous Examples on Chapter V, on limits, orders of smallness, continuity, monotone and inverse functions, with graded hints and full solutions.
These are selected from the Miscellaneous Examples at the end of Hardy’s Chapter V, restated in modern notation. They are harder than the examples in the lessons, and several combine ideas from different sections. Try each one for a good while before opening the first hint; the hints go from a gentle nudge to most of the idea. Levels: one dot is routine, two need an idea, three are challenging.
Limits and orders of smallness
Show that .
Hint
Hint
Solution
For ,
As , , so (by the continuity of at ; directly, ). The denominator tends to , and the limit is .
Let . Find and such that as , and prove that then
Hint
Hint
Solution
Choice of , . If the difference tends to , dividing by gives , so . Put , so that . For large (where both are positive),
The denominator tends to , so ; and any other would give . So , are the only values.
The second limit. Dividing the denominator by , it becomes . Hence
In the language of §98: unless , the curve approaches its asymptote with an error of the first order of smallness.
Prove that as .
Hint
Solution
For ,
As (from either side), and , by the continuity of and . So the limit is . Both and tend to separately; it is their difference that has a limit.
Prove that is of the fourth order of smallness as , and find .
Hint
Hint
Solution
Let . For , , and as . For such ,
The second factor tends to . For the first: as , and tends to through non-zero values; so given , choose with for , then with for . Hence , and
So is of the fourth order of smallness, . (The step “” matters: a limit is not a value, so we may only substitute into a limit statement about if avoids the excluded point.)
For which values of does tend to , and for which to , as ? What happens otherwise, and what happens as ?
Hint
Hint
Solution
. The numerator is at least , so for the function is at least , which exceeds any once . It tends to .
. Similarly the numerator is at most , and the function tends to .
. At the value is , and at it is . Both sequences of points tend to . If the first values tend to and the second to ; if the second values are while the first tend to ; if the reverse. In every case the function is unbounded near and does not tend to : it oscillates infinitely.
As the factor is negative, so the conclusions swap: for , for , infinite oscillation otherwise. So for the point is an infinity of the function, with opposite signs on the two sides.
Continuity and discontinuity
Let when is rational (in lowest terms, ) and when is irrational. Show that is continuous at every irrational and discontinuous at every rational point.
Hint
Hint
Solution
Rational . . Every interval round contains irrationals, where . With no works, so is discontinuous at (in fact by the argument below, so it is a removable discontinuity).
Irrational . . Let and . A fraction in with has , so there are finitely many such fractions, and none equals . Let be smaller than and than the distance from to each of them. If , then either is irrational and , or with , that is , so . In both cases : is continuous at .
Let when is rational and when is irrational. Show that, as goes from to , takes every value between and once and only once, but that is discontinuous at every point except .
Hint
Hint
Solution
Each value once. Let . If is rational, then is rational with ; an irrational would need , making rational, which is impossible. If is irrational, is irrational with ; a rational would need , which is irrational. So exactly one in gives each .
Continuity. Fix . Every interval round contains rationals , with close to , and irrationals , with close to . If , take : points of both kinds arbitrarily near give values near and near , which cannot both be within of . So is discontinuous. At : , and equals for rational and for irrational . So , and works.
This is a second, more extreme, example of the failure of the converse of the intermediate value theorem (§101).
Call increasing at if (i) for all in some interval to the right of , and (ii) for all in some interval to the left of ; and increasing on the right if (i) alone holds. Prove that a function increasing at every point of is increasing on . Show that “increasing on the right” at every point is not enough, but is enough if is also continuous.
Hint
Hint
Solution
The theorem. Let ; we show . Let be the set of in with for every in , and its upper bound. By (i) at , contains an interval , so . Every with lies in some with , so .
. By (ii) at , there are just to the left of (and to the right of ) with . So .
. If , (i) at gives an interval on which ; then , contradicting . So , and in particular .
Continuity instead of (ii). Only the step used (ii). If is continuous at , then , since every in has . The rest is unchanged.
Counterexample. On let for and for . At every point, is increasing on the right (to the right of , ). But , so is not increasing. Condition (ii) fails at , which is exactly where is discontinuous.
Implicit and inverse functions
Let be a polynomial with no terms of degree less than . Show that defines a unique function , vanishing at and continuous near .
Hint
Hint
Solution
is a polynomial, hence continuous, and because has no constant term. For monotonicity, the monomials of with cancel in , and each monomial with contributes , where the cofactor is a polynomial in of total degree (because ). So
with a polynomial without constant term. is continuous and , so when for some . There has the sign of : is strictly increasing in . By §109 there is a unique continuous near with and . (Example: gives .)
Let . Show that has a solution , vanishing with and continuous near , given by
Hint
Hint
Solution
Existence. , and the bracket has the sign of when are small. So is continuous and strictly monotone near , with , and §110 gives a unique continuous near with and .
First order. and as (continuity), so for (then ): , in particular .
Second order. From and : .
Third order. Then and , so .
Fourth order. Now and . Substituting,
(Throughout, “” is as , and the rules , follow at once from the definition in §98.) This is the beginning of the reversion of a power series.
is upper semi-continuous at if, for every , for all in some interval round . Prove that a function upper semi-continuous at every point of is bounded above there and attains its upper bound.
Hint
Hint
Solution
Bounded above. Put if is bounded above on . Upper semi-continuity at (with ) gives on some , so contains points beyond . If were not bounded above on , the classes and would form a section with number . Semi-continuity at gives on ; is bounded above on (as ), hence on , contradicting the definition of (if , on itself). So is bounded above; let be its upper bound.
Attained. Suppose for all . Then is defined and positive on , and it is unbounded above, since takes arbitrarily small positive values. But is upper semi-continuous: at a point , let and ; choose with so small that . Semi-continuity of gives , i.e. , near ; hence there. By the first part is bounded above: a contradiction. So for some .
The lower semi-continuous case ( near ) gives an attained lower bound in the same way, and a function that is both upper and lower semi-continuous at a point is continuous there. A standard example: is upper semi-continuous (its value at each jump is the larger one-sided limit) and attains its maximum on every .