Chapter IX · The logarithmic, exponential and circular functions of a real variable
The number
is the number whose logarithm is , the point where the area under reaches one unit; and for every rational .
Why this matters
In Chapter IV Hardy met a number he provisionally called , the limit of . Here it gets its real definition: is where the logarithm reaches . This makes the natural base for powers, because (at least for rational ), and it is the step that leads in the next lesson to the exponential function. That this is the same as the limit of Chapter IV is proved in §215.
The idea
The area under starting from grows steadily and without bound. So there is exactly one place where it has reached one unit of area. That place is .
Try this. Drag (or use the slider) until the area from to is . The readout turns green when you are within .
- y = 1/t
- area from 1 to x
- x (drag)
What to notice
The point lies between and , at . Notice how insensitive the area is to there: the strip you add has height only about , so moving by changes the area by only .
How can we be sure that without a calculator? Area estimates. Over the curve lies below height , so and is beyond . To show we need , an area lower bound, and lower Riemann sums give one.
Try this. This shows the lower sum for on . Start with and double until the lower sum exceeds .
- y = f(x)
- pieces above the axis count +
- below the axis count −
What to notice
With strips the lower sum is , and with it is : not enough. With strips it is . Since the true area exceeds every lower sum, , hence . A finite computation proves an inequality about an irrational number.
Precise statements
is the number whose logarithm is :
There is exactly one positive number with . It satisfies .
For every rational , if denotes the positive -th power of , then
So, for rational and positive , the two equations and say the same thing.
For irrational the symbol has not been given any meaning yet. That gap is closed in the next lesson.
Proofs
is continuous and strictly increasing, it is at and exceeds somewhere. The intermediate value theorem gives a solution of ; strict monotonicity makes it unique.
takes a value larger than
(lesson 1), so some has . (Concretely , proved below.)
Existence
is continuous on with . By the intermediate value theorem (§101) there is in with .
Uniqueness
If then , so takes each value at most once. Hardy says: it is increasing “in the stricter sense”, so it “can only pass once through the value 1”.
Show ; since is increasing, lies between and . The first is a rectangle bound. For the second, Hardy folds around .
On , , so . Hence , and .
Fold about
Put on and on ; in both, runs over :
The integrand exceeds
For , , so . Hence , and .
The folding trick pairs the tall part of the curve near with the low part near ; their average height, , is always at least , the height of the curve at the midpoint . This is convexity again, as in the exercise on in the previous lesson.
Use for rational (previous lesson) with , and .
Positive integers
.
Positive rationals
Let , the positive -th root of . Then , so , and .
Zero and negative rationals
, and .
The two equations are equivalent
If then , as just shown. Conversely, if , then , and since is one-to-one, .
Worked examples and exercises
Show that using the lower sum for with three strips of width .
Hint
Solution
The lower sum is . The area exceeds the lower sum, so , and . (With the same idea, the lower sum on is , so , the comparison behind the integral test in §218.)
Using (previous lesson) with , show that .
Hint
Solution
With : . Then , and since is increasing, . (Here is the positive square root of , a rational power, and by the corollary of the previous lesson.)
Without computing , find , , and the positive with .
Hint
Solution
. . . And exactly when .
Using and , show that .
Hint
Solution
. We need . Now , and . To bound from below, use and . So and . Hence . That is not yet below , so use a better bound: (from with ). Then and . So .
. We need . Now , and . So , and .
(The given values are rounded; a careful version would use bounds such as , but the margins above are large enough not to matter.)
Check yourself
Why is there only one number with ?
Continuity and give existence (intermediate value theorem). Uniqueness needs that never takes a value twice, which follows from strict increase (derivative ). A continuous function can take the value many times.
What is the lower sum for with strips of width ?
. Less than , so strips do not prove ; strips do.
At this point in Hardy’s development (end of §211), has a meaning.
False. So far means the positive -th power of , which requires rational (). The next section defines for every real as the inverse of the logarithm, and it agrees with the old meaning when is rational.
Hardy’s language
Summary
- is defined by : the point where the area under from reaches one unit.
- It exists by the intermediate value theorem and is unique because is strictly increasing.
- Area bounds pin it down: gives ; finer bounds give .
- For rational , ; so and are equivalent. Irrational powers are still undefined.