Chapter V · §§90–110

Limits of functions of a continuous variable. Continuous and discontinuous functions

Limits as x tends to infinity or to a point, one-sided limits, continuity and the many ways it can fail, and the great theorems about continuous functions on a closed interval: they take every intermediate value, are bounded, attain their bounds and are uniformly continuous. The chapter ends with continuity in two variables and with implicit and inverse functions.

What you will be able to do

  • prove limits at a point, and one-sided limits, with epsilon and delta
  • classify discontinuities as simple, infinities or oscillatory
  • use the intermediate value theorem and the theorem that a continuous function on a closed interval attains its bounds
  • explain the Heine–Borel theorem and why a continuous function on a closed interval is uniformly continuous
  • decide when an equation defines an implicit or inverse function

Start with “Limits as xx tends to ±∞\pm\infty” →

From sequences to functions

Chapter IV asked what happens to ϕ(n)\phi(n) as the whole number nn grows. Chapter V asks the same question for a function ϕ(x)\phi(x) of a real variable, and then asks a new one: what happens as xx approaches an ordinary point aa? The answer to the second question gives the precise meaning of continuity, and the second half of the chapter proves the great facts about continuous functions that the rest of the book (derivatives, integrals, the exponential and logarithm) uses without comment: they take every value between two of their values, they are bounded on a closed interval and attain their bounds, they have inverses when they are strictly monotone, and their oscillation can be made uniformly small.

Little in the first half will feel new if Chapter IV is fresh in your mind. Hardy says as much: the definitions are “practically repetitions” of the ones for sequences. What is new is the second quantifier pair. For a limit at a point you must say how close xx has to be to aa, not how far along a sequence to go, and the condition “x≠ax \ne a” is part of the definition.

The chapter in four stages

  1. Limits of a continuous variable (§§90–98). Limits as x→±∞x \to \pm\infty, as x→ax \to a and from one side; the algebra of limits; why a limit at aa says nothing about the value at aa; the standard limit (sin⁡x)/x→1(\sin x)/x \to 1; orders of smallness with OO, oo and ∼\sim.
  2. Continuity (§§99–100). The definition, its picture as a band and a strip, the continuity of the familiar functions, and a classification of the ways continuity can fail.
  3. Continuous functions on an interval (§§101–107). The intermediate value theorem; boundedness and the attainment of bounds; the oscillation of a function in an interval; the Heine–Borel theorem and its consequence, that a continuous function on a closed interval is uniformly continuous.
  4. Several variables, implicit and inverse functions (§§108–110). Continuity in two variables, and why it is more than continuity in each variable separately; when an equation f(x,y)=0f(x, y) = 0 really defines yy as a continuous function of xx; inverse functions.

How to work through it

  • Hardy writes δ\delta for the tolerance on the values and ϵ\epsilon for the closeness of xx to aa. Modern books do the opposite. These lessons follow the modern convention from the second lesson on and point out the swap each time it matters; see the notation guide.
  • Stage 3 is the heart of the chapter. Each proof there is one of three arguments: a Dedekind section (take the least upper bound of the points where something good happens), repeated bisection, or a finite cover. Notice which one is being used and why it needs a closed interval.
  • The interactive figures are there to be broken. Most theorems in this chapter become false when one hypothesis is dropped, and the widgets let you see exactly where.

Lessons

11 pages · about 420 minutes of reading, plus time with the book.

  1. §§90–92 Limits as xx tends to ±∞\pm\infty ✓ done How the definitions of Chapter IV carry over from ϕ(n)\phi(n) to a function ϕ(x)\phi(x) of a real variable as x→∞x \to \infty or x→−∞x \to -\infty, and the one thing that changes.
  2. §§93–95 Limits as xx tends to a point ✓ done What lim⁡x→aϕ(x)=l\lim_{x\to a}\phi(x) = l means, the limits from the right and from the left, and why a monotone function always has both.
  3. §§96–97 Limits and values ✓ done Computing limits at a point with the algebra of limits and the squeeze, why “just put x=ax = a” is not a proof, and the standard limit (sin⁡x)/x→1(\sin x)/x \to 1.
  4. §98 Orders of smallness and greatness ✓ done Comparing how fast functions tend to 00 or ∞\infty with OO, oo and ∼\sim, and measuring the speed against the scale x,x2,x3,…x, x^2, x^3, \dots
  5. §§99–100 Continuous and discontinuous functions ✓ done The definition of continuity at a point, its picture as a band and a strip, the continuity of the familiar functions, and Hardy’s classification of discontinuities.
  6. §§101–102 The intermediate value theorem ✓ done A continuous function takes every value between any two of its values; Hardy’s proof by a Dedekind section, the bisection proof, why the converse fails, and the persistence of sign.
  7. §§103–105 Continuous functions are bounded and attain their bounds ✓ done On a closed interval a continuous function is bounded and takes its greatest and least values; three proofs, the oscillation of a function in an interval, and why each hypothesis is needed.
  8. §§106–107 The Heine–Borel theorem and uniform continuity ✓ done From infinitely many local facts to one global fact; covering a closed interval by finitely many intervals, and why the oscillation of a continuous function can be made small uniformly.
  9. §108 Continuous functions of two variables ✓ done What continuity of ϕ(x,y)\phi(x, y) at a point means, and why it says much more than continuity in xx and in yy separately.
  10. §§109–110 Implicit and inverse functions ✓ done When an equation f(x,y)=0f(x, y) = 0 really defines yy as a continuous function of xx, and why a continuous strictly monotone function has a continuous inverse.
  11. Problems Chapter V problems ✓ done Eleven of Hardy’s Miscellaneous Examples on Chapter V, on limits, orders of smallness, continuity, monotone and inverse functions, with graded hints and full solutions.