Chapter IX · The logarithmic, exponential and circular functions of a real variable

The number ee

§211 25 min

ee is the number whose logarithm is 11, the point where the area under 1/t1/t reaches one unit; and log⁡ey=y\log e^y = y for every rational yy.

Why this matters

In Chapter IV Hardy met a number he provisionally called ee, the limit of (1+1/n)n(1 + 1/n)^n. Here it gets its real definition: ee is where the logarithm reaches 11. This makes ee the natural base for powers, because log⁡ey=y\log e^y = y (at least for rational yy), and it is the step that leads in the next lesson to the exponential function. That this ee is the same as the limit of Chapter IV is proved in §215.

The idea

The area under y=1/ty = 1/t starting from t=1t = 1 grows steadily and without bound. So there is exactly one place where it has reached one unit of area. That place is ee.

Explore Find the point where the area is exactly 1

Try this. Drag xx (or use the slider) until the area from 11 to xx is 11. The readout turns green when you are within 0.0040.004.

log⁡x=∫1xdtt\log x = \int_1^x \frac{dt}{t}
t1/t
  • y = 1/t
  • area from 1 to x
  • x (drag)
Area from 1 to x=2x = 2 is 0.69310.6931. Too little area: move x to the right.
What to notice

The point lies between 2.72.7 and 2.752.75, at e=2.71828…e = 2.71828\ldots. Notice how insensitive the area is to xx there: the strip you add has height only about 1/e≈0.371/e \approx 0.37, so moving xx by 0.010.01 changes the area by only 0.00370.0037.

How can we be sure that 2<e<32 < e < 3 without a calculator? Area estimates. Over [1,2][1, 2] the curve lies below height 11, so log⁡2<1\log 2 < 1 and ee is beyond 22. To show e<3e < 3 we need log⁡3>1\log 3 > 1, an area lower bound, and lower Riemann sums give one.

Explore Prove log⁡3>1\log 3 > 1 with rectangles

Try this. This shows the lower sum for 1/t1/t on [1,3][1, 3]. Start with n=2n = 2 and double nn until the lower sum exceeds 11.

∫131x dx\int_{1}^{3} \frac1x\,dx, lower rule with n=2n = 2
xy
  • y = f(x)
  • pieces above the axis count +
  • below the axis count −
Rule
Lower sum S2=0.833333S_{2} = 0.833333; exact value 1.098611.09861; error −0.265-0.265 (refine and watch how fast it shrinks).
What to notice

With 22 strips the lower sum is 12+13≈0.83\tfrac12 + \tfrac13 \approx 0.83, and with 44 it is 0.950.95: not enough. With 88 strips it is 1.0199>11.0199 > 1. Since the true area exceeds every lower sum, log⁡3>1\log 3 > 1, hence e<3e < 3. A finite computation proves an inequality about an irrational number.

Precise statements

Definition The number ee Hardy: §211

ee is the number whose logarithm is 11:

log⁡e=∫1edtt=1.\log e = \int_1^e \frac{dt}{t} = 1 .
Theorem ee is well defined, and 2<e<32 < e < 3 Hardy: §211

There is exactly one positive number xx with log⁡x=1\log x = 1. It satisfies 2<e<32 < e < 3.

Theorem Logarithms of rational powers of ee Hardy: §211 (1), (2)

For every rational yy, if eye^y denotes the positive yy-th power of ee, then

log⁡ey=y.\log e^{y} = y .

So, for rational yy and positive xx, the two equations y=log⁡xy = \log x and x=eyx = e^y say the same thing.

For irrational yy the symbol eye^y has not been given any meaning yet. That gap is closed in the next lesson.

Proofs

Proof ee exists and is unique
Strategy

log⁡\log is continuous and strictly increasing, it is 00 at x=1x = 1 and exceeds 11 somewhere. The intermediate value theorem gives a solution of log⁡x=1\log x = 1; strict monotonicity makes it unique.

log⁡\log takes a value larger than 11

log⁡x→∞\log x \to \infty (lesson 1), so some XX has log⁡X>1\log X > 1. (Concretely X=3X = 3, proved below.)

Existence

log⁡\log is continuous on [1,X][1, X] with log⁡1=0<1<log⁡X\log 1 = 0 < 1 < \log X. By the intermediate value theorem (§101) there is ee in (1,X)(1, X) with log⁡e=1\log e = 1.

Uniqueness

If x1<x2x_1 < x_2 then log⁡x1<log⁡x2\log x_1 < \log x_2, so log⁡\log takes each value at most once. Hardy says: it is increasing “in the stricter sense”, so it “can only pass once through the value 1”.

Proof 2<e<32 < e < 3
Strategy

Show log⁡2<1<log⁡3\log 2 < 1 < \log 3; since log⁡\log is increasing, ee lies between 22 and 33. The first is a rectangle bound. For the second, Hardy folds [1,3][1, 3] around t=2t = 2.

log⁡2<1\log 2 < 1

On (1,2)(1, 2), 1/t<11/t < 1, so ∫12dt/t<1\int_1^2 dt/t < 1. Hence log⁡2<log⁡e\log 2 < \log e, and 2<e2 < e.

Fold [1,3][1, 3] about t=2t = 2

Put t=2−ut = 2 - u on [1,2][1, 2] and t=2+ut = 2 + u on [2,3][2, 3]; in both, uu runs over [0,1][0, 1]:

∫13dtt=∫01du2−u+∫01du2+u=∫014 du4−u2.\int_1^3 \frac{dt}{t} = \int_0^1 \frac{du}{2-u} + \int_0^1 \frac{du}{2+u} = \int_0^1 \frac{4\,du}{4 - u^2}.

The integrand exceeds 11

For 0<u≤10 < u \le 1, 4−u2<44 - u^2 < 4, so 44−u2>1\dfrac{4}{4 - u^2} > 1. Hence log⁡3>∫01du=1=log⁡e\log 3 > \int_0^1 du = 1 = \log e, and e<3e < 3.

The folding trick pairs the tall part of the curve near t=1t = 1 with the low part near t=3t = 3; their average height, 12(12−u+12+u)=24−u2\frac12\left(\frac{1}{2-u} + \frac{1}{2+u}\right) = \frac{2}{4-u^2}, is always at least 12\frac12, the height of the curve at the midpoint t=2t = 2. This is convexity again, as in the exercise on log⁡x+1x\log\frac{x+1}{x} in the previous lesson.

Proof log⁡ey=y\log e^y = y for rational yy
Strategy

Use log⁡xr=rlog⁡x\log x^r = r\log x for rational rr (previous lesson) with x=ex = e, and log⁡e=1\log e = 1.

Positive integers

log⁡en=log⁡(e⋅e⋯e)=nlog⁡e=n\log e^n = \log(e \cdot e \cdots e) = n\log e = n.

Positive rationals p/qp/q

Let z=ep/qz = e^{p/q}, the positive qq-th root of epe^p. Then zq=epz^q = e^p, so qlog⁡z=log⁡ep=pq\log z = \log e^p = p, and log⁡z=p/q\log z = p/q.

Zero and negative rationals

log⁡e0=log⁡1=0\log e^0 = \log 1 = 0, and log⁡e−y=log⁡(1/ey)=−log⁡ey=−y\log e^{-y} = \log(1/e^y) = -\log e^y = -y.

The two equations are equivalent

If x=eyx = e^y then log⁡x=y\log x = y, as just shown. Conversely, if log⁡x=y\log x = y, then log⁡x=log⁡ey\log x = \log e^y, and since log⁡\log is one-to-one, x=eyx = e^y.

Worked examples and exercises

Exercise A cruder bound ●○○ Hardy: §211

Show that e<4e < 4 using the lower sum for ∫14dt/t\int_1^4 dt/t with three strips of width 11.

Hint
On [k,k+1][k, k+1] the smallest value of 1/t1/t is 1/(k+1)1/(k+1).

Solution

The lower sum is 12+13+14=1312>1\frac12 + \frac13 + \frac14 = \frac{13}{12} > 1. The area exceeds the lower sum, so log⁡4>1=log⁡e\log 4 > 1 = \log e, and e<4e < 4. (With the same idea, the lower sum on [1,n][1, n] is 12+⋯+1n\frac12 + \dots + \frac1n, so log⁡n>12+13+⋯+1n\log n > \frac12 + \frac13 + \dots + \frac1n, the comparison behind the integral test in §218.)

Exercise A sharper bound ●●○ Hardy: §211; Examples LXXXIII, 2 (v)

Using log⁡x+1x>22x+1\log\dfrac{x+1}{x} > \dfrac{2}{2x+1} (previous lesson) with x=1x = 1, show that e<22≈2.83e < 2\sqrt2 \approx 2.83.

Hint
The inequality gives a lower bound for log⁡2\log 2. Which power of 22 has logarithm greater than 11?

Solution

With x=1x = 1: log⁡2>23\log 2 > \frac23. Then log⁡23/2=32log⁡2>1=log⁡e\log 2^{3/2} = \frac32\log 2 > 1 = \log e, and since log⁡\log is increasing, e<23/2=22=2.828…e < 2^{3/2} = 2\sqrt 2 = 2.828\ldots. (Here 23/22^{3/2} is the positive square root of 88, a rational power, and log⁡23/2=32log⁡2\log 2^{3/2} = \frac32\log 2 by the corollary of the previous lesson.)

Exercise ●○○ Hardy: §211

Without computing ee, find log⁡e\log\sqrt e, log⁡(1/e2)\log(1/e^2), log⁡(e3e3)\log(e^3\sqrt[3]{e}) and the positive xx with log⁡x=−32\log x = -\tfrac32.

Hint
log⁡ey=y\log e^y = y for rational yy.

Solution

log⁡e=log⁡e1/2=12\log\sqrt e = \log e^{1/2} = \tfrac12. log⁡(1/e2)=log⁡e−2=−2\log(1/e^2) = \log e^{-2} = -2. log⁡(e3e1/3)=log⁡e10/3=103\log(e^3 e^{1/3}) = \log e^{10/3} = \tfrac{10}{3}. And log⁡x=−32\log x = -\tfrac32 exactly when x=e−3/2=1/e3x = e^{-3/2} = 1/\sqrt{e^3}.

Exercise Locating ee more closely ●●○ Hardy: §211

Using log⁡2=0.6931\log 2 = 0.6931 and log⁡3=1.0986\log 3 = 1.0986, show that 2.7<e<2.752.7 < e < 2.75.

Hint
2.7=27/102.7 = 27/10 and 2.75=11/42.75 = 11/4. You will need log⁡5\log 5 or log⁡11\log 11; bound the one you need with the basic inequality log⁡x<x−1\log x < x - 1 applied to a ratio close to 11.

Solution

e>2.7e > 2.7. We need log⁡2.7<1\log 2.7 < 1. Now log⁡2.7=log⁡2710=3log⁡3−log⁡10\log 2.7 = \log\frac{27}{10} = 3\log 3 - \log 10, and log⁡10=log⁡2+log⁡5\log 10 = \log 2 + \log 5. To bound log⁡5\log 5 from below, use log⁡5=log⁡4+log⁡54=2log⁡2+log⁡54\log 5 = \log 4 + \log\frac54 = 2\log 2 + \log\frac54 and log⁡54>5/4−15/4=15\log\frac54 > \frac{5/4 - 1}{5/4} = \frac15. So log⁡5>1.3862+0.2=1.5862\log 5 > 1.3862 + 0.2 = 1.5862 and log⁡10>2.2793\log 10 > 2.2793. Hence log⁡2.7<3.2958−2.2793=1.0165\log 2.7 < 3.2958 - 2.2793 = 1.0165. That is not yet below 11, so use a better bound: log⁡54>22⋅4+1=29=0.2222\log\frac54 > \frac{2}{2\cdot 4 + 1} = \frac29 = 0.2222 (from log⁡x+1x>22x+1\log\frac{x+1}{x} > \frac{2}{2x+1} with x=4x = 4). Then log⁡10>1.3862+0.2222+0.6931=2.3015\log 10 > 1.3862 + 0.2222 + 0.6931 = 2.3015 and log⁡2.7<3.2958−2.3015=0.9943<1\log 2.7 < 3.2958 - 2.3015 = 0.9943 < 1. So e>2.7e > 2.7.

e<2.75e < 2.75. We need log⁡114>1\log\frac{11}{4} > 1. Now log⁡114=log⁡3−log⁡1211=1.0986−log⁡1211\log\frac{11}{4} = \log 3 - \log\frac{12}{11} = 1.0986 - \log\frac{12}{11}, and log⁡1211<1211−1=111=0.0909\log\frac{12}{11} < \frac{12}{11} - 1 = \frac1{11} = 0.0909. So log⁡114>1.0986−0.0909=1.0077>1\log\frac{11}{4} > 1.0986 - 0.0909 = 1.0077 > 1, and e<2.75e < 2.75.

(The given values are rounded; a careful version would use bounds such as 0.69314<log⁡2<0.693150.69314 < \log 2 < 0.69315, but the margins above are large enough not to matter.)

Check yourself

Check yourself Choose one

Why is there only one number xx with log⁡x=1\log x = 1?

Why

Continuity and log⁡x→∞\log x \to \infty give existence (intermediate value theorem). Uniqueness needs that log⁡\log never takes a value twice, which follows from strict increase (derivative 1/x>01/x > 0). A continuous function can take the value 11 many times.

Check yourself Enter a number

What is the lower sum for ∫13dt/t\int_1^3 dt/t with 44 strips of width 12\tfrac12?

Why

12(11.5+12+12.5+13)=12(0.6667+0.5+0.4+0.3333)=0.95\tfrac12\left(\tfrac1{1.5} + \tfrac12 + \tfrac1{2.5} + \tfrac13\right) = \tfrac12(0.6667 + 0.5 + 0.4 + 0.3333) = 0.95. Less than 11, so 44 strips do not prove e<3e < 3; 88 strips do.

Check yourself True or false?

At this point in Hardy’s development (end of §211), e2e^{\sqrt 2} has a meaning.

Why

False. So far eye^y means the positive yy-th power of ee, which requires yy rational (ep/q=epqe^{p/q} = \sqrt[q]{e^p}). The next section defines eye^y for every real yy as the inverse of the logarithm, and it agrees with the old meaning when yy is rational.

Hardy’s language

Summary

Summary
  • ee is defined by log⁡e=1\log e = 1: the point where the area under 1/t1/t from 11 reaches one unit.
  • It exists by the intermediate value theorem and is unique because log⁡\log is strictly increasing.
  • Area bounds pin it down: log⁡2<1<log⁡3\log 2 < 1 < \log 3 gives 2<e<32 < e < 3; finer bounds give 2.7<e<2.752.7 < e < 2.75.
  • For rational yy, log⁡ey=y\log e^y = y; so y=log⁡xy = \log x and x=eyx = e^y are equivalent. Irrational powers are still undefined.