Appendices

Appendices

Four short appendices: the inequalities of Hölder and Minkowski, two proofs that every algebraic equation has a root, double limits and when their order matters, and the difference between the infinite of analysis and the infinite of geometry.

What you will be able to do

  • prove the general theorem of the means, Hölder's inequality and Minkowski's inequality, and say when equality holds
  • follow two proofs of the fundamental theorem of algebra: by the winding of the image of a square, and by the least value of |f(z)|
  • recognise when two limiting operations may be interchanged, and produce counter-examples when they may not
  • explain why the line at infinity of projective geometry is an actual object, while the ∞ of analysis is only part of a phrase

Start with “The inequalities of Hölder and Minkowski” →

Why the appendices are worth reading

Hardy’s appendices are short and dense. Each picks up a thread that the main text left hanging: an inequality proved only for rational exponents, a theorem about polynomials that was quoted but never proved, a habit (swapping two limits) that the book has used quietly several times, and a word (“infinity”) that means one thing in analysis and something quite different in geometry. None of them is needed to follow the ten chapters, but each one changes how you see something in them.

The appendices have no numbered sections, so the lessons here are labelled “Appendix I” to “Appendix IV”. Each lesson names the sections of the main text it grows out of (for example §74 for Appendix I, where Hardy first mentions it), so that you know where to look in the book.

The four appendices

  1. The inequalities of Hölder and Minkowski (Appendix I; grows out of §74). The theorem of the arithmetic and geometric means with arbitrary real weights, proved by the mean value theorem or by the concavity of log⁡x\log x, and then the two inequalities that make (∑ak)1/k\left(\sum a^k\right)^{1/k} behave like a length. Needs: §74, the mean value theorem (§126), and xαx^\alpha for real α\alpha (§214).
  2. Every equation has a root (Appendix II, two lessons). The fundamental theorem of algebra, proved twice. Proof A follows the winding of the image of a square and traps a root in a shrinking chain of squares; proof B finds the point where ∣f(z)∣|f(z)| is least and shows that, unless it is 00, one could go lower. Needs: complex numbers (Ch. III), continuous functions and their bounds (§§103–108), and the argument of a complex number followed continuously (Ch. X).
  3. Double limit problems (Appendix III; grows out of §220). Integrating a series term by term, differentiating it term by term, or letting x→ξx \to \xi inside a sum all swap two limiting processes. Sometimes that is harmless and sometimes it is false; the lesson collects counter-examples you can see as grids of numbers.
  4. The infinite in analysis and geometry (Appendix IV). In analysis "→∞\to \infty" is only part of a phrase; in projective geometry the line at infinity is as real as any other line. Homogeneous coordinates show how both pictures fit together.

How to read them

  • Appendix I and III are the most useful in later mathematics: Hölder and Minkowski are the basic inequalities of the ℓp\ell^p and LpL^p spaces, and the double-limit question becomes the theory of uniform convergence.
  • In Appendix II, read proof A with the winding widget open: the whole argument is the picture. Proof B is the shorter one and the one most textbooks give.
  • Appendix IV is a short essay rather than a piece of mathematics. Read it after Chapter IV, when "ϕ(n)→∞\phi(n) \to \infty" has become familiar, and the contrast will be clear.

Lessons

5 pages · about 200 minutes of reading, plus time with the book.

  1. App. I The inequalities of Hölder and Minkowski ✓ done Appendix I: the theorem of the means with real weights, and the two inequalities that turn (∑ak)1/k\left(\sum a^k\right)^{1/k} into a length.
  2. App. II Every equation has a root: the winding proof ✓ done Appendix II, proof (A): follow the image of a square under ff, count how often it winds round 00, and trap a root in a chain of shrinking squares.
  3. App. II Every equation has a root: the least value of ∣f(z)∣|f(z)| ✓ done Appendix II, proof (B): ∣f(z)∣|f(z)| attains a least value, and at a point where f≠0f \ne 0 one can always go lower, so the least value is 00.
  4. App. III Double limit problems ✓ done Appendix III: integrating or differentiating a series term by term, or letting x→ξx \to \xi inside a sum, swaps two limits; the order can matter.
  5. App. IV The infinite in analysis and geometry ✓ done Appendix IV: in analysis ∞\infty is only part of a phrase; in homogeneous geometry the points and the line at infinity are as real as any others.